100mg zoloft while breastfeeding upperbe.it camerata.com should diflucan be taken during period or after sevban.com best azithromycin medicine name for pimple cialis online australia paypal ketoconazole price unitedreporters.com does hydroxyzine give you a buzz metronidazole class firsttimetravels.com does proventil have steriod in it gabapentin 300 mg price yogaindailylife.org lineofoslo.no took 3000 mg metformin pregnancy recommened prednisone taper for poison ivy can you take ondansetron on an empty stomach ftortho.net what is erythromycin oint 4gm used for atenolol 40 mg will having an orgasm affect metronidazole treatment gabapentin 300 mg tablet inactive fda propecia 5mg canada diflucan one tablet one dose does 7.5mg mirtazapine work for anxiety orlistat 120 mg resultados gkris.com voltaren75m en espanol singulair 10 mg 20 comprimidos order clonidine online no prescription xenical price per capsule philippines singulair dosage in adults cialis online drugstore azascd.org haciendahotel-oldtown.com bellesthailand.com para serve o medicamento cyproheptadine hcl bp 4mg aptmetrics.com interaction between ciprofloxacin and glucophage 500 mg cialis ca golfnewmexico.com viagra sale fast shipping floacin antibiotic levofloxacin is crushable la pastilla atenolol deja esteril a una mujer dosis tomar cytotec para abortar montelukast 4 mg tablet price india segtucson.com purchase diflucan over counter manfaat obat meloxicam 15 mg buildingsonfire.com vardenafil available in philippines kaupers-kapellenhof.de easiest cialis doctor raleigh nc ryman.pl revue-pto.com celecoxib sale del mercado dexamethasone 4 mg dolor de garganta crestor 5 mg vs lipitor 10mg side effects nitroglycerin metoprolol wechselwirkung ketoconazole tablet for sale in philippines buy indocin 75 mg can i take zofran while breastfeeding fungsi tetracycline hcl emberdomme.com benicar 40 equals diovan doxycycline dosage for respiratory infection learninc.org what happen if delayed period and you take metformin celebrex for prostatitis how long does it take to withdraw from 2.5mg olanzapine buy generic viagra what happens if you double doses of viagra oeufspolis.com levitra cheap no prescription viagra gel packs nglturf.org atenolol 25 mg bid buy lamisil singapore thebestkindofdifferent.com serophene tablete 50 mg tengo ulcera gastrica puedo tomar lasix cena plavix 75 mg whats the price of danazol oral in india proscar online pharmacy lasix 500 mg tabletten content-catalyst.com floryakurye.com.tr cytotec como se toma y q tan peligrosa es 10 mg baclofen how long does it last cluster ha and zyprexa disadvantages of metformin mobile-pharma.com cialis free coupon 5 mg zithromax spanish name how long to feel effects of zyban for bipolar benefisios de hydroxyzine best dosage for anafranil for ocd happyknits.com synthroid nausea puedo tomar misoprostol para que me baje farmasi menjual cytotec di malaysia dosage of amoxicillin for ear infection for baby diflucan fluconazole harga ciprodex price deremerstudios.com wpodrozy.eu albuterol 4mg price can you take fluconazole 2 days in a row can clomid make you release eggs from both ovaries harga cialis how long does it take fluconazole 200 mg to work ciprofloxacino dubai how can i get zofran 4mg disolvable for free. arilarotokiralama.com can lisinopril cause neck pain zestril 10 mg edgewaterstudio.com viagra free shipping purchase viagra online us tetracycline acne price in india does metformin affect digoxin viagra alternatives 5 hour energy aml.ca does azithromycin in 5 days cure chlamydia taking fluconazole 50 mg after taking meal aljanine.com westregion.org floraphotographs.com doxazosin 20 mg metformin 500mg er side effects discount coupon for singulair huntofalifetime.org can i take more than one single dose diflucan arr.czestochowa.pl diverticulitis antibiotic choice. levaquin 500 buy viagra from canada online mirtazapine alternatives uk levaquin 500 mg for uti bemalingsplan.com tome pastillas cytotec y mi bebe nacio con retraso virtualsem.com sportcurrent.com learninc.org andysternberg.com nexium cura la gastritis cialis generic best private uk viagra prescription amoxicillin and glucophage westregion.org photoloco.com fluconazole dosage for cheilitis generic famciclovir sekerpinarosgb.com can you mix clonazepam and hydrocodone and baclofen does smoking weed affect your antibiotics piroxicam dispersible tablets 20 mg valsartan in philippines robertjszmidt.pl mobile-pharma.com side effects of celexapro 20 mg sobrietybyyourside.com seroquel xr 300 mg dosage edgewaterstudio.com grandlakehistory.org dapoxetine nhs westwoodhomesinc.com dose of prednisone for gout tetracycline timeline why would i get prescribed cefpodoxime and zithromax bupropion 300 mg xl viagra india online lamisil price australia diflucan 150 overdose is disulfiram available in south africa eu-atp.org how to calculate prednisone pack chloramphenicol mca how tadalafil invented 10 mg prednisone for 3 days metronidazole 500 mg tablet buy holland viagra tablets cialis without doctor neurontin 400 mg uses manfaat obat wiros piroxicam 20 mg westregion.org can seroquel cause pinpoint pupils metronidazole mnemonic does doxycycline hyclate antibotic contain penicillen buildingsonfire.com fluoxetine liquid australia ciprofloxacin cipro din cuanto cuesta cialis de 5mg en mexico do flagyl work if taken on period how many pills of metronidazole can cause abortion price of generic lamisil acyclovir boston 800 uk mail order viagra bupropion and weight loss does selden blue contain ketoconazole filmarray.com zithromax australia ureaplasma adalat xl generic name minax metoprolol tartrate memory celexa alternatives after three days amoxicillin rash wat are the side effects of the drug naproxen blackisbusiness.info how many days is augmentin 875 prescribed for deepspacesupply.com is dexamethasone tablets appetite booster diflucan 100 mg for 14 days where are the place of apani adalat how long does inderal la take to work chloramphenicol 3 obat apa rothacin indomethacin 100 mg tratamiento de clomiphene 100mg can u get high on quetiapine 50 lamisil oral how long to start alcohol dosage for flagyl for 20lb dog mobile-pharma.com how long does kamagra gold works penegra generic viagra silagra cumwithuscom webafest.com.au prednisone taper schedule 20 mg femara for infertility seenonstage.pl loestrin 24 fe and topamax mercury drugs to dispense cytotec how do sildenafil citate tablets vega100 work flomax 350 mg granulato posologia lemurialifecoaching.com seroquel and tramadol taken together how many mg of prednisone for a dogs with a brain tumor does gabapentin cause irritability newworldfoods.ca feel crazy on 5 mg of lexapro bactrim vs diarrhea rf5.org gratisdiscotecas.com gabapentin 300 mg for pain in back sekerpinarosgb.com cabinetsbydesignsarasota.com does 50 mcg in synthroid help with weight loss does keflex affect ethinyl estradiol busy-autokary-wynajem.pl aljanine.com effect of grapefruit and mirtazapine amoxil make vagina tight can gabapentin cause acne in dogs rantical.com nexium 5mg mitsuifinearts.com metoprolol 15 mg tome cytotec y aun sigo sangrando can citalopram 40 mg get you high haciendahotel-oldtown.com function of montelukast should i take viagra3000mg on empty stomach moonshine and wellbutrin xl 300 flexeril high vs gabapentin twentynineinches-de.com floraphotographs.com prazosin gatos valtrex for chlamydia indocin 1mg synthroid 137 vs 150 piroxicam purchase ciesielstwokukulak.com.pl content-catalyst.com expiration of albuterol inhalers advantagegolfcars.com clomid and nolvadex for sale uk how many days can i take augmentin 1000mg stem.neu.edu magnificent.pl generic carvedilol fungsi obat amlodipine besylate 10mg uk viagra sales hellolace.net doxycycline brand in philippines does kamagra work for women order premarin from canada pastile kamagra gold bigdaddyssigns.com if taking valtrex can i take vitamin c vardenafil 20mg uk fluoxetine 40 mg tablets does neurontin have a pill that has 104 can you have a glass of wine with metoprolol succinate alexcitypr.com klebsiella pneumoniae o levofloxacina combate how to replase concor 5 with norvasc 5 artcontact.ge erythromycin and metronidazole together celecoxib online zoloft australia buy diflucan can the pill be cut in half jwalkny.com ciprodac 250 used for buy generic tamoxifen no prescription q2melbourne.com purchase isotretinoin online vardenafil 20 mg bayer augmentin 500mg can i take 1g chinatripadvisor.com red bull while on metronidazole does gabapentin show up in a drug test in va 300 mg topamax flomax over the counter equivalent finacare finasteride cream amoxil package insert augmentin forte beda dengan augmentin apa doxycycline or amoxicillin for tonsilitis dosage of lexapro for women cardura capsula medicinale costo kegunaan dexamethasone salep stopping 60mg prednisone side effects venta de cytotec en cuautitlan izcalli inyecciones que sirva para aplicar con la cytotec metronidazole 500 mg and alcohol wellbutrin 400 mg side effects hydroxyzine pam 50 mg street value advantagegolfcars.com diflucan and marajauna street value of wellbutrin 150 mg blood sugar levels with avodart mhc-s.com poison ivy prednisone not working louielouie.net vibramycin tbl lsb 200 mg para q es azithromycin 200mg 5ml oral suspension panafcort with colchicine antybiotyk amoxicillin eg micardis plus 40 mg 12.5mg yogaindailylife.org stdennischurch.org anger when withdrawing from celexa maxalt generic safe to take during pregnancy tofranil obat apa ya what is nortriptyline hcl 10mg used for back pain am1320.com teva montelukast 10 mg how long to work aptmetrics.com synthroid 137 tengo 6 semanas de embarazo puedo abortar con cytotec modifikasi motor happy nexium 150 paano ang tamang pag inom ng misoprostolmifepristone cialis 5mg double revopac.com my cycle is 26days when will i ovulate if i take clomid acyclovir 2gm bid bridgehousemedia.com bactrim guinea pig cyst can you buy nexium over the counter in canada misoprostol 25 mcg for abortion ic bupropion hcl xl 150 mg does the itching go away augmentin sospensione pediatrica digitalmaniacpro.com what makes you more droesy paxil or efflor deremerstudios.com effects of clomid and tamoxifen on ovulation deremerstudios.com avodart 2.5 mg preatoni.ae grandcanyonbrewery.com arimidex online purchase 54 provera 5mg prevent miscarring para qde mi sirve el medicamento de mirtazapine 30 mg vibramycin 200 mg nebenwirkungen can be taken prednisone with phenobarbital bociansafaris.com viagra pricing in canada does wellbutrin xl generic brand cause weight loss prednisone and hydrocortisone together doxycycline 9 weeks pregnant metformin xr australia brand nane ofdiltiazem 2 cream buy viagra online canada no prescription shepardspropertyservices.com voltaren tabletten online apotheke szcy5.com nexium esomeprazole obat apa bdxmen.com how far apart for cipro dosages montelukast sodium 10mg tab digitalmaniacpro.com amitriptyline price india aygestin 5 mg reviews citalopram 20 mg hallucinations unitedreporters.com can levaquin dosage be crushed levofloxacin diverticulitis dosage atorvastatin 10 tab price floraphotographs.com prozac price delhi rantical.com raloxifene 30 mg tab india 90 mcg albuterol how many mg 5x5.hu zoloft in combination with birth control side effects linezolid colombia gabapentin appetite suppressant prezzo mirtazapine adega.info how much cost cialis im u.k. and cost clavulin amoxicillin 375mg for throat infection over the counter lasix for dogs cymbalta without depression clonazepam with lisinopril side effects hypertension zofran pvp tedmitew.com is 10mg of citalopram effective stanglass.eu venta de cytotec en italia interaction zovirax ointment with prednisone clonidine snort celebrex 500mg coupons generico del singulair 4mg gibt es in holland doxepin 10mg so-sc.org olanzapine 50 mg average dose generic for zyprexa artpol.org.pl amoxil junior dosis viagra pill splitting can amoxicillin 50 mg for dogs ear louielouie.net westwoodhomesinc.com digitalmaniacpro.com desogen price how long before taking 2nd diflucan 150mg clomid worked clomid and proviron pct lifebychristian.com does lamisil burn on open wound dosage of fluconazole for nail infection q es metformina orlistat sandoz alli clopidogrel indication ppt antidote of sildenafil metronidazole for breast abcess como tomar piroxicam cialis prices in uk 555fs.com prednisone dose pack poison oak prednisone dosage for dogs with lymphoma how mmany milligrams is em erythromycin for fish how many days can one take ciprobiotic tablet clomiphene citrate dosage before food or after food amaryl 2mg 500mg viagra vision side effects nizoral shampoo expiration will 50 mg of prednisone for 5 days cause constipation content-catalyst.com allegra 120 mg tablet gabapentin tablets usp 800mg webbrowsers.lv side effects of sertraline capsules with alchol grandlakehistory.org nexium 40 mg price india homemade substitute for albuterol imax metformin metronidazole ciprofloxacin side effects ukmi linezolid lexapro 10 mg dosage product development rational for indomethacin gel order metformin 850 paroxetine 12.5 for premature ejaculation buy generic cialis online australia nizoral sampunas cipro how long to take effect chloramphenicol 1 eye ointment 4g addictedtoallthingspretty.com eu-atp.org atal bihari in apki adalat meloxicam 15 does it show on drug test will i lose weight taking synthroid at night buildingsonfire.com how many escitalopram 10mg to od edgewaterstudio.com levocetirizine montelukast paracetamol brands amoxicillin 6 year old ear infection dose thuoc chlortetracycline cattle RETROFITREBATE.COM 10mg lexapro equal 50 mg zoloft buspirone 30 mg high replace baclofen pump cpt code doxycycline hyclate anxiety side effects kegunaan obat salep feldene fluconazole medscape amitriptyline 400 mg estimated free thyroxine chrisandradeforcongress.com buy metoprolol xl gratisdiscotecas.com online propecia pharmacy misoprostol abortion pill in sri lanka

The Nature of Sin

Do you have to know you are committing a sin in order to actually commit one?
by Father John Bartunek, LC | Source: Catholic.net

Question: Do you have to know you are committing a sin in order to actually commit one?

Answer: You would think this simple question has a simple answer. But it doesn’t. We have to get a little theological here to unravel it, but I’ll try to be brief anyhow.

First of all, we have to remember what sin is. Sin is rebellion against God. It is saying to God, “I don’t want to do what you want me to do.” (For more on the nature of sin, you can you seen the posts on scrupulosity and bad thoughts) Right away, then, we can see that every sin has two poles.

Evil Effects Follow Evil Actions

In the first place, there is the action itself. As human beings, our actions can be conscious thoughts, words, or deeds. (Digesting lunch isn’t really a human action, because we don’t do it consciously). So a sin is, in the first place, a (conscious) thought, word, or deed that goes against God’s will. Now, we know that God’s will is as full of wisdom as the ocean is full of water (see Psalm 36:6). And his wisdom is intrinsically connected to his limitless love, his overflowing goodness, and his absolute omnipotence. To go against his will, then, is not a smart thing to do. It’s like going against the manufacturer’s instructions – like putting sand in the gas tank of our car, or drying out a wet cell phone by putting it in a hot oven for a couple of hours. It does damage.

It’s important to have that clear. Any thought, word, or action that goes against God’s will (that violates the natural moral law, the Ten Commandments, the teachings of his Church…) will cause some kind of damage to one’s own person, and to the world around us. We may not always see it right away, but it is there, and it will show up, sooner or later. God doesn’t make up a random list of sins out of thin air. Disobedience to God is disobedience to God’s wise plan for human life, for our life; it’s trying to fly without wings. To describe this first aspect of sin, we can use the term “evil action.”

To Blame or Not To Blame

In the second place, sin involves the conscious choice to perform such a rebellious action. This is why, for example, someone who is driving drunk and causes a fatal accident is not necessarily guilty of the sin of murder (they didn’t consciously intend to kill), but they are guilty of the sin of drunkenness (they chose to abuse alcohol). This is also why a criminal who forces a banker at gunpoint to unlock a safe doesn’t make the banker guilty of the sin of theft – the banker opened the safe against his will. Where there is no free choice, there can be no moral responsibility.

But our distinctions don’t end there. The conscious choice to perform an evil action can itself be culpable or not culpable. In other words, we can be responsible for the evil choice or not responsible for it. If I am responsible for it, then I become morally guilty for the evil committed and its consequences. If I am not responsible for it, then I am morally innocent.

For example, if a little boy grows up with parents who are thieves and who teach him to follow in their footsteps, that child may grow up convinced that stealing from non-family members is not an evil action. In that case, whenever he steals from non-family members, although he is freely committing an objectively evil action, he is not aware that it is evil (he doesn’t know that it is a sin). So, the damage is done, both to his soul (he deepens his habits of deception and dishonesty) and to the world around him (the pain and suffering caused by injustice), but he is not morally culpable for it – not guilty.

On the other hand, if a little boy grows up in a normal family environment, his natural, God-given sense of right and wrong will be nourished by the words and example of his parents and education. In this case, he will know that he shouldn’t take anything that doesn’t belong to him. And so, when he goes off to summer camp for the first time and discovers that his roommate has a collection of candy bars, he knows that taking one of them without permission is an evil action. And so, if he takes one anyway, he is responsible for the evil – guilty.

The Hazy Days of Sinners

This all seems obvious. But in real life the line between culpability and non-culpability often gets hazy. As the first little boy grows up, for example, at some point he will realize that other people don’t live like thieves. At some point his natural, God-given sense of right and wrong will flash a thought into his mind: “What is this person going to do if I steal their credit card and max it out at the cash machine?” It may be a very quiet qualm of conscience, but at some point, unless he has become psychopathic or sociopathic, the qualm will surface. At that point, doesn’t he become culpable, even though he had such a twisted upbringing?

A classic example of this haziness in the realm of moral responsibility is the case of the guards in charge of exterminating prisoners during the Nazi holocaust. Was it truly possible that they didn’t realize, at some level of consciousness, that they were destroying fellow human beings? Are the guards morally innocent because they were simply following orders?… When we start to wrestle with tangled cases like that, it is relief to remember that God is the perfect judge.

Here is an example of haziness (uncertainty about what’s right or wrong in a specific situation) that’s a little closer to home. Imagine that the government makes a mistake in my favor and sends me an extra $1000 on a tax rebate. That money really doesn’t belong to me, which means it belongs to someone else. So, shouldn’t I send it back to the government? But wait, doesn’t the government charge too much money in taxes anyway, and wasn’t it their mistake? Is taking that extra rebate (which I may really need) stealing? Some good Catholics would keep that money without batting an eye, thanking God for it. Others would send it back immediately, convinced that it was a temptation from the Devil. On rare occasions, then, knowing right and wrong is tricky business, business that keeps moral theologians busy.

Getting Down to Brass Tacks

Now we are ready to answer your question. To be guilty of an evil action, I must be aware that it is evil, that it is morally wrong. That awareness may be clear or fuzzy. The clearer it is, the more guilty I am. To be guilty of an evil action, I also have to freely make the evil choice. The greater the degree of freedom, the great the culpability. If I commit an evil action without awareness of the evil or when my freedom is impaired, however, the evil is still committed; damage is done. This is why ignorance is NOT bliss. Fornication still wounds souls and societies, even if the fornicators have never been taught that fornication is wrong.

The spiritual consequences of this long answer to your very short question are pretty obvious. We need to make a decent effort not only to do what’s good and avoid what’s evil, but also, to know what’s right and wrong – it’s much easier to walk quickly and surely in the daylight than in the dark. We have to inform ourselves about what the Church teaches and why, going beyond the Google News sound bites about the Pope’s latest encyclical. That’s why you are reading this Q&A, and that’s why faithful Catholic resources like http://www.ncregister.com and http://www.faithandfamilylive.com are so invaluable to us.

Yours in Christ, Father John Bartunek, LC

On the Net:
For more questions and answers on the spiritual life, go to 

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows Catholic.net to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to Catholic.net right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular