guna flagyl lasix interventions gabapentin 300mg para que sirve phenergan for dogs buy online tamsulosine si perdoret can u drink on azithromycin one dose lisinopril getting off how much hydroxyzine pamoate for suicide is minoxidil the same as finasteride thu?»‘c singulair 4 mg what is a high level of neurontin in urine can i take theraflu while on buspirone how long does baclofen show up in a lab is it ok to take hydrochlorot and carvedilol pills ciprofloxacin ciprodin atarax 10mg for anxiety when can a person take antibiotik levofloxacin zyprexa 7.5mg can you get high off rizatriptan benzoate para que sirve las pastillas de septran why.push lasix slow how long do you bleed with 200 mg of cytotec l SUNNYDUVET.COM zyprexa 20 mg hs thuoc propranolol terbinafine drugs cost in indian rupees synthroid 75 mcg ingredients w long will it take zovirax eye ointment to work how do you know if cytotec worked for abortion SUNNYDUVET.COM cost of singulair with insurance zestril elevated heart rate while exercise tab.atarax price kegunaan feldene flash piroxicam 20 mg misoprostol tabelts price in srilanka does gabapentin build up in premier canine system misoprostol sirve retirar un mirena estradiol ii e411 amitriptyline withdrawal side effects reviews allegra tablet online booking in bng can you smoke marijuana while taking flagyl quitting lexapro after 2 months 1g of azithromycin make you nauseous astinenza da anafranil 25mg can topamax cause thyroid problems naproxen 500 mg tablet side effects can you use zovirax cream on shingles NEOHAIRINDO.COM clomid cyst 10dpo etodolac high khasiat acyclovir piroxicam 10 mg dosage can i take micartis plus with synthroid cheap levitra u.s starting lexapro 2.5 mg is metronidazole safe while breastfeeding cialis price uk apa khasiat meloxicam 15 ml been on prozac 2 weeks does coreg cr cause fungal infection cymbalta 60 mg withdrawal symptoms efectos secundarios del medicamento coreg 12.5 mg what decongestant can i take with lisinopril is mobic 15mg stronger than norco birth defects valtrex buy metronidazole 500mg online metoprolol tartrate oral to iv weakness and metronidazole 600 mg price of anastrozole 1mg from teva zovirax discount coupons augmentin 312 mg syrup dosage how much does fluoxetine cost cara kerja captopril can i take mulberry zuccarin with lisinopril pssd piroxicam does neurontin have sulfa in it does kamagra work for women what is prednisone 5mg used for bronchitis 2700mg neurontin side effects where is celebrex swimming commercial filmed will welbutin help stop sugar cravings from zoloft provera 10 day pill como tomar dostinex 5g aquatic azithromycin vs azithromycin cialis and huge erections historia del medicamento lipitor does bactrim cur bv inderal bei examens stress dosierung clumpy discharge after taking metronidazole pill cialis commercial actresses merck proscar can u take claritin with clonazepam and celexa singulair when waresoff acid reflux due to zoloft clomid and ultrasound monitoring sandoz azithromycin liquid chlamydia doxycycline monohydrate used for pnemonia mobic 415 leaflet for indocin gel dexamethasone 4mg tab in india with price kegunaan obat levofloxacin d00mg celebrex 100mg capsule side effects of men taking to much clomid kelebihan happy nexium 150r provera 20 mg long term doxycycline use can you snort strattera 60 mg side effects of prednisone short 7 days safe dosages of lasix in elderly levitra 20mg vardenafil 50 mg viagra equal to cialis can yo crush augmentin gabapentin and alcohol withdrawal hydroxyzine brand name uk cheap atarax no prescription lowest prices cialis hoe gebruikt je misoprostol 200 arimidex 1 baclofen can it get you high sonics allegra 2 dostinex 2 comprimidos como tomar cat giardi metronidazole and flagyl 50mg generic viagra neurontin 600 mg used for pastilla ciprom 500mg nitroglycerin lingual spray .4 mg metformin after age 70 pfizer celebrex sales does bactrim kill yeast how much does lexapro cost in australia difference between teva citalopram and mar citalopram does ciprotab tablet good for pregnant person quetiapine lawsuit trazodone high street price phenergan pregnancy over the counter in u.s.a buy actos skin shoes does neurontin help cyclothymia tngo 1 mes de embarazo puedo usar las cytotec buy generic remeron kegunaan salep dexamethasone ciprodel otico how long does it take to get over a bactrim reaction moduretic buy online sildenafil 40mg troche aggrenox vs plavix vs coumadin stabilanol fluconazole 100mg what is biotech ciprofloxacin capsuls use for ophthalmic ointment zovirax during pregnancy augmentin brands in nigeria taking amoxicillin 500mg as suppository does coreg cause swelling water retension generic zyban proventil burning in lungs NEOHAIRINDO.COM levitra 20mg street value do you get dizzy on escitalopram and klonopin verapamil tablet price can lyrica be taken with lexapro celexa losing effectiveness can i give my 9 month old albuterol sulfate do amitriptyline and rock stars para que se receta el metoprolol buy xenical canada generic viagra forum uk can i buy cialis over the counter in australia thyroidectomy without thyroxine naprosyn 500mgcost does 450 mgs of wellbutrin xl cause bruxism how long after taking cytotec are you allowed to pee metformin xr foamy urine baguio cytotec for sale xenical no prescription needed propecia and finasterode combination topiramate 50 mg en espanol can 1 cytotec kill 1 month pregnant lisinopril zestril20 efectis secundarios topamax skutki uboczne excessive sweating gabapentin cialis in kosovo how many 500mg of azithromycin for chlamydia metoprolol buy uk atorvastatina vs omega 3 linezolid injection monograph is dangerous to take fluconazole 150 mg for 7 days viagra prices nz doxycycline 20mg, dog how soon does lisinopril take effect in the body how much hydrochlorothiazide will kill you can you take lomotil and zofran while breastfeeding rizatriptan odt price gabapentin 300 mg cong dung zoloft withdrawal duration can you shoot buspirone hydrochloride 30 mg propranolol 160 mg tablets actos 500 mg power v8 viagra cost in bangladesh buy levitra hong kong propecia 5 mg dangers effect of olanzapine om mirtazapine what is ic amoxicillin shelf life open package cytotec prozac sales rank lisinopril 20 mg. 12.5hctz lamisil side effects and candida can you take nyquil with desyrel 100 mg viagra side effects cual es el precio del anafranil valsartan side effect anxiety buy priligy dapoxetine uk quetiapine prices in mexico telmisartan 20 price of lexapro without insurance can you take metronidazole with imodium polypose singulair amoxil bd 875 mg bula augmentin treats chest infectiins over the counter flagyl tablets in south africa how soon after taking amitriptyline can i take ambien propecia no results after 4 months fibromyalgia nortriptyline dosage apetito cyproheptadine in s.a pharmacies bahan active azithromycin nizoral 200mg tablets dosage for jock itch gabriel lisinopril tablet doxepin online kaufen brand name synthroid vs generic cheapest place to buy estrace cream use of escitalopram tablets for 20 years sideaffets can i take aleve with doxycycline hyclate genuine viagra no prescription bactrim and hearing loss walgreens albuterol inhaler candida albicans diflucan oral indikasi salep feldene piroksikam topamax side effects forum zoloft 50 mg pakistan y glucophage use doxycycline side effect women levitra in belgian pharmacies medroxyprogesterone acetate 150 mg price minumacyclovir400 mg zoloft and cough drops anti depressant for low.comenergy topamax dosage mood stabilizer amlodipine 0.625mg uk cost side effects of high doses of prednisone sildenafil analogues suppliers velcade no prescription ketoconazole 500 mg what happens if augmentin is not refrigerated zoloft and diphenhydramine hcl diovan hct 25 mg eefects of yasmin and azithromycin para que sirve clomiphene citrate 150mg buy cardizem online equivalente natural de seroquel lipitor cost blur cross rx can i take meloxicam 15 mg with cyclobenzaprine 7.5 mg how long will it take for bactrim to cause infection bupropion and atorvastatin will zoloft dosage 25 mg work generic cialis online coupon meloxicam 3mg is prozac prescibed in australia efectos secundarios del metformin en un ct scan viagra kamagra cheap u s a viagra 100 3000mg can i take amlodipine besylate with chlorothiazide cure yeast infection bactrim kamagra online kopen forum diflucan 150 mg pfizer price what is 9pm sildenafil buy zithromax europe propecia shed after 1 year lisinopril en colombia efectos secundarios cialis norvasc pka of montelukast by usp ubat seroquel xr para que sirve atorvastatin plendil 5 mg tablete metoprolol 95 mg how many hour does baclofen stay in the system salep lamisil cream can levofloxacin winthrop 750 give you a face rash erythromycin order online zyprexa 10 mg bijsluiter conjugated linoleic acid buy online levitra 3 free trial voucher reaksi pil cytotec 400 mg azithromycin 7169 when will propecia be generic in the us what will happen if i stop taking clopidogrel bisulfate flagyl cost without insurance nizoral hair loss ireland levaquin infiltration can doctors prescribe generic cialis viagra cheap buy minipress xl 5mg dosage levofloxacin 500 mg bula purchase amoxicillin buspar during first trimester buy rizatriptan benzoate online propecia uk boots diflucan weaken birth control neurontin for toothache is clonidine 0.1 dialyzable what is ciprofloxacin hexal used to treat flagyl generic names gabapentin 300 mg erowid how often should i use ketoconazole novale lotion why do we take atorvastatin cholecalciferol tablets amoxicillin duration flagyl sanofi buy nizoral cream canada deta lab male enhance liquid cialis prednisone onset and duration amaryl 4mg price in pak 24 hour kamagra next day delivery uk fluoxetine without gelatin how much does proventil cost at walmart premarin in pakistan zofran odt nhs is doxycycline used for ecoli infection terbinafine hydrochloride 10mg clopidogrel half tablet montelukast kastair 5mg zithromax suspension 15ml over counter in south africa can u take ibuprofen with tamsulosin and omeprazole buy strattera india metformin tab 500 mg cost amlodipine besylate 5mg generic cymbalta cost 100mg tablets of viagra fluoxetine prozac capsule rate in india levitra 10 mg cost plavix cost walmart clomid acupuncture twins gynecomastia with benicar neurontin 800 mg para que sirve can i get my wife pregnant while on viagra viagra delgra coupon para diovan 80 mg harga lasix 40mg buy accutane free shipping metformin 500 mg pcos side effects shelf life atenolol tablets magkano ang ketoconazole cream azithromycin tablet cipla for tonsils how long before fluconazole works on dogs dutasteride ireland lamisil tablets price uk can i take a hydrochlorothiazide pill with a losartan does augmentin 875 mg treat meningitis how to cycle nolvadex cost of cialis from india how often is clonidine 75 mcg can be given nizoral price increase metformin 1000 mg tab zyd flagyl and ovulation colesterol y escitalopram can you smoke quetiapine foil difference between paxil and amitriptyline regenpure shampoo for prescription uk is dexamethasone tablets appetite booster several propecia sheds tamsulosin sale paxil 12.5 azithromycin how many tablets 500mg for gonerear memory and long term atorvastatin can escitalopram and mirtazapine be taken together cozaar 100mg tablets misoprostol venezuela aplicacion will flomax show up on a drug test can u take oxycodone with zithromax yang menjual misoprostol cytotec di apotik surabaya bactrim 5 weeks pregnant montelukast 5mg in the morning 5mg at night cymbalta recreational use

Just Punishment

Canon lawyers are dubious about the prospects for excommunication of Catholic politicians who support abortion, but other disciplinary measures are available.
by Brian ONeel | Source: Contributor Write
In northern California, Sacramento-area residents recently opened their newspapers to learn that for the first time since he entered Congress, Rep. John Doolittle, a stalwart abortion opponent, would have a primary challenger in this year’s Republican primary election.

While the man who would be challenging the five-term congressman criticized Doolittle on several grounds, he was particularly harsh in his characterization of the conservative legislator’s pro-life stance: “His hard anti-abortion stand is unacceptable,” said the challenger, Dr. Bill Kirby. “I’m a Catholic, but I believe what a woman does with her body should be between her and her God, not the government.”

If successful in his bid to oust Doolittle, Kirby would join a host of other Catholic elected officials around the world who profess beliefs directly contrary to those of their Church, particularly on the issue of abortion.

This phenomenon is not confined to the United States. The Canadian prime minister, Jean Chretien, identifies himself as a Catholic and is an outspoken proponent of legal abortion, as is Joe Clark, the former Tory prime minister. Indeed, in the nations of the industrialized West, scores of prominent Catholics who hold elective office are not pro-life. But it is in the US that the role of “pro-choice” Catholic politicians has caused the most heated debate.

A vivid demonstration of the power of pro-abortion Catholic legislators came when the US Congress attempted to override President Bill Clinton’s vetoes of bills that would have outlawed partial-birth abortions. Despite the gruesome nature of the procedure, and the unusually vocal admonitions from the US bishops, the effort to override the presidential veto twice fell just short of the necessary two-thirds majority in the Senate. In each case, nominally Catholic senators provided the margin of defeat.

The Excommunication Option
Both Pope John Paul II and various bishops’ conferences around the world have reiterated, time and again, the responsibility of all Catholics—and especially those in public life—to foster a culture of life. In 1998 the US bishops released a document called Living the Gospel of Life. In that document—released as the debate on partial-birth abortion was at its zenith—the bishops affirmed:

Catholics who . . . serve in public leadership positions have an obligation to place their faith at the heart of their public service, particularly on issues regarding the sanctity of human life. We urge those Catholic officials who . . . depart from the Church teaching on the inviolability of human life in their public life . . . to reflect on the grave contradiction of assuming public office and presenting themselves as credible Catholics when their actions on fundamental issues of human life are not in agreement with Church teaching . . . . No appeal to policy, procedure, majority will, or pluralism ever excuses a public official from defending life to the greatest extent possible.

The remarkable thing, however, is that as such statements from Catholic bishops have become increasingly clear and emphatic, the voting performance of Catholic politicians has become steadily worse. The resulting frustration has caused some Catholics to look for new ways to bring pressure to bear on pro-abortion Catholic officials. In Sacramento, California, one pastor, Msgr. Edward Kavanagh, went so far as to write that the ostensibly Catholic Governor Gray Davis “has brought on himself automatic excommunication” because of his support for abortion.

While few Church leaders in the US have mentioned the possibility of excommunication for politicians who support abortion, that option has been explored in other countries. In Mexico City last year, Cardinal Norberto Rivera responded to efforts to liberalize abortion laws in his country by saying “anyone who promotes or practices abortion, including legislators and governors, will be excommunicated by the Church.” Colombia’s bishops also mentioned excommunication during a July debate on that country’s abortion laws. And in Peru, Lima’s Cardinal Juan Luis Cipriani instructed pastors to deny Communion to public officials who persisted in public support for abortion.

Emboldened by those prelates, thousands of American Catholics have signed a petition asking Pope John Paul II to pronounce excommunication on prominent American pro-abortion politicians such as Senators Ted Kennedy and Tom Daschle. “It is impossible to be Catholic and pro-abortion at the same time,” explains Judie Brown, the president of American Life League, who is among the leaders of the petition drive. “Pro-abortion Catholic lawmakers have become a stumbling block for faithful Catholics.” The petition lists as defendants approximately 50 members of Congress, as well as a number of other current or former political office holders.

Is It Realistic?
Do Catholic politicians who publicly reject the teachings of their faith deserve excommunication? At first glance the Catechism of the Catholic Church (2272) seems clear: “Formal cooperation in an abortion constitutes a grave offense. The Church attaches the canonical penalty of excommunication to this crime against human life.” As many faithful Catholics see it, a vote for legal abortion, or for the funding of abortions, constitutes formal cooperation in the act. Thus many people believe that a pro-abortion Catholic politician incurs excommunication.

But according to several canon lawyers, the issue is not so clear. Phil Gray, a canonist in Ohio, explains:

Canonically speaking, “formal cooperation” involves the doctor who performs the abortion, the nurse who assists, the woman having the abortion, the man who agrees to take his wife or girlfriend, the person who drives the woman to the clinic—and even that last one is questionable. With legislators, what you have is probably best termed “material cooperation.”

Edward Peters, professor of canon law for the Institute of Pastoral Theology at Ave Maria University in Ypsilanti, Michigan, agrees. “You can only incur excommunication for a specific offense,” he emphasizes. “Although having an abortion can result in an excommunication, governmental support for abortion is not a similar offense.”

Some pro-life activists make the argument that a vote for taxpayer funding of abortion is a specific act, enabling poor women to procure abortions. That, they argue, is formal cooperation. But Peters replies:

People who make that argument are possibly using Canon 1329 [which prescribes excommunication for accomplices in such offenses as abortion], and are trying to characterize these people as accomplices. The problem is that in order to be an accomplice to an action, you have to be able to show that, but for this vote that freed up X number of dollars, this abortion would not have taken place. What if the bill passes by two votes? Whose vote do you blame?

Peters also makes a more general point about the interpretation of canon law: “Canon 18 is clear that whenever you’re talking about sanctions, you have to read those canons very narrowly—as narrowly as can reasonably be interpreted and still mean something.”

Neither Peters nor Gray believes petitioning the Vatican to excommunicate prominent politicians will succeed. “Anybody can request that from Rome,” says Gray. “But authorities there will turn to the principle of subsidiarity. Local bishops need to address this first . . . . They’re the ones that need to be doing something about these guys.”

The Political Options
Both canonists agree, however, that politicians who promote the culture of death by their pro-abortion stance are guilty of grave sin. “If someone takes this sort of public stand while also receiving Communion, they put themselves out to be practicing Catholics, even though they’re putting themselves at odds with the Church,” adds Gray. It is a grave sin “because they are adhering to a belief that is contrary to the magisterium of the Church and contrary to the natural law.” He goes on to point out: “Canon 750 says you are not to hold anything contrary to the truth as taught by the Catholic Church.”

Germain Grisez, a noted Christian ethicist at Mount St. Mary’s College in Emmitsburg, Maryland, believes that anyone who supports legal abortion should reconsider seeking public office. And he rejects the notion that a public official could be personally opposed to abortion, yet support the legality of the procedure:

If they say “I’m personally opposed, but . . . ,” it seems to me that maybe they’re being insincere and saying this because it’s politically advantageous. On the other hand, if they’re sincere in this, it seems to me they’re confused. Opposition to abortion is not a matter of taste. If one is personally opposed to it, it is because one recognizes that it is the killing of an unborn individual and a grave injustice is involved. If someone thinks otherwise, they’re deeply confused. It seems to me that someone that badly confused about something that obvious or who is insincere is not a trustworthy person to hold any public office.

Some Catholic politicians have explained their pro-abortion votes by saying that they do not have the right to impose their own religious beliefs on other citizens. But William May, a professor of moral theology at the John Paul II Institute in Washington, DC, answers that argument:

The point of when human life begins is not a religious belief, so you can’t say you’re forcing your religious beliefs on someone. Rather, it is a scientific fact on which there is clear agreement even among leading abortion advocates. Second, the sanctity of human life is not merely Catholic doctrine but part of humanity’s global ethical heritage and our nation’s founding principle. Finally, democracy is not served by silence. Real pluralism depends on people of conviction struggling vigorously to advance their beliefs by every ethical and legal means at their disposal.

Other Sanctions
If Catholic politicians who oppose their Church on the issue of abortion are not automatically excommunicated, are there other canonical penalties that could be applied? Edward Peters says that a bishop who wants to censure a pro-abortion Catholic politician has several options:

Canon 1369 says, “A person is to be punished with a just penalty, who, at a public event or assembly or in a published writing . . . gravely harms public morals or . . . excites contempt for religion or the Church.” What if you’re speaking on the floor for an abortion bill? You can be punished with anything from a reprimand all the way up to excommunication.

Certainly a bishop could refuse the Eucharist to someone who persists in a grave sin. In fact even a parish priest could make that decision. “The question is have they been warned?” says Gray. He continues:

Canon 915 says that those who obstinately persevere in manifest grave sin cannot be admitted to Communion. “Obstinate” means you have to be warned; you have to be told it’s a grave sin; you have to be told to stop; and you have to be told what the penalty would be. If you ignore that warning and continue to cling to that sinfulness publicly, at that point several punishments are an option.

In America today, Gray concedes, “There’s not a Catholic politician who doesn’t know what the Church teaches. That means they’re conscious of the fact that their support of abortion is a grave evil.” Nevertheless, he argues that they should not be refused the Eucharist until they have received a formal warning.

Other options also exist. Charles Wilson of the St. Joseph Foundation in San Antonio, Texas—an organization that specializes in the application of canon law—advocates putting some politicians on trial in an ecclesial court, so that a fair public hearing of the evidence could be had. There is also talk of making a public denunciation of a public official before that person’s bishop.

Nonetheless, it is with the bishops themselves that the real power resides, and few bishops in recent memory have taken action against public dissenters. One exception was Bishop Fabian Bruskewitz of Lincoln, Nebraska, who in the mid-1990s excommunicated members of Catholics for a Free Choice. Just prior to the 2000 election, the late Bishop James McHugh of the Diocese of Rockville Center, New York, directed his pastors to remove from any parish position those who held pro-abortion views; he explicitly included public figures who claimed to be “personally opposed” but showed themselves—as he put it—”unwilling to integrate their moral principles with civic responsibilities.”

Creating A Martyr
Of course, if a bishop imposes any form of discipline on a pro-abortion Catholic politician, that individual could quickly attain the status of a martyr-figure among dissenting Catholics and other proponents of abortion. For some Catholic officials, defiance of the Church is a carefully calculated political stance.

David Carlin has an interesting perspective on that issue, as a former majority leader of the Rhode Island state Senate and a member of Democrats for Life. Of one prominent pro-abortion Catholic politician from Rhode Island, he says:

He could get elected here as a pro-lifer, but that would bring him grief from the fanatics on the other side, and it would ruin his chances to climb even further up the national Democratic ladder. Morally and religiously, he has taken the wrong stand, but politically he has taken the smart stand.

Carlin observes that while many Catholic constituents disapprove of the official’s stance on abortion, they nonetheless continue to cast ballots for him. In fact, he sees this voting pattern repeated regularly—not only in Rhode Island but all across America. The net result, he says, is: “The more Catholics a state has, the more likely it will send pro-choicers to Washington, and the fewer Catholics it has, the less likely.”

“In the end,” Carlin says, “the problem isn’t Catholic politicians: It’s the Catholic voters.”

Reprinted with permission from Catholic World Report. All rights reserved. Brian O’Neel writes from Sacramento, California.

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Published by: Deborah Perry
Date: 2013-03-30 09:48:28
I think that the Church has a great responsibility to stand up to these politicians. It may go a long way in the way people vote.

Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular