heavyanalytics.com aasoc.pl buy metronidazole for dogs without prescription in uk doe topamax 25 mg get you high webafest.com.au cytotec chiriqui accutane 5 mg per day result stopping lipitor para que sirve ciprofloxacin cr 500 can you eat lobster coumadin a45 antibiotics wat r some of the illness it cures bactrim for guinea pig uti formulation of antibiotic eye drop wikipedia stabilanol fluconazole 100mg dctourguideonline.com how much is montelukast to buy in the uk whats the price of metronidazole bangkok does 215 gabapentin work for migraine does 10mg propranolol work for tremors can i take antacid with lexapro ativan flagyl metronidazole ebay ketoconazole mouthwash weed and levitra debtspecialistcentre.com drugs.co bupropion stop cold turkey linezolid and fentanyl interaction zyvox dosage mrsa does metronidazole 500mg kill intestimal parasites lexapro 3 weeks after increase lbc4help.org how long is nolvadex good can fluconazole tablet help oral thrush how can you not gain weight when taking lexapro herbal viagra online vicodin erectile dysfunction lamisil terbinafine spray accutane 1 month erythromycin tablet used in chiken pox treatment thesoundalarm.com coumadin level 6.1 michalchrzanowski.com cymbalta price canada wellbutrin and tremors azithromycin tablets usp 250 mg for chlamydia accutane works within 2 weeks aasoc.pl tetracycline antibiotic australia onlywebs.us gkris.com waterfrontalehouse.com 2exhibitions.com who has taken prometrium 400 mg to induce period flagyl 400mg dosage in pregnancy doumsystems.com costo de lexapro 10 mg does bactrim and zantac interact do my husband need viagra viagra cheap now nizoral shampoo price in hong kong vardenafil tablets 20mg availble in ambattur captopril sublingual average street value of 100 mg zoloft revue-pto.com 75 mg sertraline does it help attention lasix tablets used for dogs side effects parmaciboevino.com seroquel xr 150 mg side effects clonidine hydrochloride 25mg chloramphenicol capsule 500 mg dosage generic cialis no prescription canada difference between zithromax and ciplox beer and bactrim ds cialis nota 75 para q sirve terbinafine 250 mg tab cam raloxifene uk buy floraphotographs.com levalbuterol tartrate side effects xenical urinary infections brown discharge while on prometrium status of plavix lawsuit buy arimidex cheap learninc.org apa itu benzoyl metronidazole can my 3 year old take amoxicillin an tylanol together q2melbourne.com is voltaren max gel polish zofran recreational use atorvastatin calcium 20mg price paroxetine 20mg reviews ciprofloxacin 500mg 3 days usian.org cara pakai diflucan buildingsonfire.com ubat singulair 10mg how long does buspirone last cialis and tamsulosin and finasteride combination baclofen foro amitriptyline mg overdose goldmax viagra for women canada dapoxetine priligy philippines how many days i can give phenergan syrup to my baby azithromycin 5 day dose pack medication dapoxetine hydrochloride for sale buy levitra thailand zoloft and breast milk supply why shoulg you not eat ice cream after taking viagra provera acetate regulates periods glimepiride accord 3mg dutasteride uk muscle buy cheap viagra online from india clavodar amoxicillin 400 periactin tabletas engorda fehmierduran.com metformin rash acyclovir 200 mg capsule. dose it cure gentil wards alexcitypr.com spider bite spain antibiotic increasing from 25 to 50mg clomid men nyscaa.org where to buy misoprostol over the counter in kenya generic india viagra how much synthroid to lose weight does wellbutrin sr cause euphoria synthroid 88 mcg equivalencia para armour cipro with flagyl for bacterial vaginitis montelukast 10mg levocetirizine dihydrochloride 5 mg berenboom.com can green tea help with weight while taking remeron amoxicillin 875 root canal receta para misoprostol en pilar buenos aires citalopram 30 mg aiuta glimepiride adalah deserteichler.com cheapest generic accutane acne.org clubdeayudaauditiva.com side effects of cital and levofloxacin medroxyprogesterone 60 mg 20 milligrams prozac every other day azithromycin 200mg side effects cardaffairs.com estradiol tablet buy interaction levothyroxine ortho tri cyclen amitriptyline cost per pill viagra vega 100 djelovanje stesolid och atarax strausser.com beribak.com amoxicillin side effects chest pain dws-xip.pl interaksi lipitor dan digoxin am1320.com olanzapine 2.5 mg half life champion-container.com buy clomiphene citrate canada withdraw of escitalopram depression tabs para q sirven las pastillas anafranil de 75mg blueberry erectile dysfunction haciendahotel-oldtown.com trazodone for pain relief 10mg how long does lexapro sweating last azithromycin tablets cost in india can cytotec abort 3 months of gestation seadoo-maldives.com ansbach-direkt.de multi-monety.pl misoprostolcytotec in south africa furosemide metformin digoxinmetoprolol interactions gevolgen overdosis cymbalta metformin eye problems interaccion nifedipino captopril denimandlace.ca how much amoxicillin should be given to a 5 year old preatoni.ae apakaz.org does citalopram make you last longer prozac 40 mg high order ivermectin tablets for humans pria.it metoprolol 25 mg prospect generic lasix india minimania.cz lamisil tabletin yan etkileri me puedo intoxicar con misoprostol caducado the price of flagyl in kenya prozac etkileri bupropion hydrochloride 100mg side effects will lisinopril get you high misoprostol alone for 2weeks pregnancy why does levitra help me last longer is amoxicillin trihydarate safe for first trimester doxycycline monohydrate jerawat trazodone 1500 mg para que serve interactions thyroxine 25 mg zinc does clomid for fertility come in a liquid starting femara on day 4 avvsagradafamilia.net happyknits.com uso para furosemide businesscreditpro.com prednisone dosage for dog hotspot viagra netherlands prescription lawonline.co.il berenboom.com clozaril sandoz pi prednisone taper schedule 60 mg urticaria treatment mifepristone e misoprostol para abortar prednisone for asthma over the counter paroxetine withdrawal rls antiviral drugs walmart initiativemobileinsights.com how many mg of sertraline does it take to get high can paxil cause blindness or hair loss flagyl pills for sale adega.info can u take voltaren with methadone order lamisil pills septran tablet for acne skin levofloxacin other drugs in same class prozac 20 mg for anxiety apo naproxen 500mg side effects buy accutane online cost generic lowest price viagra zithromax pack philippines minimania.cz quitting zoloft after 3 months fluconazole for eczema price philippines zovirax for plantar warts flagyl price walgreens no insurance 150gm viagra tofranil pm price azascd.org can ginkgo biloba taken with lisinopril 10 mgs how much does strattera cost for 30 days supply bizconst.org lamisil spray in india revue-pto.com singulair price ireland lasix online bestellen mobilfodral.net buspirone high 555 how long does it take to effect you deserteichler.com alendronate 70 mg cost menarini dapoxetine where to purchase singulair merck discount card erythromycin pills sale lifebychristian.com bactrim sulfametoxazol y trimetoprima celexa and abnormal liver functions generic ivermectin pour on can sandoz bupropion 150 sr tablets be divided for use buildingsonfire.com what the street pricing for hydroxyzine 50 mg mirtazapine online te koop does metronidazole need refrigerated high off singulair 3 estrogens how much does fluoxetine cost short term prednisone taper for dogs remeron increase testosterone wellbutrin 150 mg xl how to shoot danocrine efek samping amoxicillin treatment for toothache drink every buy trazodone online sertraline 300 caverta generic veega viagra viagra outlet in west bengal mobile-pharma.com stem.neu.edu buspar frequent side effects septra dosage for staph infection buspar prozac klonopin trazodone olanzapine arab ncsdsample2.docbro.com orlistat 120mg reviews uk take zoloft for 6 months newworldfoods.ca katartisi-pnai.gr serophene 2 comprimidos dia buildingsonfire.com medicamentos con verapamil kegunaan levofloxacin 500 quien me vende 4 pastillas cytotec venezuela generic sinequan jwalkny.com champion-container.com is ketoconazole hydrocortisone for ringworm scalp mightyrabbitstudios.com ciprodex eye drops south africa 7xianyuan.com rf5.org gratisdiscotecas.com webworksandgraphics.com coparmex.org.mx erythromycin gel philippines price torontoems.ca cat vomiting withrawal prednisone eu-atp.org solubility of topiramate can i take meloxicam with cialis augmentin devo tablet metformin 500mg bloating pcos side effects of too much metformin blakesgourmet.com hpw much does 20mg of lexapro cost fehmierduran.com thisisjacobriddle.com esporaeventosycomunicacion.com what is prednisone used for dogs flagyl 400 can cure bad breath levofloxacin 500 mg for sinus infection wilbraham.com is there a generic version of plavix 75mg tabletsr cabinetsbydesignsarasota.com bactrim 800 mg pre?§o clomiphene citrate dosage for low testerone in men tension tablet inderal10mg should i give my dog furosemide on an empty stomach double strength bactrim twitching side effects does anti depresant get you high is augmentin duo forte good for acne celexa 10 mg effective plavix 10 mg ahmeterhan.com can you take gaba and celexa periactin uk pharmacy asiliahomehealth.com mobilestoreoperators.com backboneitgroup.com proscar diviso 4 funziona efek samping tineuron gabapentin 300 mg digitalmaniacpro.com 6 cytotec for 8weeks pregnant iaspm2013.espora.es abundantgraceandcharm.com how much does meloxicam cost xenical orlistat price in pune amoxicillin kucing gauntletpress.com beach on celebrex commercial zofran side effects oculogyric can you mix cipro and amoxicillin augmentin together atenolol 50 mg tablet price cyproheptadine online can i take hydrocodone with generic plavix bridgehousemedia.com generic duloxetine reviews would flagyl help a gum infection zoloft stomach growling cuanto cuesta el micardis 30mg voltaren resinat instructiuni ile brac sildenafil 100 mg can i snort ic baclofen thyroxine sodium 100mcg used photoloco.com does ativan help with sertraline side effects ivermectin 12 mg cara minum obat 3 g amoxicillin when will the side effects of tamoxifen start westwoodhomesinc.com bactrim oral suspension piriton reaction with antibiotics how many lisinopril 20mg would it take to kill someone prednisone tabs for dogs otc 1001.org depo provera 8 days late grandlakehistory.org betaine and fluconazole generic cymbalta 60 mg reviews is lamisil better than than lotrimin for ringworm viagra pricing costco how many days of cipro for sinus mobic 15 mg usos acyclovir 800mg side effects erections inovaclub.com.mx newworldfoods.ca cyproheptadine hydrochloride ip 2mg kese le metformina glibe km-kh.com serum sickness azithromycin benicar generic for ed buy revatio 20 mg indicaciones de zyprexa zydis sublingual cialis black 800mg reviews is 20 mg buspar get you high turystykawinternecie.pl rwmeierlaw.com facial twitching prednisone dogs price for medication clonidine hcl 01 mg tablet hair loss and montelukast sod 10mg harga salep acyclovir carpetandfloors.co.uk cost eye ointment acyclovir linezolid injection package insert metformin glucophage 500mg levaquin side effects night sweats kikkaskitchen.com astakaryaindotama.com dirtbiker.cz does cialis come in pink tablet how much should prednisone cost chinatripadvisor.com why give atarax in labour withdrawal from paroxetine two weeks alendronate sodium tablets 70 mg side effects can i get viagra from a walk in klinic winnipeg buy piroxicam online arroyograndecc.com zofran odt cats digoxin sandoz 0.25mg can i take coreg with cipro accutane 2 months tabex ili zyban ciprofloxacin 250 for dog dosage ear infection colchicine 0.6 mg tab obat apa amoxicillin rash, uptodate does azithromycin interfere with depo canciprofloxacin 250mg be taken 6 hours apart fluconazole400 how many doser required penile thrush lexapro vs wellbutrin can men take buspar metoprolol demenz floraphotographs.com clozaril protocol quinine drug reactions with azithromycin and cefixime vibrancetech.net dctourguideonline.com take 500mg amoxicillin for syphilis stopping wellbutrin after 2 weeks how many mg fosamax prostate cancer generic cialis uk next day delivery ilosone generic name bt.sklep.pl nitroglycerin sr 2.5 mg dose in relation with meals can i take flagyl with orange juice how can i f ind generic atorvastatin calcium 5 mg launchpoker.com doxycycline brands in the philippines strattera lawsuits gyno atarax 10mg 5ml syrup acyclovir for impetigo wordsalamode.com does valtrex work for phn weani g iff lexapro weight tamoxifen 10 mg pct 1500 mg seroquel suizid alternative for augmentin 625 5x5.hu oral thrush diflucan didnt work magnificent.pl flomax dental considerations augmentin antibiotic in boots mobile-pharma.com singulair rebate menafilmfest.com plendil 20 mg zoloft reviews springracinginsights.com onlywebs.us lost weight on zoloft sweetcheekshq.com how much does maxalt cost panoramainternetu.pl amoxicillin 850 mg uses fexofenadine hydrochloride 60 mg dosage generic diovan hct ketoconazole kosten nederlands planned parenthood prescription valtrex sildenafil citrate zilden waterfrontalehouse.com duloxetine tmj lisinopril 80mg itchy throat when does cialis loose effect viagra in nederland km-kh.com soleaturk.com arimidex einnahmedauer learninc.org coparmex.org.mx deremerstudios.com celexa 10mg vs 20mg happyknits.com what is the effect of diovan on dogs research supply clomiphene edgewaterstudio.com bt.sklep.pl daisylcreations.com metoprolol interact with hibiscus flower dosage too low of zoloft online lexapro coumadin 15 accutane 80 mg 6 months can you get cytotec for ulcer over the counter in sa esomeprazole tri benh gi wilbraham.com weekly viagra content-catalyst.com wordsalamode.com generic plavix no prescription augmentin 725 acid reflux after lamisil

Rome's Zenit News

 Fecha: 2012-11-05

ROME, Nov. 5, 2012 (Zenit.org).- The following is an interview with Patrick H. Byrne, professor of Philosophy at Boston College on the life and works of famed theologian, Fr. Bernard Lonergan.

* * *

Q. A few days ago the fiftieth anniversary of the Second Vatican Council was celebrated. What were the ideas, suggestions and expectations of Fr. Lonergan for this epochal event in the history of the Church?

Byrne: Lonergan wrote two articles that touched upon the Second Vatican Council: “Existenz and Aggiornamento,” and “Pope John’s Intention.” In both articles Lonergan points out the purpose of Vatican II was pastoral. That the challenge was proclaiming the Good News in the cultural context of the modern world, a world that had changed greatly. So the great effort of his work was to offer an analysis of culture that would facilitate the carrying forward the mission of Vatican II. As his own contributions, he first distinguished between “classicism” and “modern culture.” He identified five defining features of classicism, and five corresponding changes that characterize modern culture. He developed his method in theology for the sake of communicating the faith to a culture that was no longer classicist, rather than trying to insist that modern culture accept the faith on classicist terms.

Q. His thought is a great contribution to the philosophical debate of our days. He tried to read the modern times in the light of the tradition and in the wake of S. Augustine, S. Thomas Aquinas, John Henry Newman and other contemporaries. It is not only a remarkable synthesis but a real step forward. How can his philosophy and theology be briefly described?

Byrne: Of course to describe Lonergan’s philosophy and theology briefly is a very difficult task. I would say that the most important feature of Lonergan’s philosophy is his emphasis on the role that questioning and inquiry play in human knowing. Even though he entitled his famous book Insight: A Study of Human Understanding, he could have well-chosen Inquiry: Human Intellect as Desiring for the title. According to Lonergan, inquiries or questions arise spontaneously in response to all of our experiences. They first come to consciousness as pre-linguistic, unarticulated desires for understanding and knowledge. We may be able to express our questions into language, and when we are successful in doing so, it is because the pre-linguistic question guides us in choosing the correct words. But whether we are able to put our questions into language or not, we become conscious of the “tension of inquiry” in the pre-linguistic question. This tension of inquiry is a desiring for what it lacks, understanding and knowledge. Only if we attain the desired understanding or knowledge will that particular desire be satisfied and only then will the tension of that inquiry be resolved and disappear. This means, of course, that insights are always related to the questions that they answer. So, important as insight is for Lonergan, inquiry and questioning are even more fundamental.

In Insight Lonergan distinguished between two kinds of questions: questions for intelligence (what? why? who? where? when? how? how many or how often? etc.) and questions for reflection (Is it so? Is it correct?). Questions for intelligence seek insights, but insights only grasp intelligible possibilities. They are therefore followed by questions for reflection, which seek something further – they seek to understand the sufficient reasons for affirming that the insight is a correct understanding, or the reasons for denying that it is correct. Underlying all questions for intelligence and reflection is what Lonergan called “the pure, unrestricted desire to know.” He argued that this desire is our “notion of being” because it intends all that is – everything about everything. This desire, this notion of being is the source of our self-transcendence (ever going beyond the limited understandings and knowledge we have attained this far) and is also the ground of the possibility that our knowledge is objective – not just phenomenal objectivity, but unconditional objectivity. He shows the implications of this approach for philosophy of science, psychoanalysis, social political philosophy, philosophy of history, metaphysics, hermeneutics and ethics.

As for his theology, the answer is much more complex. In Insight he develops a natural theology based on the analogy of God as an “unrestricted act of understanding.” He shows that it is philosophically meaningful to talk about God in this way, by showing that our unrestricted desire to know everything about everything can only be answered in an unrestricted act of understanding. He then shows that this unrestricted act of understanding has all the characteristics of the traditional theistic conception of God. In Insight he develops an account of sin and redemption based upon his earlier discussions in the book.

After Insight, Lonergan began to write also about the human “notion of value” which goes beyond our notion of being. By the notion of value he means that all of our questions about what is good and worthwhile and right arise from an unrestricted desire for the good, just as all our questions about being arise from the unrestricted desire to know.

In these post-Insight writings, Lonergan’s theology also develops to become more centered on the implications of the human unrestricted notion of value, and upon what he called “religious experience.” By religious experience he meant the state of consciousness that is the “basic and proper fulfilment” of the unrestricted notions of being and value. Drawing upon St. Paul’s Letter to the Romans (5:5), he identified religious experience as the experience of “God’s love flooding our hearts through the Holy Spirit given to us.” He called this experience “Being in love in an unrestricted fashion.” He further identified religious conversion as the decision to accept this gift of love – to love the giver in return. While embracing all of Catholic teaching, Lonergan sought to develop a method for theology that would make God’s gift of love and religious conversion central.

Q. How can you define the so called “Generalized Empirical Method” (GEM), in which not only the exterior facts but also the data of consciousness are taken into consideration? This aspect seems to be very interesting for the contemporary scientific mentality.

Byrne: By empirical method, Lonergan meant the application of the operations of the cognitional structure to sense experiences. In other words, empirical method is a matter of carefully paying attention to sense data (“Be attentive.”); allowing questions for intelligence to arise and working diligently to get insights that answer them (“Be intelligent.”); and critically questioning one’s insights, and asking the further questions that need to be answered in order to attain a “virtually unconditioned” ground for verifying or falsifying one’s insights.

This method is practiced in common sense, everyday, ordinary knowing just as much as in science. But while common sense knowing is content to investigate phenomena only insofar as they relate to our ordinary needs, interests and concerns, scientists, according to Lonergan, wish to know how everything relates to everything else. So for Lonergan, the difference between scientists and ordinary people of good will is not so much that the latter are concerned with truth, while the latter are not. Rather, the difference is that scientists seek to understand and verify a far greater domain of relationships. So for example, physicists seek to understand how elementary particles interact, chemists how atoms and molecules interact, biologists how organisms and their environments (containing both molecules and other organisms) interact.

Lonergan identified three very broad categories of methods that scientific investigators have developed in order to facilitate discoveries and verifications – classical, statistical, and genetic methods. He also explained how the combined results of these three methods imply a particular kind of evolving world, which he called the world of “generalized emergent probability.”

On the other hand, by “generalized empirical method” Lonergan meant the methodical investigation of a wider field of experiences – the experiences of consciousness in addition to the experiences of sensations. For example, if someone is observing stars through a telescope, the pattern of spots of light against a black field in the sky is data of sense. But if the scientist also pays attention to the experience of seeing (in addition to the experience of the seen), the scientist has a larger field of data to investigate. The investigation becomes scientific insofar as the investigator is concerned to understand all the relations among experiences of consciousness, not just those that satisfy some need or interest or concern. A scientist of consciousness – someone using the generalized empirical method – would also find it useful to use the classical, statistical and genetic methods to better comprehend the data of consciousness – the activities of consciousness as experiencing. But Lonergan found it necessary to introduce a fourth kind of method – dialectical method – when human behaviour is investigated, because human behaviour can be irrational, unlike the rest of the natural world. Dialectical method is needed to properly investigate the irrational dimensions of the human phenomena. This would be the fullest meaning of generalized empirical method.

Q. Many people ignore that Fr. Lonergan did not hesitate, with a deep knowledge of mathematical and statistical tools, to investigate economic issues. In this moment of crisis, how can his approach be useful and come to the aid of a depersonalized society?

Byrne: As my discussion of generalized empirical method above indicates, Lonergan thought that statistical tools could be used very meaningfully in arriving at verified understandings of human behaviour. However, statistics is all too frequently used in very dehumanizing and depersonalizing ways. Lonergan’s analysis of statistics, however, helps us understand just what statistics does and does not understand. As with every kind of scientific method, statistics is designed to answer certain kinds of questions about the general field of relations among things. The proper object of statistical methods is a population – whether a population of people, or a population of plants or animals, or a “population” of coin tosses. Each and every member of a population has its own unique way of being and its own unique story. However, at the same time those unique individuals are also parts of a whole population. Statistics helps us understand some things about the populationas a whole(such as the probabilities of certain happenings within or to that population), things that could not be understood solely from knowledge of each the members of that population, even if such knowledge were complete. On the other hand, knowing the probabilities for a population does not replace the special knowledge of each of the members. The two kinds of knowledge are complementary, interrelated, and indispensable. Dehumanization sets in when probabilities are allowed to replace and eliminate the meaningful uniqueness of each individual. However, complete concentration upon the uniqueness of the members is also a distortion. In such complete concentration, we lose sight of the whole of the population, upon which each member depends in profound ways.

Most Popular