isoptin 240 mg side effects tab galcipro acyclovir 400 mg untuk scabies finasteride 1 month mark buy doxycycline usa reaction to 100 mg of prozac much does clozapine cost sertraline standard dosage prednisone 15 mg for 3 days can chloramphenicol and amoxicillin work together 300mg zoloft zombo how long does ciprofloxacin 500 mg stay in your system orlistat uk supply sildenafil 50gm amoxicillin 875 mg and beer clonidine for the treetment of bot flushes can cytotec abort a 4weeks pregnancy ciprone tablet for what clopidogrel cost with medicare generic drug for lanoxin bactrim uti 3 days can i use flagyl during 3rd trimester jock itch fluconazole dosage 150 mg anafranil comentarios amitriptyline versus cymbalta for pain valacyclovir 1000 mg tablet glucophage 200mg tamoxifen 20 mg price skin yellow on plavix flagyl 200 mg metronidazole will it get rid of cysts buy seroquel xr 300 mg metronidazole interfere with birth control pause fra strattera hydrochlorothiazide generic equivalent dosage erythromycine pour adult que pasa si tomo cytotec y estoy amamantando is it ok the chew acyclovir tablets orlistat reeshape 60mg buy plavix and dry mouth walmart acyclovir 800 mg 5 times a day for shingles diovan 40 mg you jizz fineviagra fish or bird doxycycline for kennel cough tabkets can clomiphene citrate cause my period to be shorter amlodipine 10 mg and simvastatin 40 mg pil farmoten captopril 12.5mg propecia shedding timeline price comparison levitra cvs walgreen walmart levofloxacina e bortedella henselae can i take bromocriptine and propranolol together azithromycin ip 500 mg injection metronidazole gel costs can celebrex make you angry zoloft 100 to 75 mg side effects weaning trazodone mx71 does norvasc 2.5 give side effects grossesse et zithromax topamax mixed with penicillin stopping 4 mg of prednisone can 25mg of seroquel cause weight gain buy nexium no script levitra price in dubai kegunaan amoxicillin untuk jerawat 50 mg synthroid dosage misoprostol venta panama generic viagra online with no prescription dog ate diovan help gurning on sertraline vyvanse lexapro interaction purchase plavix drug feldene fiale uso nel cane tamsulosin ranbaxy capsule mga 0.4 mg cialis effect on men without erectile dysfunction levitra order pharmacy amoxicillin pampalaglag levaquin renal dosing levofloxacin 500 mg tab cena novartis diovan a valsartan adalah how long before prednisone works on a rash having a can you drink on zoloft how long does flagyl stay in your system misoprostol en huancayo peru levofloxacin article 30 referral how much is 5mcg side effects of synthroid where can i buy kamagra oral jelly in dubai cipro and flagyl antibiotic treatment and fertilization south beach diet buy viagra topamax alcohol interaction zyvox bacterial coverage montelukast g6pd lamisil 1 30ml spray uso cutaneo me tome via oral la misoprostol cuanto tarda el efecto side effects of lowering synthroid dosage cialis 20mg uae price shelf life of ciprofloxacin lexapro 20 mg cost spray lamisil liver damage is a side effect of topamax extra dry mouth que es azithromycin 1 gm powder packet poison ivy prednisone 10 day dose metronidazole dose rabbits rash treated with prednisone 70 mg tab augmentin 625mg price valacyclovir 1 mg tab flagyl cream availiable in india apa itu remeron celebrex mims harga metronidazole injection i.p. prednisone deltasone 50 mg laryngitis bupropion contraindicated eating disorders doxycycline for sepsis RETROFITREBATE.COM how to treat stiffness when taking bactrim before and after use of doxycycline for impetigo taken clomid twice yet no pregnacy augmentin fara reteta in uk will anti depressants makke ne high serophene e ecitalopram suppliers of viagra in uk can ciprofloxacin treat abscessed tooth fluconazole once every 3 days 1500 mg seroquel suizid is 15 mg of prozac effective strattera 50 mg street price order doxycycline online australia buy plavix tablets do they make fake kamagra lexapro 90 mg levofloxacin pharex can cause cough ciprofloxacin 750 mg twice daily can you drunk alcohol with albuterol buying viagra from canada online prednisone 14 days poison ivy celexa recall generic meloxicam tablets how to discontinue bupropion azithromycin 200mg price of quetiapine rbx 300mg tablets can i use zovirax on 3 year old plavix generic alternative what is metformin hcl er 500 mg used for bowels levofloxacin 10 days anto depressants citalopram versus lustral nizoral sampon 20 mg pret quees nexium montelukast doxofylline tablet distributor buy amoxicillin in uk fast delivery from holland side effects of too much lasix with dogs what is prednisone 6 day pack and the direction buspar how long is it in your system 2.5 50 mg prednisone missed one day feel weird where to buy venom diet pills in south africa atarax overdose in infant what effect acyclovir 200 mg dosage symptoms when stopping isoptin 240 sr propecia uk cost zovirax dm philippines price of amoxicillin trihydrate el misoprostol sirve para abortar a as 12 semanas gave my dog 500mg of amoxicillin clomiphene citrate 50 should take at bed time terbinafine lamisil for birds acyclovir denk 400 mg three times daily for 5 days when is the best time to take buspar can my 2year old use chloramphenicol revista caras online gratis cialis generic capsules clomiphene citrate 50 mg buy uk allergic reaction to keflax amd bactrim sublingual tadalafil pharmacokinetics what is an equal dose of propranolol to 20 mg. timolol street value of buspirone hydrochloride doxepin 50 nebenwirkungen metronidazole contraindications for vetinary bactrim uti 3 days propecia works fine on receding hairlines nexium 20 mg tablet buy generic atorvastatin does black pepper affect coumadin hunger and headace day 2 after clomid does alcohol counteract antivirals how does your body process metoprolol succinate out what is the dose for cipro for uti cialis generic discount mifepristone e misoprostol para abortar ciprofloxacin tinidazole is use for ghonorea does kaiser cover cialis farmacias q vendan misoprostol cap fed can i take metronidazole tablets while on my periods SUNNYDUVET.COM is metformin tab zyd immediat release selectra antidepressant celexa does really work dapoxetine phenergan 9 month old viagra prices singapore seachem metronidazole petsmart atenolol 50 mg online baclofen toxicity in dogs zyprexa overdoze forum augmentin es 600 package insert augmentin pediatrico periactin entra en l seguridad social thyroxine 12.5 normal or not cialis brand or generic can i take pepto bismol while taking cipro flagyl 500 mg neye iyi gelir is atarax safe for sleep apnea buy metronidazole veterinary donde se puede encontrar la pastilla cytotec en rep.dom que es metforminhcl tabletas can metronidazole cause fatiguefor dogs is topamax safe gambar metronidazole untuk obat keputihan misoprostol south african dosages lisinopril 10 mg alas cuantas horas ase efecto montelukast 10mg tablets coupons tamsulosin hcl 0.2 mg how much is zithromax in nigeria levothyroxine 75 meg tablet strattera adderall prednisone 21 pack directions celebrex for tendonitis diffrence between montelukast and acebrophylline schedule use of prednisone dogs teva escitalopram irbesartan 300 mg tablet precio azithromycin 750 bactrim in the morning wine at night seroquel taper schedule iv furosemide to oral furosemide conversion topiramate cause facial hair growth zoloft withdrawal neck zaps what is zestril 25 mg citalopram sickle cell lipitor 300 levofloxacin dosage for kidney infection oral jels for erection ireland cpt code for baclofen test topamax 300 septran levofloxacin get high plavix generic europe will flagyl 500 mg treat staph infection paroxetine mg voltaren 80mg can lisinopril cause headaches propranolol hydrochlorid decadron 8 mg compresse does zofran come over the counter how many long can amoxicillin cure gonorrhea buy zovirax 5 cream cipro eggs casa allegra house in australia 900 seroquel xr at night taking celebrex 200mg with panadol 1000mg how much is azithromycin 500mg at target 2 tablets que es la bupropion hcl 40 mg citalopram 10mg tablets dose cialis online how safe phenergan 5137 medicines containing isotretinoin in india flagyl 250 mg tablets for dogs side effects for dogs amlodipine dosage in italiano is lexapro dangerous dr diflucan length of time to work metronidazole same for dogs and humans order accutane online canada fosamax dosage cost periactin appetite stimulant a comprehensive view does amoxicillin treat strep b dosage 0n cytotec f0r 6 weeks pregnant where can i buy atenolol online augmentin 1000 pret ciprofloxacin prospect de 500 mg side effects when stopping adco paroxetine 20mg what is the street value of 300 milligram neurontin natural substitution for tetracycline dosage for 48 prednisone 10mg gaviscan and atorvastatin strattera 40 mg how long does it last purchase viagra without prescription allegra 180 mg uses azithromycin hearing loss side effects how much does 100 pills of 800 mg neurontin cost order rizatriptan terbinafine 250mg para que sir e azilect and celecoxib viagra plus 400 mg can lasix be taken in the evening is zoloft 5mg the same as sertraline 50 mg voltaren 125 diclofenac natr aspen atorvastatin vs winthrop vs lipitor twitching from stopping cymbalta mayoclinic dry cough with lisinopril levaquin cephalosporin valacyclovir 1gm staph infection can you take antiviral drug with beer after three days amoxicillin rash indication of bactrim syrup amlodipine 4mg buy bactrim mexico topamax 93 155 3dciprofloxacin scan phoenix az lexapro 7 weeks levitra 5mg enough ibuprophen amoxillin ect ic quetiapine fumarate and ginseng erection pills and jelly for sale in gauteng fungsi pil flagyl estrace online kaufen viagra dhe efekti i saj cheap propecia online pharmacy hyzaar precio mexico cheap viagra fast shipping si ya comi es malo tomarme la pasta cytotec voltaren 100mg suppositories teva antidepressant side effect septra dosage 250 norvasc weird dreams super kamagra tablets holland generic valtrex online pharmacy buy flagyl 500mg online cat doxycycline tablets viagra price drop uk cost for daily cialis side effects of prednisone in women taking cymbalta without food kegunaan salep atau obat metronidazole efectos secundarios de premarin 0625 mg para que sirve atorvastatin captopril sandoz 50mg buy nolvadex online credit card is acyclovir taken during varicella pneumonia clomiphene tablets ip 100mg IMAJJI.COM how long can a canine take flagyl500mg cipro for cold sores zyvoxam 600 mg ampolletas lamisil nails skin body soap erythromycin 875 alendronate sodium tablets usp 5 mg toro herbal viagra atarax drop for baby 4 months buy lexapro online uk can u snort neurontin how does work nizoral 2 percent shampoo taking of 15 mg amlodipine price of 10 tablete revatio 20mg tabs how to overdose on 5 mg amlodipine tetracycline slurry how to shoot up 200 mg seroquel voltaren emulgelspray prednisone 20mg for plantar fasciitis side effects of prednisone dogs runny nose buspirone back ache can i quit wellbutrin after a week propranolol ethical 40 mig para que sirve is sertraline covered by medicare permament effects of luvox how should i cycle the albuterol for fat burning allegra 6 centrifuge rpm to g florida doctors who treat levaquin side effects where i can buy original misoprostol in the philippines gabapentin can it help with toothache nerve side effects of clonidine and incontinence el cytotec para abortar es caro en mexico buy nizoral cream australia buy metformin uk allegra 120 mg tablet accutane online safe order zithromax price about tablet isotretinoin 40 mg in india lisinopril react with carvedilol cialis generic fda approved pharmacy after course of azithromycin yellow phlegm persists harga salep ketoconazole buying cytotec brasil

A Commentator's Role

Inappropriate tasks Commentators must avoid.
by Father Edward McNamara, LC | Source:

Question: Can you provide any insight into the role of the commentator? The commentator is quite common here in the United States, and every church seems to have a different job description for this person. For example, in our parish before the start of Mass the commentator greets the people, asks if anyone is celebrating a birthday or anniversary or is visiting. Then there is the usual happy birthday or anniversary song. Then the commentator gives a 5- to 6-minute reflection and words of advice for the coming week. During the Mass the commentator sits in the sanctuary; directs the people via hand signals whether to sit, kneel, rise; calls out the music/song that we will be singing, etc. At the end of Mass, before the final benediction he/she reads the announcements; gives comments and their take on the homily; and thanks the people, etc. I have suggested this is taking the role of "commentator" a bit too far, but cannot find anything in the GIRM to help back up my claim. Can you help? -- M.P., Keaau, Hawaii

Answer: I think you are correct that this is taking the role of commentator a bit too far.

The liturgical function of the commentator is described, along with that of sacristans, ushers, and those who take up the collection, in the General Instruction of the Roman Missal, No. 105:

“The commentator […] provides the faithful, when appropriate, with brief explanations and commentaries with the purpose of introducing them to the celebration and preparing them to understand it better. The commentator's remarks must be meticulously prepared and clear though brief. In performing this function the commentator stands in an appropriate place facing the faithful, but not at the ambo.”

No. 352 of the GIRM later insists on the need for preparation: “Since, indeed, a variety of options is provided for the different parts of the Mass, it is necessary for the deacon, the lectors, the psalmist, the cantor, the commentator, and the choir to be completely sure before the celebration which text for which each is responsible is to be used and that nothing be improvised. Harmonious planning and carrying out of the rites will great assistance in disposing the faithful to participate in the Eucharist.”

This is all that is said about the commentator. By saying that the commentator intervenes “when appropriate” could be interpreted that this function is best used whenever there is something special, such as a confirmation or ordination that requires some explanation.

The insistence that this office’s functions must be meticulously prepared and are specifically orientated toward helping the people live the celebration would seem to exclude spontaneous interventions and unprepared remarks based on the homily.

Likewise it is highly debatable that the assembly’s singing "Happy Birthday" is the most appropriate spiritual preparation for Mass.

It must also be remembered that GIRM, No. 31, specifically assigns the presentation of the rite and any concluding summaries to the presiding priest and not to the commentator: “It is also up to the priest, in the exercise of his office of presiding over the gathered assembly, to offer certain explanations that are foreseen in the rite itself…. In addition, he may give the faithful a very brief introduction to the Mass of the day (after the initial Greeting and before the Act of Penitence), to the Liturgy of the Word (before the readings), and to the Eucharistic Prayer (before the Preface), though never during the Eucharistic Prayer itself; he may also make concluding comments to the entire sacred action before the dismissal.”

GIRM, No. 50, however, foresees the possibility that the brief introduction to the Mass of the day may also be assigned to a lay minister.

Although it is not a specific function of the commentator to call out the songs or make the usual announcements at the end of Mass, it is practical so as not to multiply the number of people in the sanctuary. All the same, it would be better to find another means to designate the songs so as to limit interruptions to the prescribed rite.

The duty of indicating, whenever necessary, the posture to be adopted by the people has traditionally fallen on the deacon, or on the cantor. It is usually only necessary when some special rite is celebrated, such as the Litany of Saints during ordinations.

The duty of indicating, whenever necessary, the posture to be adopted by the people has traditionally fallen on the deacon or the cantor. But No. 43 of the GIRM also allows this task to be assigned to another lay minister if necessary: “With a view to a uniformity in gestures and postures during one and the same celebration, the faithful should follow the directions which the deacon, lay minister, or priest gives according to whatever is indicated in the Missal.”

I believe that such indications are usually only necessary when some special rite is celebrated, such as the Litany of Saints during ordinations or in places where there are frequent visitors from different parts of the world who might be used to other practices.

Otherwise I believe that it is better to leave aside choreographic gestures and indications for regular Sunday Masses. Some of these might have been necessary at the beginning of the reform until people got used to the new rite. But after nearly 40 years of practice I think most Catholics now know when to kneel, sit and stand.

Something similar can be said about the persistent habit of cantors raising their hands, or saying “Response” after each psalm verse or invocation of the prayer of the faithful. It was all very well when the responsorial psalm and the intercessions were liturgical novelties, but by now it is sometimes a bit theatrical and distracting.

It is worth noting that such gestures are studiously avoided in papal Masses celebrated in Rome. The faithful easily interpret the appropriate moment to intervene as indicated by a pause, the cadence of the melody, or the intervention of the organ.

* * *

Follow-up: Kissing the Hands of a New Priest

The theme of kissing of hands of a new priest (see
June 10) brought to the fore another question regarding the use of hands.

A New Orleans reader asked: “Should there be silence (i.e., no music) during the imposition of hands at an ordination? I believe that the Pontifical says something like, 'Saying nothing' the bishop and then the other priests present impose hands. The force of the Latin, if I recall it correctly, seems to be simply that the priests say nothing (no prayer, no "God bless," no "You made it, Bill") while imposing hands. My question is this: Which is more fitting during this liturgical action, sacred silence similar to the elevation of the sacred species after the words of institution, or some fitting piece of music like, say, 'Veni, Sancte Spiritus'?”

The Pontifical, which our reader remembers well, says: “One by one, the candidates go to the bishop and kneel before him. The bishop wearing the miter lays his hands on the head of each, in silence.

“Next all the concelebrating presbyters and all other presbyters present, provided they are vested with a stole worn over an alb or over a cassock and surplice, lay their hands on each of the candidates, in silence. After the laying on of hands, the presbyters remain on either side of the bishop until the prayer of consecration is completed.”

From this we adduce that the priests imposing hands should say nothing and that any prayer for the ordinand should be purely mental.

The silence of this moment of the rite of ordination is of great importance and in a way it is a rite in itself. Thus during the rite of imposition of hands there should be no music or singing whatsoever.

However, even though there is nothing in the rubrics to support it, when the imposition of hands is likely to be protracted due to the number of priests or due to the number of candidates, liturgical practice seems to tolerate singing some invocation to the Holy Spirit. If and when this is done, the bishop usually imposes hands in silence and the hymn is intoned shortly after the priests have begun to impose hands.

In order to maintain the climate of silence the rubrics foresee the possibility of a smaller number of the priests present imposing hands. This is sometimes done, and is to be preferred to interrupting the silence, but it is not always easy to carry out without someone feeling excluded.

The second, much rarer, situation of prolonged silence is when the number of candidates is very numerous. After 10 minutes of absolute silence during a rite, even fervent people can get nervous and lose concentration on the mystery that is being celebrated. Thus the silence itself can become an obstacle to the concentration it seeks to promote.

In such cases some invocations such as the Veni Creator Spiritus can be tolerated.

This was the case in my own ordination in which I was blessed to form part of a group of 60 priests ordained by Pope John Paul II in St. Peter’s Basilica. The rite of imposition of hands alone lasted about half an hour and thus several hymns invoking the Holy Spirit were sung during its course.

* * *

Readers may send questions to Please put the word "Liturgy" in the subject field. The text should include your initials, your city and your state, province or country. Father McNamara can only answer a small selection of the great number of questions that arrive.

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular