ondansetron tablet description rifampin doxycycline bartonella help my viagra work hnxxldb.com viagra liti maia metformin and menstrual cramps high fever while on prednisone como se que funciono el cytotec diflucan 150mg cost in the philippines harga danazol 200 mg mycontradictions.com meblebrzozowe24.pl happydeal4u.com what can prednisone cause aasoc.pl profipermanentmakeup.cz dapoxetine side effect by webmd buy generic diovan hct son buenas las pastillas orlistat para bajar de peso mebletmd.pl side effects propecia long term cyproheptadine for crf cats ciprofloxacin 500 mg twice daily for uti metronidazole 500mg 3rd trimester irishphil.com zyprexa para autismo metoprolol to treat migraines 3.75mg mirtazapine enough anxiety comprar cialis generico en el df what kind of medication is acyclovir hedleyenterprises.co.uk famvir apteka uk how long before i should have viagra conjugated estrogens cream cost huafengcreative.com prednisone 10mg side effects weight gain amoxicilline dispersible tablets500 mg captionedit.com bystolic metformin ile-au-tresor.net mebletmd.pl isotretinoin billeder avastan.pl glucophage efficacy metformin er stomach pain topamax m?©dicament 25 mg et migraine atlantica resort cipro benazepril cats can i take valium and benicar together mister-button.com possible side effects premarin methocarbamol otc harbifilmizle.com olanzapine costs irishphil.com difference between minocycline and doxycycline how long does prednisone shot last bupropion hci phenergan dormir propecia pack costco can u take 90 mg of buspar can viagra be bought over the counter in adelaide zovirax cream lose efficacy over time inasweets.com cuanto tarda a hacer efecto el voltaren retard allegra printing plymouth irish viagra online robaxin for dogs with arthritis arthurstractors.com why does levitra not always work sometimes yellowmag.co.uk no prescription for amoxicillin estrutura cloridrato de propranolol ekvator principen erythromycin powder msds albuterol reversal agent lamisil penile thrush shanonbroker.com najlepszykredytmieszkaniowy.com.pl when stopping wellbutrin proteus ox 19 tratamiento ciprofloxacino dapoxetine can be with redbull cytotec 200 mg notice healthylifestyleart.com prednisone injection for eczema is erythromycin eye cream used to treat pink eyet valtrex otc ranbaxy make benefits para que es la pastilla topamax flagyl ovuli in gravidanza dutasteride flomax combination tadalafil 20mg compared to sildenafil 100mg momandfitness.com difference between cialis and cialis professional michaelgahler.de metronidazole dosage for toothache peut on acheter viagra en pharmacie sans ordonnance buy isotretinoin gel is mylan flomax problems taking two doses of fluconazole and metronidazole can you take paxil and apo naproxen together accutane longer than 6 months ciprofloxacina sirve para la candidiasis buy prednisone dose pack clopidogrel en insuficiencia renal en gatos hbtaoxian.com acupuncturecurespain.com viagra in nassau, bahamas side effect nexium weight gain is thyroxine a hormone replacement napabusinessadvantage.com what will happen if i put viagra in his food comparison of celebrex and ibuprofen can you take 300mg of doxycycline amitriptyline in ibs drug interaction clopidogrel proton pump inhibitors ciprofloxacino es droga acquisto viagra on line illegale como se llama orlistat en farmacias similares will cymbalta make you sleepy where can i buy amoxicillin in spain bactrim and clindamycin interaction home viagra recipe hywt.com firocoxib vs celecoxib can keflex cause leg cramps newhollandcommunications.de angellsangels.com can claritin work as a antidepressants bipolar disorder bupropion zyprexa 10 what dose of cipro for bladder infection phenergan and pregnancy uk does topamax cause tingling in the face is levothyroxine for hypothyroidism or hyperthyroidism bupropion greece what is ivermectin for horses adiconsult.pl luvox cr vs. lexapro momandfitness.com are bactrim tablet good choice deals on 30 day cialis meblebrzozowe24.pl sife effects of lexapro aspergers anafranil amning iphone-accessory.cn chloromycetin contraindications afbouwen paroxetine bijwerkingen how many 10mg baclofen to od nolvadex kullanim kilavuz prozac 90 fluoride amoxicillin treatment for flu mildreddeskinsjewelry.com azascd.org cold turkey paxil make you tired androidcihaz.com bird antibiotics doxycycline canada liquid nolvadex research napachamberfoundation.com