altace viagra tamsulosin effect on diabetes 5 facts about albuterol sulfate from journal iv lasix bumex conversion how long before initial symptoms of propecia went away best sildenafil citrate combinationindia precio sildenafil chile cialis from us with prescription z tabs antibiotics azithromycin zithromax pregnancy why take prednisone for back pain how long dies diflucan 150mg stay in your system how long does zyprexa tiredness last taking metformin with insulin phenergan dosage forms augmentin peritoneal dialysis wellbutrin dosage availability lamisil cream tauranga can you take cialis daily with paxil does neurontin 100 mg make you tired azithromycin 500mg online from usa cyclical tiredness with prednisone withdrawal tramadol, neurontin, amitriptyline long term use thereal price of non generic sildenafil valtrex meningitis cipro and flagyl for c diff augmentin ile alkol does generic diflucan cause anxiety is amoxicillin good for impetigo flagyl wie lange kein alkohol is the 25 mg generic plavix come in white can cipro help a tooth infection en las farmacias de torreon venden la cytotec sertraline price in philippines can i take clomid on the first day of my period average copay nexium 40mg pct clomid dosimg what happens if one takes viagra too often how long does allegra work does flagyl conflict with metformin does strattera give you a buzz donde compro cialis en el df interaction between metformin and iodine hair fall after accutane paxil withdrawal emotional metoprolol tartrate drug action can you disolve viagra in a drink do tadalafil kills sperm provera for sale bupropion efavirenz accutane white spots on skin bupropion hcl sr 100mg tablet buying kamagra important chiangmai ciprofloxacin covers what organisms ventolin laba abuelo viagra nexium better than protonix viagra online sales co uk prendre viagra et cialis en meme temps 10mg viagra will ti work montelukast 10 mg philippines cloxacillin and amoxicillin difference how long would a quarter cialis c20 viagra last allegra lucci how often should you take zofran while pregnant long term effects of paxil withdrawal adalat 28th jan allopurinol al 100 aliud pharma taking cipro and sun can you give a cat a human albuterol neb treatment nortriptyline and heart attack will glucophage and inofolic help with pregnancy apotex amoxicillin side effects seroquel highest dose uses of ofloxacin ornidazole doses of neurontin for sciatica plavix buy online canada conditions remboursement aciclovir maxim esomeprazole 40 mg using tampon while taking metronidazole tablets for bv preciode el medicamento montelukast albuterol one or two puffs low dose accutane for acne rosacea ovulation sous clomid quand for viagra to work do you have to be horny cytotec misoprostol penang area amlodipine 2.5mg for cats side effects can you buy zithromax at walmart terbinafine hcl vs clotrimazole finasteride 5mg vision lexapro esquecimento kamagra doppelte dosis does lisinopril 20 mg have a maoi in it using amitriptyline for pain topamax price brand walgreens paxil aksam can you take preparation h with amlodipine besylate atenolol to get high generic zyprexa not as effective does flagyl syrup treat diarrhea in dogs can you take zoloft and claritin d costco prescription shampoos is methocarbamol a good muscle relaxer doxycycline hyclate chest infection length course amitriptyline and antivert baclofen lijek can viagra treat premature ejaculation how stuff works cong dung cua thuoc equivalent to atorvastatin 10 mg sildenafil for scleroderma can seroquel be taken with methadone aciclovir cr?me dermique paxil 5 mg side effects hydrobromide 20mg how to take digoxin 125mcg for dogs how long does it take fluconazole to digest information sub antimicrobial dose of doxycycline kamagra by cheque uk cialis and gerd can cytotec be used when three months pregnant doxycycline used in abortion misoprostol de 28 tabletas diflucan and effects on birth control creatine monohydrate avec de la doxycycline how much is viagra at walmart pharmacy cymbalta how to take beads neruda gabapentin 800 mg what is mg for strongest viagra drug diflucan side effects how does levaquin darken urine can you stop cymbalta ciprodex use after expiration date side effects ondansetron dogs delayed backache with viagra with viagra can i get a second erection obat amitriptyline 25 mg will misoprostol work if i take alcohol albuterol nebulizer cost buying cialis 800mg in canada en guatemala cuanto cuestan cuatro pastillas cytotec singulair baby comprimidos mastigaveis prednisone and cerebral edema viagra alternatives in turkey if taking sertraline can you take water tablets as well how long does it take nizoral 2 treat a yeast infection doxofylline with montelukast sodium doxycycline can cure stds 400 mgs zoloft silagra kaufen 80 mg paxil can hydroxyzine hcl syrup get you high numbness in toes lisinopril buy viagra sydney can you split lisinopril in half buy sildenafil online canada fluconazole 200mg candida breast levitra overseas first dosage of zoloft propecia made my hair fall out gabapentin modafinil tablet ic citalopram hbr 20 mg vs venlafaxine nexium mop technology linezolid class does amitriptyline relax your muscles linezolid behandling lopressor for atrial fibrillation metformin increased lfts singapore cialis shop guardian bactrim forte e coli sperma nifedipine in pregnancy journal erythromycin ethylsuccinate gastroparesis lamisil cream canada apteka plavix clopidogrel 75 cena amoxicillin dosierung bei sinusitis ampicillin concentration for cell culture out of date metronidazole how much does viagra sell for on the street what is prednisone taper dose should i take cialis for performance anxiety can i take only a half of 20 cialis manfaat acyclovir tablet dosis 200mg pada cacar air propranolol for resting tremor will cymbalta show up on a drug test arthritis tapering prednisone pregnancy can you get high off apo valacyclovir vitamin in viagra 88 mcg synthroid side effects viagra does not work. could cialis be effective how long for propecia to leave body finasteride caps ivermectin sarcoptic mange treatment instrucciones para aplicar cytotec lexapro urinary problems is gaviscon safe with clopidogrel verapamil with divaon 160 candida die off with diflucan viagra caratteristiche uso do baclofen no alcoolismo hydroxyzine mg poison ivy cialis auckland blackmarket ivermectin albendazole suspension ciprofloxacino 0.3 solucion oftalmica pre?o atenolol 25mg medley how much is bactrim antibiotic generic cialis canada online slow release metformin why acromegaly prednisone viagra jamshedpur is viagra covered by health care card australia prednisone changing stool color does norvasc and metoprolol make a good combination metformina dosis para resistencia ala insulina clomipramine and fluvoxamine finasteride how much does it cost warfarin prescribing guidelines uk glucophage nursing implications does viagra make your erection last long cephalexin 500mg capsule side effect chlamydia treatment single dose azithromycin cialis uk suppliers when should paroxetine be taken strattera in liquid form in the uk can 1 cytotec kill 1 month pregnant tetracycline capsules acne what can i buy without prescription for ovulation luvox 50 mg side effects singulair canada pharmacy can you take ventolin with alcohol singulair es cortisona propecia how long to you see hair contre indication du xenical what is considered long term when taking prednisone buy viagra uk pay money after delivery alternative medication to flomax cipro side effects tongue ciprofloxacino causa candidiasis lexapro oxycodone drug interaction estradiol 1 mg tab barr labs pfizer stock before and after viagra accidentally took two nexium 40 mg ubat kurus orlistat side effects high dose zoloft timing of ovulation after clomid which brand of amoxicillin with good taste kamagra oral jelly vs escitalopram is this glutten free lidia allegra amitriptyline tabletki la mutua passa il cialis doxycycline tablets india is amoxil safe for pregnant women levaquin side effects dairy amoxicillin upset tummy 3.75mg mirtazapine enough anxiety amoxicillin tablet can get good sperm amoxicillin 500 for a dog bit alternatives to prednisone for inflammatory septra warfarin interaction viagra to bye cymbalta application for patient assistance buy orlistat china levothroid espanol celexa rocks what is zestril 20 mg used for levothyroxine and l glutamine best dosage cymbalta viagra cor de rosa arret cymbalta effet mobic costochondritis neurontin for lyme is it bad to go into a hot tub after taking cialisis pacher antidepressants propecia copyright what is the difference between plavix and iscover viagra citrus will fluconazole help for rash under breasts viagra dhe perdorimi i saj septra or bactrim or cipro for parasite dosage of amoxicillin for cellulitis infection paxil washout what will happen if man takes viagra for woman robaxin and vicodin high ampicillin as an antibiotic kamagra w aptekach bez recepty buspirone 7.5 street value estradiol 312 levonorgestrel ethinyl estradiol generic prednisone dosage for hives fungsi obat amlodipine besylate zoloft is no longer working celebrex heart study albuterol nebulizer liquid on hands lisinopril stomach bloating cialis milinda gmbh price zovirax cream philipines augmentin 1000 milligrm tab is excellent suddenly stop topamax que dosis debo tomar de cytotec para abortar anafranil tbl dexamethasone 4 mg injection shelf life of liquid tamoxifen citrate buy cyproheptadine online prednisone 7 day dose effect period nolvadex en winstrol ciprofloxacin dexamethasone 5ml price mercury drug can you iv strattera 80 mg jaki jest prawidlowy wynik estradiolu lisinopril dosage options lisinopril and diuretics cialis comercial transcript how can i stop taking plavix what the fastes way for cialis to work verapamil transdermal gel cost stopping avodart atomoxetine smoking head zaps while on paxil what should you expect to feel after taking viagra clomid days 1 6 duloxetine costco pharmacy does azithromycin make u get your period cialis 5 mg how long does diarrhea from azithromycin last twins after clomid sandoz azithromycin price in pakistan flagyl 500mg stat dose iv how much for 90 10mg buspar bargain on viagra lisinopril side effects with bananas antibiotics cipro and alcohol viagra ranbaxy malaysia anafranil 25mg clomipramin.hydrochl for which function prazosin hydrocloride tablets does seroquel slow heart rate vardenafil and pot what can i take for daily erection baclofen feeling media tableta de cialis ketoconazole mercury drug is valtrex a sulfa drug prednisone and uti in dogs glucophage et fibrome buy propecia generic finasteride cuanto tiempo debo tomar el lexapro zyprexa olanzapina 5mg powered by mybb generic replacement for lipitor blum minipress pro for sale efectos cialis generico levothyroxine side effects impotence etamox 500 amoxicillin 500mg suppliers ciprofloxacin hcl used for treatment of lyme diserse vibramycin metabolism cymbalta passing out how to order misoprostol online in ireland tamoxifen migraine aura flagyl suspension price uk what price is cialis in the republic of ireland finasteride winthrop aripiprazole first episode breastfeeding while taking diflucan taking hydrocodone and clonidine together what medicine is like zoloft atorvastatin drug mechanism of action wikipedia org wiki azithromycin is zoloft class a b or c wellbutrin and delsym sildenafil nitroglycerin wechselwirkung cytotec in pph precio de seroquel 200mg is lisinopril hctz a 24 hour pill clomiphene erectile dysfunction metformin hours what is biotech ciprofloxacin does ranitidine and azithromycin pregnancy symptoms first time using clomid premarin ajuda a engravidar nardil seroquel sleep

Palin Family Values and the Abortion Debate

Abortion activists and media analysts in awe with both Gov. Sarah Palin’s decision to give birth to her Down syndrome child and her teenage daughter’s decision to continue her pregnancy and marry her baby's father.
by Joan Frawley Desmond | Source:

Perhaps the most absorbing element of this election season is the spectacle of abortion activists and media analysts grappling with both Gov. Sarah Palin’s decision to spare the life of her Down syndrome child and her teenage daughter’s decision to continue her pregnancy and marry the father of her unborn child.

As a group of talking heads on television expressed their amazement at the state of the Palin household, I thought of William May, my moral theology professor at the John Paul II Institute for Studies on Marriage and Family, and his penchant for poking holes in the tortured logic of abortion advocates. May could nail the source of abortion supporters’ present discomfort in a nanosecond: Palin’s family choices directly challenge arguments that justify abortion as the “lesser evil.”

Since the ’60s, reproductive rights activists have presented abortion as perhaps the best solution for the scourge of teenage pregnancy, inner-city poverty, gender inequality, and the suffering experienced by disabled infants and their families. But May didn’t buy those arguments: “If abortion is the ‘lesser evil,’” he used to tell our class, “then the alternative — keeping the baby — constitutes the ‘greater evil.’ But how can that position be proved?”

The answer is that it’s impossible to prove that abortion constitutes the “lesser evil.” Catholic moral theologians like May have labored for years to explain both the logical inconsistencies and the moral dangers of the “lesser evil” argument. Now, the Palin family is providing an assist.

Basically, the “lesser evil” argument seeks to weigh, or commensurate, the good and evil consequences of two opposing moral choices.

But May and others argue that this exercise is like comparing apples and oranges. With abortion, the decision is made to terminate nascent human life in order to avoid a worse outcome. According to this equation, bringing the baby to term will produce such disastrous consequences that the good of preserving human life is outweighed by the overwhelming burden of sustaining it. But no abortion advocates have offered an analytical model that will support this utilitarian calculation. In fact, this balancing act is not a precise scientific evaluation, but a reflection of personal beliefs and experience.

The “lesser evil” argument also reveals a scary indifference to the moral evil inherent in the choice to destroy innocent human life. Many pregnant women, unwed or not, can be overwhelmed by the scandal, financial and logistical demands, and threats to personal freedom posed by the arrival of a new child. This argument implicitly assumes the mother can predict the future, and that it will be bleak if her child is brought to term. But this, too, cannot be proved. The future, as we all know, is woefully, or gloriously, unpredictable.

In fact, the “lesser evil” position depends on scary scenarios that can distract the would-be mother from the fundamental moral principle at issue: “You shall not do evil that good shall come of it.”

There was a time when every American child learned that “the ends don’t justify the means.” But since the ’60s, that moral aphorism has been under sustained attack, both within and without the Church. Long before self-described Catholic politicians challenged traditional teaching on abortion, the Church was roiled by the eruption of theological dissent on the morality of married couples using contraception.

The rejection of Humanae Vitae (The Regulation of Birth) depended on a steady stream of sympathetic portraits of married couples struggling to achieve financial and emotional stability by spacing births. Contraception was the “lesser evil.”

During the debate on Humanae Vitae, dissenting theologians advanced two additional arguments to justify the use of contraception. Moral relativism remained the most popular argument — times had changed, and moral absolutes no longer applied. The second argument has been described as the “fundamental option”: “Good” people can occasionally violate moral absolutes without endangering their souls. Good Catholics could contracept, as long as they remained loving parents and spouses. Since then, similar arguments have been employed to justify abortion, sidestepping the decisive way evil actions shape our character and future moral choices.

The three lines of theological dissent pose logical and moral problems. But May also liked to expose the blind spot at the heart of any rejection of moral absolutes. The arid “lesser evil” equation that sentences the unborn child to death ignores the endless possibilities of a human choice that embraces the great good of preserving life.

As Pope John Paul II often noted, the Ten Commandments provide the absolute limit beyond which human behavior cannot descend. But the Decalogue sets no limits on human transcendence. Christians navigate their temporal existence with the aid of a Church that offers the truth that sets us free.

When abortion is off the table, the search for true solutions begins — tightening the household budget, proposing marriage, offering the child for adoption to a childless couple. Catholic moral teaching drives human creativity, inspiring real fruitfulness.

Once declared a settled political question, abortion keeps resurfacing at the center of the political stage. In part, that’s because the debate over abortion is not just about the unborn person’s right to life. It’s also about how we should embrace the vast possibilities of our vocation to love as Christ loves us. How we should live in this world.

Many Americans, Republicans and Democrats will be drawn to the drama of the Palin family. And while neither they nor we know what the future holds, we share their hopes. And who knows? Maybe this election will consign the “lesser evil” argument to the dustbin of history. Professor May would applaud heartily.

Marylander Joan Frawley Desmond writes for a variety of publications on religious and cultural topics.

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular