kamagra tablets rs dostinex per togliere il latte can i use cephalexin for a uti prednisone dosage for 10 lb cat hoxtonradio.com buy finasteride new zealand hcpc for oral amoxicillin axellerata.com where to buy viagra revatio navodilo vancampinc.com arimidex eod or e3d how long does it take bupropion sr 150 mg to work fake viagra mexico with meth can azithromycin fail twice in treating chlamydia ondansetron hcl 4 mg zofran pump for hyperemesis cialis tutta vita where can i purchase flagyl 500mg without percription afsvc.com tseworldgolf.com can lasix cause kidney pain newe effekte van amitriptyline cut or chew azithromycin will i shed if switching from propecia to avodart what interfere with cialis antibiotics for babies 3 times a day symptoms of tapering off zoloft kosbonso.com percocet atarax azithromycin 5 day dose pack side effects houseontheisland.com premarin for girls cymbalta other names 0798hx.com tudo sobre o remedio xenical misoprostol price in pakistan worldtravelandtourservices.com viagra where to order nolvadex 20mg ed will tea affect cipro 500 mg antibiotic napahappy.com can i take three 4mg zofran and be safe order celexa cialis and drinking beer twospy.com method development on tadalafil aciclovir pomada serve para micose singulair medicine wiki brianlinton.com hydrochlorothiazide .5 best viagra for sale augmentin sospensione orale 140 ml wowhomes.biz adv-re.com en cuanto tiempo te hace efecto la pastilla cytotec cialis israel price co.il nlpcloud.net can zithromax treat whooping cough association-secours-sante.cm mirtazapine sandoz as an appetite stimulant for cats vestito sposa allegra metformin pcos how does it help metformin side effects burning feet can you use wellbutrin to get high muteber.com wie ist cialis einnehmen doxycycline dosage heartworms balkan-area.com prednisone dose pak order online metoprolol tartrate prostatitis aguda ciprofloxacino azithromycin 4 pills augmentin 1g is causing pain in the stomach ampicillin dieu tri inderal retard80mg boredstop.com cymbalta cures make nizoral from fish medicine treatment of acne vulgaris with azithromycin naproxen de 500mg para que sirve ibicisi.com zofran and tylenol while pregnant flagyl alcohol cooking brand viagra pills generic citalopram price ampicillin para que sirve atenolol chlorthalidone 50 25 side effects skruv principen propecia side effects itchy after eating levitra 20mg used hbtaoxian.com wast.org.uk different ways of giving viagra drops to girls boobisaweekendword.com can you die from taking too much montelukast cyproheptadine hcl 4mg what is it used for. ciprofloxacin for dental use mrw-2012.pl mobicip frame load interrupted safe place buy viagra online meastcompany.com take 30 mg levitra anyone taking cymbalta for anxiety lechatnoirrestaurant.com stopping tamoxifen after 4 years does flemings drug affect clomid work para que se usa ciprofloxacin ophthalmic solution isoptin 120 prezzo hopemedicalinstitute.org which is better 20mg of cialis or 100mg of viagra lower back hurts after taking azithromycin dosage for lamisil for tenia versicolor buy accutane england accutane 80 mg 6 months wbstaffing.pl novaisi.com cephalexin in lactating women webster.sasakistrategies.com is it safe to take amoxicillin 500mg during pregnancy muslimdate.com levothroid doses how long does it take abilify to work for psychosis mediatrax.com topamax side effects respiratory hbm.org.pl how soon can u ovulate on clomid max dose rate metformin xr priligy chile venta what is the difference between synthroid and cytomel augmentin 12 ore generic accutane reviewa furosemide and nsaids interaction can milk help with metformin side effects mooboos.com how to overcome lisinopril for men erection iheartjonahbees.net lexapro 10mg used ka 20 cialis nyquil and flagyl cipro 500 mg ne kadar isotretinoina farmaco cytotec produce esterilidad happydeal4u.com can wellbutrin help with blepharospasm augmentin 625 price in dubai terbinafine cream to go on inner tigh at walmart celebrex mg per day is ampicillin good for bronchitis no1fl.com aasoc.pl ibizaglobalradio.com did clomid work with vitamin e can you buy viagra online australia nexium 25 hr is baclofen bad for liver azithromycin 800mg minimum effective concentration of amitriptyline hcl viagra imports bemalingsplan.com lipitor prohibido l allegra compagnia limbiate azithromycin 3 day tablets price augmentin 1g antibiotic lexapro constricted pupils irtech.com.pl haltner.com viagra freiburg hywt.com orlistat tablet reviews najlepszykredytmieszkaniowy.com.pl nolvadex uk online taking misoprostol at 13 weeks what viagra actully works itaessienchrisandco.com how much amoxicillin oral sold in dollars misoprostol abortion via oral how to give dexamethasone .5 dosage to canine q hace la pastilla cytotec obat amaryl 2 glimepiride digoxin price philippines sildenafil vaginal tablets 25 mg manufacturer uzdrowisko-ewa.pl ciprofloxacin atypical coverage does clonidine show on a drug test metformin increased cm cramps tramadol taken with celebrex bikerlawblog.com orange recharge mobicarte reunion 1819wine.com side effect of doxycycline for dogs esomeprazole strontium 49.3mg viagra online reviews uk voltaren synthesis viagra price comparison at american pharmacies review of viagra web site zoloft piwo hanhvyshop.vn lexapro sprawdzlek can you take bactrim for an ear infection banganderson.co.uk lamisil manfaatnya side effect of weaning off prednisone banganderson.co.uk how much trazodone is safe prescribed prednisone for 3 weeks side effects metformin times of india is coumadin the same thing as plavix generic viagra and pay pal meblebrzozowe24.pl clear discharge on clomid is remeron a narcotic or controlled substance metformin shallow breath arilarotokiralama.com provera cost perbedaan salep ketoconazole miconazole what happens if you snort antidepressants can azithromycin cute folliculitid where to order cialis from canada estradiol valerate tablets 2mg in iui dapoxetine 15mg clomid side effects statistics viagra the pill wellbutrin pregnancy category b fda decadron injection arousal nizoral pulled from shelves atenolol 12.5 mg wellbutrin xl or sr better for weight loss viagra kullanan kadinlar body aches from lowering dose of lexapro anxiety attack and wellbutrin taking ciprofloxacin and metroprol tar como usa o clomid review of cialis daily 5 mg cyproheptadine take 8 mg wingandnut.com mister-button.de midol and zoloft can you take zofran and nexium together not sleeping with zoloft propecia price walgreen prednisone 20 mg vs hydroxyzine purchase albuterol for nebulizer comprar cytotec en ambato pastillas tadalafil price nexium 40 mg singapore is it safe to take daily cialis before surgery water pills spironolactone diltiazem er 180 mg capsule abilify recreational drug revista 20 minutos madrid bikerlawblog.com ivermectina para alpacas antibiotic flagyl giardia 250 mg duration indigent plavix program wellbutrin and methadone interactions best herbal viagra chinese shop does zyprexa affect tsh levels over the counter viagra cost rica aside of doxazosin mesylate metspirit.com kamagra vs viagrapaypal effect of lasix on serum sodium flomax 0.4 mg cap is cialis tablet available in pakistan lamisil 500 mg chi lo ha preso haltner.com wrestling-news.com wellbutrin sr 150 mg three times a day cialis benefits tablets gabapentin in dogs toxic levels whats an overdose of seroquel arilarotokiralama.com how many timws to diflucan in a tow albuterol side effects liquid interaction of flagyl with clomid tab 100mg doxycycline for a 10 lb dog acyclovir drugs ppt moonman.io sites for charles linskaill viagra find arman-crusher.com wigardenexpo.com zyprexa overdose dosage z pack and celexa wingandnut.com does estrace increase serum estrogen enalapril maleate and hydrochlorothiazide 10mg administering ivermectin singulair one month free chengdong.net can you use monistat with fluconazole napachamberfoundation.com valtrex price australia entropicity.com vizioescort.com prices of cialis in publix diovan cost 320 mg morbidoutlook.com wendy-unes.com waar cialis kopen in belgie walmart levitra special pricing levitra 10 mg teilbar buy zithromax boots what are disulfiram tablets used for napahappy.com flagyl without food the effects using cialis and androgel together can you take ibuprofen with lexapro and terazadone kegunaan obat cytotec amaryl 3mg price in pak vermogensbeheer.net iheartjonahbees.net how much does hydroxyzine pam go for on the street bactrim forte can take without meals oxyelite pro cymbalta is lisinopril hctz a 24 hour pill tomo te de oregano despues de cytotec viagra jelqing obat amitriptyline 10mg should proventil inhalers be given routine or prn huaxzw.com hashtonim.com will doxycycline treat ear or tooth infection citalopram 10mg price kamagra india precio cialis generico espa?a isotretinoina difa cooper 20 mg priligy ohne rezept kaufen hastings-print.co.uk dapoxetine 30mg side effects is viagra daily expensive singulair model 96 bula bissulfato de clopidogrel hollisterlancasterlaw.com is my itching caused by citalopram yahoo napahappy.com getting off of gabapentin effects of 100mg sertraline in pregnancy tadalafil black millteksport.pl bactrim sperm count can you get high off of ic quetiapine fumarate 50 mg comprar cytotec puebla precio viagra natural decadron 2 mg ampola ventolin camara inhalacion guna voltaren gabapentin for ringing in ears clomid days 8 12 i took diflucan pills two days apart is that ok can ventolin cause tachycardia buy strattera online no prescription can i cut in half a 10 mg singulair medical metoprolol succinate if allergic to erythromycin can you take clindamycin chengdong.net can you take buspar with cranberry juice viagra cheap generic uk combining zoloft and cymbalta phenergan with codeine brand name alatnj.org does tamoxifen reduce breast density amitriptyline 10mg price clozapine 200 mg what drup ejacutale paxil andiescafenapavalley.com doxycycline online no prescription uk cgtheink.com dostinex and lactation valtrex feux sauvages who should take lisinopril what if a teenager takes viagra terbinafine vs tolnaftate vs clotrimazole q serve remedio propranolol mifepristone e misoprostol comprar online flagyl la copii prednisone side effects anger atrial fibrillation and 20 mg prednisone can a girl have viagra bupropion recreation how long does it take doxycycline hyc vizioescort.com autorepairmanualdoc.com fluconazole oral suspension to treat yeast infection pastillas lopressor metoprolol 25 mg topamax 50 mg daily colchicine annual sales treating fever blisters with valtrex gabapentin 1000 aasoc.pl websitedesignportcharlotte.com infokurye.com misoprostol de teva en honduras bupropion 450 mg weight loss wallflore.co.uk imipramine price prednisone 5 days weight loss after discontinuing prednisone milodi.net how long is herpes contagious after taking valtrex tadalafil livraison rapide novo sertraline que es el clomid y para que sirve metoprolol 23 75 mg nebenwirkungen composizione vardenafil ugatipoffclub.com coughing side effect of levaquin buy levitra new york dapoxetine in lebanon henrycavillfan.org topamax side effect study rate of occurrence woodmizer.net.pl variamedia.com.pl cialis if your young does lisinopril cause thinning hair fluoxetine buy no prescription ebodesign.com can injectable ivermectin be given orally to dogs sildenafil iupac name clomid et enceinte sans le savoir viagra was kostet das zyprexa iv dosage zyvoxid et tyramine is nexium ok to take while pregnant 28 day cycle when to take clomid cheap xenical online no1fl.com beribak.com cialis slow to take effect jwapr.com will zoloft make me fail a drug test hydroxyzine hydrochloride syrup usp uses kd ki adalat full episode ketoconazole 753 websitedesignportcharlotte.com flagyl dogs topamax fedex rash after taking ciprofloxacin woodmizer.org.pl lasix nursing interventions fluconazole back pain aneyron.com association-secours-sante.cm azithromycin vs augmentin are they safe for pregnant zyprexa dergboadre dosage generic amitriptyline side effects wallflore.co.uk does over tge counter naproxen show up on drug test ugatipoffclub.com misoprostol composicion quimica phenergan with codeine cough syrup dosage lipitor over age 70 lexapro15 mg hairgrowth synthroid price walmart ugatipoffclub.com sildenafil citrate tablets vegah extra 120 prostata i cialis comprimidos de nizoral selepas makan cytotec paxil 10 mg success metronidazole hair growth xenical day 4 costo del levitra 20 mg amlodipine and cough hlahlaaung.com boobisaweekendword.com orlistat kids terbinafine hcl 250 mg for ringworm buy esomeprazole magnesium online the cost of lamisil in ontario can i take thyroxine with ezetimibe reliable viagra sites cephalexin rash baby viagra buy in uk online ofloxacin ear drops baby is augmentin stronger than penicillin isoptin 20 clomid 50mg europe ciprofloxacin hcl twice a day all g is augmentin for pink eye buy real avodart online pms erythromycin bula champions-league-news.com acyclovir swelling costo viagra dopo scadenza brevetto efeitos colaterais da metformina accutane chapstick adverse reactions of mixing synthroid with advil ciprofloxacin cat bites association-secours-sante.cm allegra 180 mg twice daily angellsangels.com plavix 75 mg buy michellestockman.com wpmodder.com metronidazole 400g safe in pregnancy africanamericanimages.us engagement mobicarte orange augmentin gi bleed baufinanzierung-aktuell.com

Rome's Zenit News

 Fecha: 2012-11-05

ROME, Nov. 5, 2012 (Zenit.org).- The following is an interview with Patrick H. Byrne, professor of Philosophy at Boston College on the life and works of famed theologian, Fr. Bernard Lonergan.

* * *

Q. A few days ago the fiftieth anniversary of the Second Vatican Council was celebrated. What were the ideas, suggestions and expectations of Fr. Lonergan for this epochal event in the history of the Church?

Byrne: Lonergan wrote two articles that touched upon the Second Vatican Council: “Existenz and Aggiornamento,” and “Pope John’s Intention.” In both articles Lonergan points out the purpose of Vatican II was pastoral. That the challenge was proclaiming the Good News in the cultural context of the modern world, a world that had changed greatly. So the great effort of his work was to offer an analysis of culture that would facilitate the carrying forward the mission of Vatican II. As his own contributions, he first distinguished between “classicism” and “modern culture.” He identified five defining features of classicism, and five corresponding changes that characterize modern culture. He developed his method in theology for the sake of communicating the faith to a culture that was no longer classicist, rather than trying to insist that modern culture accept the faith on classicist terms.

Q. His thought is a great contribution to the philosophical debate of our days. He tried to read the modern times in the light of the tradition and in the wake of S. Augustine, S. Thomas Aquinas, John Henry Newman and other contemporaries. It is not only a remarkable synthesis but a real step forward. How can his philosophy and theology be briefly described?

Byrne: Of course to describe Lonergan’s philosophy and theology briefly is a very difficult task. I would say that the most important feature of Lonergan’s philosophy is his emphasis on the role that questioning and inquiry play in human knowing. Even though he entitled his famous book Insight: A Study of Human Understanding, he could have well-chosen Inquiry: Human Intellect as Desiring for the title. According to Lonergan, inquiries or questions arise spontaneously in response to all of our experiences. They first come to consciousness as pre-linguistic, unarticulated desires for understanding and knowledge. We may be able to express our questions into language, and when we are successful in doing so, it is because the pre-linguistic question guides us in choosing the correct words. But whether we are able to put our questions into language or not, we become conscious of the “tension of inquiry” in the pre-linguistic question. This tension of inquiry is a desiring for what it lacks, understanding and knowledge. Only if we attain the desired understanding or knowledge will that particular desire be satisfied and only then will the tension of that inquiry be resolved and disappear. This means, of course, that insights are always related to the questions that they answer. So, important as insight is for Lonergan, inquiry and questioning are even more fundamental.

In Insight Lonergan distinguished between two kinds of questions: questions for intelligence (what? why? who? where? when? how? how many or how often? etc.) and questions for reflection (Is it so? Is it correct?). Questions for intelligence seek insights, but insights only grasp intelligible possibilities. They are therefore followed by questions for reflection, which seek something further – they seek to understand the sufficient reasons for affirming that the insight is a correct understanding, or the reasons for denying that it is correct. Underlying all questions for intelligence and reflection is what Lonergan called “the pure, unrestricted desire to know.” He argued that this desire is our “notion of being” because it intends all that is – everything about everything. This desire, this notion of being is the source of our self-transcendence (ever going beyond the limited understandings and knowledge we have attained this far) and is also the ground of the possibility that our knowledge is objective – not just phenomenal objectivity, but unconditional objectivity. He shows the implications of this approach for philosophy of science, psychoanalysis, social political philosophy, philosophy of history, metaphysics, hermeneutics and ethics.

As for his theology, the answer is much more complex. In Insight he develops a natural theology based on the analogy of God as an “unrestricted act of understanding.” He shows that it is philosophically meaningful to talk about God in this way, by showing that our unrestricted desire to know everything about everything can only be answered in an unrestricted act of understanding. He then shows that this unrestricted act of understanding has all the characteristics of the traditional theistic conception of God. In Insight he develops an account of sin and redemption based upon his earlier discussions in the book.

After Insight, Lonergan began to write also about the human “notion of value” which goes beyond our notion of being. By the notion of value he means that all of our questions about what is good and worthwhile and right arise from an unrestricted desire for the good, just as all our questions about being arise from the unrestricted desire to know.

In these post-Insight writings, Lonergan’s theology also develops to become more centered on the implications of the human unrestricted notion of value, and upon what he called “religious experience.” By religious experience he meant the state of consciousness that is the “basic and proper fulfilment” of the unrestricted notions of being and value. Drawing upon St. Paul’s Letter to the Romans (5:5), he identified religious experience as the experience of “God’s love flooding our hearts through the Holy Spirit given to us.” He called this experience “Being in love in an unrestricted fashion.” He further identified religious conversion as the decision to accept this gift of love – to love the giver in return. While embracing all of Catholic teaching, Lonergan sought to develop a method for theology that would make God’s gift of love and religious conversion central.

Q. How can you define the so called “Generalized Empirical Method” (GEM), in which not only the exterior facts but also the data of consciousness are taken into consideration? This aspect seems to be very interesting for the contemporary scientific mentality.

Byrne: By empirical method, Lonergan meant the application of the operations of the cognitional structure to sense experiences. In other words, empirical method is a matter of carefully paying attention to sense data (“Be attentive.”); allowing questions for intelligence to arise and working diligently to get insights that answer them (“Be intelligent.”); and critically questioning one’s insights, and asking the further questions that need to be answered in order to attain a “virtually unconditioned” ground for verifying or falsifying one’s insights.

This method is practiced in common sense, everyday, ordinary knowing just as much as in science. But while common sense knowing is content to investigate phenomena only insofar as they relate to our ordinary needs, interests and concerns, scientists, according to Lonergan, wish to know how everything relates to everything else. So for Lonergan, the difference between scientists and ordinary people of good will is not so much that the latter are concerned with truth, while the latter are not. Rather, the difference is that scientists seek to understand and verify a far greater domain of relationships. So for example, physicists seek to understand how elementary particles interact, chemists how atoms and molecules interact, biologists how organisms and their environments (containing both molecules and other organisms) interact.

Lonergan identified three very broad categories of methods that scientific investigators have developed in order to facilitate discoveries and verifications – classical, statistical, and genetic methods. He also explained how the combined results of these three methods imply a particular kind of evolving world, which he called the world of “generalized emergent probability.”

On the other hand, by “generalized empirical method” Lonergan meant the methodical investigation of a wider field of experiences – the experiences of consciousness in addition to the experiences of sensations. For example, if someone is observing stars through a telescope, the pattern of spots of light against a black field in the sky is data of sense. But if the scientist also pays attention to the experience of seeing (in addition to the experience of the seen), the scientist has a larger field of data to investigate. The investigation becomes scientific insofar as the investigator is concerned to understand all the relations among experiences of consciousness, not just those that satisfy some need or interest or concern. A scientist of consciousness – someone using the generalized empirical method – would also find it useful to use the classical, statistical and genetic methods to better comprehend the data of consciousness – the activities of consciousness as experiencing. But Lonergan found it necessary to introduce a fourth kind of method – dialectical method – when human behaviour is investigated, because human behaviour can be irrational, unlike the rest of the natural world. Dialectical method is needed to properly investigate the irrational dimensions of the human phenomena. This would be the fullest meaning of generalized empirical method.

Q. Many people ignore that Fr. Lonergan did not hesitate, with a deep knowledge of mathematical and statistical tools, to investigate economic issues. In this moment of crisis, how can his approach be useful and come to the aid of a depersonalized society?

Byrne: As my discussion of generalized empirical method above indicates, Lonergan thought that statistical tools could be used very meaningfully in arriving at verified understandings of human behaviour. However, statistics is all too frequently used in very dehumanizing and depersonalizing ways. Lonergan’s analysis of statistics, however, helps us understand just what statistics does and does not understand. As with every kind of scientific method, statistics is designed to answer certain kinds of questions about the general field of relations among things. The proper object of statistical methods is a population – whether a population of people, or a population of plants or animals, or a “population” of coin tosses. Each and every member of a population has its own unique way of being and its own unique story. However, at the same time those unique individuals are also parts of a whole population. Statistics helps us understand some things about the populationas a whole(such as the probabilities of certain happenings within or to that population), things that could not be understood solely from knowledge of each the members of that population, even if such knowledge were complete. On the other hand, knowing the probabilities for a population does not replace the special knowledge of each of the members. The two kinds of knowledge are complementary, interrelated, and indispensable. Dehumanization sets in when probabilities are allowed to replace and eliminate the meaningful uniqueness of each individual. However, complete concentration upon the uniqueness of the members is also a distortion. In such complete concentration, we lose sight of the whole of the population, upon which each member depends in profound ways.

Most Popular