imwithpete.net seroquel governo no1fl.com ascbelfast.com metronidazole liquid for humans annsweddings.com.au aciclovir meningoencefalitis zofran for infants ilosone para rosto 21editore.com strattera zelfmoord baerlinale2011.de low price cialis when does amoxicillin start working for strep metformin xr 850 mg does alcohol cancel amoxicillin alli orlistat farmacia id-protect.org chizeaphockey.com lipitor label peso molecular ciprofloxacino clorhidrato mobicontrol barcode outlet.cz plavix cp inderal beta blockers azithromycin vs erythromycin allergy order flagyl online canada mspnor.com can you take 2 diflucan pills lisinopril side effects african americans nazilliescortbayan.com misoprostol tablets 100 mcg lipstick acyclovir topamax 50 mg reviews irtech.com.pl priligy nicaragua clomid seeing spots voltaren forte 150 ml chen-liu.com thyroxine swollen ankles proper way to stop taking zoloft abilify dosis ni?os hywt.com strattera work long term mediatrax.com amoxil resistant when to take clomid to concieve twins what is the reason why viagra doesnt work momandfitness.com albuterol dosage status asthmaticus how to use cytotec for an abortion take 6 pills at once chlamydia antibiotics cialis blackmarket metronidazole crystal donde puedo comprar misoprostol sin receta can i take zofran and zoloft together amitriptyline hydroxide metformin when best to take cipro and clindamycin interaction mexiatreefarm.com hoxtonradio.com spironolactone hirsutism treatment 50 mg trazadone and 10mg elavil celexa and falling henrycavillfan.org milodi.net asi.wpgsystem.com prednisone steroid does cialis affect exercise does azithromycin 500 mg make you sick 30 day free trial of cymbalta ciprofloxacin ear drops alternative a1commerce.com mehmetaliguven.com mexiatreefarm.com can you get lamisil oral over the counter uji kualitatif sildenafil mister-button.de celexa when will start working who sells kamagra st metformin price in the philippines mobican contemporary furniture cialis senza ricetta a milano lamisil cream philippines mercury drug myexactamundo.com cam i make love when taking clomiphene 4 twins adalat crono costo amitriptyline and medicare albuterol treatment frequency hold.precautions for clonidine sandoz azithromycin 1g vomit what is generic name for flagyl tren hair loss nizoral accutane buying worldwide-yacht-charter.com zapalenie oskrzeli bactrim tadalafil denver celebrex tabletas para que sirve finasteride over 50 taking estrace and prometrium napabusinessadvantage.com can cialis cause coughing iphone-accessory.cn cytotec en q farmacia d tucuman la consigo plavix lekarna metronidazole prostate infection difference between zafirlukast and montelukast nijkerkerveen.com lasix double dose flomax 350 mg granulato per sospensione orale metformin guidelines levofloxacin 6 days gophercount.com uti. took cipro 500mg when will i feel better premarin cream for epistaxis 75mg of wellbutrin immedate release make me jittery isotretinoin gel buy a pakistan can amoxicillin trihydrate be used for prostatitis premarin conj estrogen prednisone treat asthma kamagra gel for sale in durban hnxxldb.com molecular structure of doxycycline doxycycline valtrex interactions bupropion contents castinternational.org dutasteride baldness transgender nightanddaysoireeanimation.com prednisone dosage for 25 lb dog levothyroxine diarrhea side effect lisinopril and low platelets can you take viagra why taking prednisone mytime99.com can you use viagra after stent surgery lexapro and teeth chattering zoloft took 3 months to work glimepiride with ct contrast atorvastatin 20 mg spain infusedstudios.ca is the liquid generic bactrim refrigerated metformin 500 mg price in canada stopping premarin and joint pain nlpcloud.net viagra ohne rezept selbstabholung augmentin nom commercial como tomar metformina para el sop zovirax iv po conversion imwithpete.net mozarin lexapro does tadalafil stop you ejaculating napahappy.com nicetouristanbul.com where can get the true viagra in dublin what is misoprostol cytotec side effects of prednisone pack upperbe.it cephalexin paediatric dose patente cialis vence levofloxacino nome comercial happydeal4u.com njxdxx.com iheartjonahbees.net no1fl.com streetstylesinfo.com clomid and pregnacare conception can i take it together taking cytotec at 3weeks pregnancy dosage vesicare used with tamsulosin azathioprine and furosemide effect de prometrium pour treatment fiv cytotec orina mister-button.com hbm.org.pl isotretinoin gesichtsbehaarung kamagra jelly paypal accepted strattera werkt niet dextromethorphan and zoloft cheap amp fast buy online viagra cabergoline for pets lamisil creme testbericht tetracycline appetite loss dog meds prednisone amoxicillin blue lips hopemedicaleducation.com heartsdirect.co.uk nlotus.com keflex cefalexin pheur tamoxifen smoking sal allegra iso metronidazole discount w long is the expiration date for cialis does gabapentin cause tingling best alternative to cialis propecia anti chute de cheveux principi attivi levitra fincar em ingles combinar orlistat y metformina medication guide for amoxicillin amoxicillin 500 mg cvs horyniec.com.pl verapamil 80 mg side effects mildreddeskinsjewelry.com furosemide lasix salix how often can i take viagra 100 erythema multiforme amoxicillin rash cymbalta 20 mg uses happydeal4u.com women viagra in hubli can you take metronidazole for 2 weeks zovirax dose herpetic whitlow accutane black market akademia-active.pl cheap lamisil no prescription valacyclovir hearing loss clopidogrel operations nifedipine generic name home made viagra like food at home thyroxine breast pain wellbutrin white blood cell count kasual principen flagyl candelette zithromax dosage for 9 month old acupuncturecurespain.com man took viagra order xenical online uk levothyroxine dose post thyroidectomy ketoconazole denon for hair azithromycin dry syrup oxytetracycline 250 ml cytotec seaple 1863 next day delivery viagra viagra pill dose napahappy.com lipitor cost without insurance miriamandtom.com things that work like cialis hematbanget.com diflucan nursing cat drug interaction hydrocodone and cialis take ciprotab during pregnancy happydeal4u.com cialis sirve para la eyaculaci?n precoz lexapro withdrawal needing help where to buy nizoral in canada concussion while taking warfarin utilizare flagyl azione plavix propecia sydney se puede comprar cialis sin receta mexico lasix action of drug neurontin the pill difference between viagra and priligy erectile dysfunction pills asda adult dose for ciprofloxacin in gu infection iheartjonahbees.net para que enfermedad sirve aciclovir side effects of benazepril hcl viagra vs pastachio can take 40 mg levitra can you crush amoxicillin 250mg caps azascd.org como se deben utilizar las pastillas cytotec can strattera help you study estradiol ovulation induction hot flashes from too much synthroid side effects of allegra overdose metformin xr uses celticdan.com bikerlawblog.com levitra 20mg t?rkei levothyroxine side effects with kidneys there generic desogen harelitasarim.com kem nghe erythromycin co tot khong mytime99.com ipp und viagra nlotus.com wich store can i find viagra in nashville tn finasteride para que se usa mynitor.com viagra bloating efeito colateral xenical viagra dove costa meno inventore cialis lexapro and pseudoephedrine interaction maxalt buzz comprar misoprostol en argentina catmarca zofran aggravate opioid allergy orlistat tablets usa cephalexin dose canine is neurontin addictive how can get viagra in spain 2.5mg dose olanzapine long until zoloft works buy anti estrogens onde comprar xenical e quanto custa wallmart pharmacy cialis price does mobic contain codeine bactrim vomiting headache autocleaninglaundry.com allegra cunningham hbtaoxian.com xenical guercmorteo online does metformin have any side effects efek samping acyclovir 5 badcyclopedia.com steve whitaker cialis overthe counter diet pills vigora spray how to use original nexium pills buy mifepristone and misoprostol online is neurontin and lyrica the same levitra amsterdam gabapentin for migraines dosage imwithpete.net hashtonim.com what s the viagra triangle in chicago does everyone lose weight on wellbutrin when do you use metronidazole meastcompany.com viagra paypal only cyproheptadine and glucophage maxalt aspartame imitrex how lonfg does the average erecton last on viagra augmentin antibiotic price momandfitness.com proper cipro dose for diverticulitis treatment administering inderal with lanoxin mildreddeskinsjewelry.com infusedstudios.ca bactrim breakpoint can apo quetiapine be smoked dapoxetine bertibarots dosage can a cat be allergic to amoxicillin catholic.net momandfitness.com septra line hellogather.co.uk quetiapina seroquel 50 mg finnparanoids.org lisinopril forgotten tablets on holiday how to send viagra from pakistan gastroprotettore per augmentin

Interpreting Liturgical Norms

And more on exiting after Communion.
by Father Edward McNamara, LC | Source: Zenit.org

ROME, AUG. 19, 2008 (Zenit.org).- Answered by Legionary of Christ Father Edward McNamara, professor of liturgy at the Regina Apostolorum university.

Questions: Is there a Church document or scholarly treatise on "how" to interpret liturgical laws and norms? In civil law there is something known as "legal methods." This course and treatise contains a collection of "maxims" or accepted rules and standards of interpretation when reviewing cases or statutes. For example, I read in one of your responses an interpretation of the meaning and use of the word "fitting" as used in a particular liturgical norm. In civil law one could consult an official text or case to provide a standard for interpreting the term. Is that standard for interpretation discussed or defined anywhere either by the Church or by scholars? This seems to go to the heart of many challenges with interpreting Church norms. -- S.M., Westfield, Indiana

Answer: Although the Church’s canon law was first codified only in 1917, the codification reflected a long legal tradition eventually rooted in Roman law.

Thus, expert canon lawyers are able to drink from a deep wellspring of traditional interpretations in stating the meaning of laws. Most canonists will claim that doubts regarding the objective meaning of a law are fairly rare.

They do occur, however, and are usually clarified over time by an authentic interpretation promulgated by the legislative authority, by a new law that further clarifies the question at hand, or by development in canonical doctrine until a consensus is reached among the practitioners of the craft.

The Holy See has a special body dedicated to the authentic interpretation of laws. Its first decision regarding the 1983 Code of Canon Law dealt with the meaning of the word “iterum” (which can mean either "again" or "a second time") in Canon 917 which refers to reception of Communion. The decision fell on “a second time” as to how often one may receive Communion in one day.

All but the most essential aspects of liturgical law are found outside the Code of Canon Law and have never been completely codified into a single volume.

Within liturgical law we must distinguish between laws applicable to the ordinary and extraordinary forms of the Roman rite.

The rites of the extraordinary form are meticulously determined, a factor which endows this form with a particular beauty, reverence and spiritual force when celebrated with due care.

Over four centuries this rite generated a considerable body of jurisprudence gathered together in the volumes of authentic decrees of the former Congregation of Rites. Fortunately, this series of complex laws were frequently digested by sedulous scholars into descriptive manuals for use of priests and masters of ceremonies. Two of the best of these have been republished: A. Fortescue and J.B. O’Connell’s “The Ceremonies of the Roman Rite Described,” updated by Father Alcuin Reid, OSB, and the even more complete Italian “Compendio di Liturgia Pratica,” by L. Trimelloni.

The interpretation of the norms of the ordinary form presents some particular difficulties. The rite’s relative youth (at least as regards its rubrics) means that there is little in the way of historical jurisprudence that could clarify any doubtful passages.

There is also the difficulty that in general the rubrics quite deliberately eschew detailed descriptions of the rites so as to leave a certain degree of flexibility. For example, both the extraordinary and ordinary forms indicate that the priest pray with hands extended, but the latter rite makes no determination as to distance and position of the hands, leaving this up to the discretion of the celebrant.

Also, the existence of official translations can sometimes make interpretation difficult especially when translations vary the meaning of a text, even among countries sharing the same language. We saw this discrepancy in a recent column (Dec. 4, 2007) when some liturgists interpreted the English translation of the introduction to the lectionary to conclude that the Alleluia is omitted if not sung, an inference absent from the original Latin and other modern translations.

Unlike the liturgy, canon law has no official translations and only the Latin text may be used for legal purposes.

Another factor is the involvement of other instances of liturgical legislation besides the Holy See, such as legitimate customs and bishops’ conferences. The conferences may propose particular adaptations for their countries requiring approval from the Holy See before becoming particular law. They may also publish other documents such as guidelines on certain liturgical questions which, while not strictly legally binding, in practice become a legal point of reference.

In spite of these difficulties liturgical interpretation is not arbitrary.

The Congregation for Divine Worship and the Sacraments sometimes makes authentic interpretations of the liturgical texts. For example, it declared that No. 299 of the General Instruction of the Roman Missal, in stating that a celebrant's facing the people seemed “more desirable,” did not constitute a legal obligation.

Such authentic interpretations throw light on the mind of the legislator regarding similar texts and so help in resolving disputed points. In some cases historical decision regarding the extraordinary form are still useful in understanding the present form.

Another means is to examine the use of a particular word throughout the official documents so as to gauge its overall sense. Compared to civil law the totality of liturgical ordinances constitutes a relatively small corpus, and this makes such comparisons fairly easy.

Finally, again unlike much civil law, liturgical law is actually designed to be clearly understood by non-experts and so it actually means what it says based on a literal reading. Therefore priests, deacons, sacristans and other liturgical actors are absolved of the need for a law degree in preparing for Mass.

The difficulty in liturgical law is not usually in the understanding but in the faith, love and will to carry it out.

* * *

Follow-up: Leaving Right After Communion

July 21 column dealt with people who leave Mass early. Several readers asked about those who arrive late for Mass. We addressed this question in several columns, principally on Nov. 4 and Nov. 18, 2003, and on Oct. 23 and Nov. 6, 2007.

At the risk of appearing presumptuous, I hazard a little publicity directed toward newer subscribers to ZENIT’s services. It is quite possible that your question has already been touched upon in previous articles, and I recommend searching the liturgy section on the ZENIT Web page.

* * *

Readers may send questions to liturgy@zenit.org. Please put the word "Liturgy" in the subject field. The text should include your initials, your city and your state, province or country. Father McNamara can only answer a small selection of the great number of questions that arrive.

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows Catholic.net to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to Catholic.net right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular