levitra vardenafil 100mg bayer 30 tablet efectos de dejar tamoxifeno elavil uses opipramol cialis myghsy.com xenical mercury drug store terbinafine for dogs in india zofran dose while pregnant agrirobo.pl blackisbusiness.info arman-crusher.com german cialis hcpcs code for 4 mg of zofran lisinopril 40 mg statin amoxicillin buat anak wellbutrin 100mg how to buy finasteride from india diflucan 150 mg dosage for yeast infection heavyanalytics.com syp amoxil dosage tamoxifen and varicose veins badcyclopedia.com haltner.com propranolol dementia alzheimer terbinafine cat ringworm and kidney generic viagra for cheap lexapro for acne and birth control half inderal and alcohol lopressor same as metoprolol nolvadex lh fsh how long does valtrex take to work to profolactically diet pill trim zone buy zyprexa 10 mg levitra sales online hillsboroughcountyfair.com does bactrim ds treats vibrio vulnificus usos de phenergan how to counteract seroquel can wellbutrin make you high metformin diabetes tablets cialis dose for women forums sobre zoloft azithromycin once a week prophylactic pitands why doesnt sildenafil tablets work informatyk-szczecin.com.pl accutane enlarged lymph nodes doxycycline ivf husband duloxetine hcl 30 mg. once daily gave me diarrhea zithromax farmacocinetica what are the symptoms of stopping cymbalta zovirax tablets over the counter australia cymbalta dosage for elderly best cialis levaquin swollen glands buy propecia online for cheap prednisone taper schedule asthma asiliahomehealth.com stability of fluconazole injection how to start zoloft dosage vollemaan.org abilify 10 effets secondaires alli diet pills website levitra shoppers drugmart amoxicillin 500mg and ibuprofen where can i get viagra in edmonton effects of drinking on zoloft suppliers of cialis in uk mobilepushnotifications.org paxil bipolar ii mobilfo.com cipronex cena apteka hoxtonradio.com urinary retention after paxil side effect atenolol 50 mg zlobeklesneskrzaty.pl can you take prednisone and mucinex clopidogrel crystal form wellbutrin meditation sklepy-zoologiczne.pl cebuweb.tk can viagra be taken while on blood thinners medicosefectivos.net cialis 40 mg dose yalovadaarsa.com metronidazole uk online misoprostol 200 mcg intravaginaaly for iud singulair 10 mg te da hambre harbifilmizle.com dosages of wellbutrin metformin hcl males me pee light ciprodex ear drops cause stomach upset tratamiento metformina embarazo canine prednisone 40 mg diarrhea azithromycin in stores paris france pharmacological classification of furosemide medroxyprogesterone 100 mg price zoloft online pharmacy levitra 20mg reviews zyprexa side effects treatment side effects from stopping singulair clomid for low testosterone neurontin 800 mg para que sirve atomoxetine online does metronidazole gel contain gluten dianabol nolvadex cycle cheap cialis online india revopac.com prednisone erowid vault discount lexapro online vancampinc.com is dapoxetine priligy available in pakistan fertility blend vs clomid erfahrungsberichte sildenafil pfizer paroxetine average dosage how much clomid to take for twins carrepairmanualdoc.com hlahlaaung.com asi.wpgsystem.com buy cabergoline steroids mildreddeskinsjewelry.com augmentin 1g bid and breastfeed e coli resistente a ciprofloxacino napabusinessadvantage.com vibramycin 100mg reviews sousyakai.net vermogensbeheer.net upd315.com cymbalta printable coupon does cialis make you turned on by a woman walan.com need to order metronidazole does acne stop after accutane abilify access paroxetine inhibition how long before lisinopril works mytime99.com cialis cheapest price canada propecia vs. generic finasteride viagra 39 iheartjonahbees.net sons got erection help mom viagra makes you grow hair paroxetine hcl for hot flashes viagra 50 mg jovenes cipro denk with alcohol hpaulsantmire.com tamoxifen conditional expression florida-info.cz finasteride johnny depp can sildenafil be bought in singapore can you buy viagra in boots 21 amoxicillin 250 mg prices topamax dose for migraine prophylaxis buy doxycycline india can men take diflucan 150 mg dosage judytaylor.com mooboos.com cytotec kom ut igjen retail cost of premarin cream bezpieczne-nawierzchnie.pl dosages for cymbalta buy nolvadex anabolic steroids nolvadex k?pes albuterol adrenergic how much does mircette cost without insurance metronidazole dogs diarrhea otc nicetouristanbul.com buy erythromycin cream metformin pfizer 1000 mg shawniverse.com florida-info.cz napabusinessadvantage.com prednisone 5 mg daily side effects tobramycin and dexamethasone ophthalmic cost wellbutrin disorientation generic orlistat india autorepairmanualdoc.com azithromycin for 9 months celexa and nicorette wellbutrin xl adipex p diet pill fda approved levofloxacin dog dosage chlamydia azithromycin dosage acyclovir n947 how to get help paying for plavix proscar 5 mg vs propecia 2 ketoconazole lotion cost how to stop taking bupropion vintagevideo.co.uk cost of lexapro 20 mg cvs lamisil 1 una aplicacion can lexapro affect blood sugar levels thyroxine canine side effects can i take sudafed while taking amoxicillin clomid 50mg for what transition from celexa to prozac maxalt e zomig healthylifestyleart.com levitra 20 mg generic lisinopril and lupin volo roma cipro low cost hopemedicaleducation.com taking fluconazole during pregnancy reviews coenzyme q10 interaction with clopidogrel ivermectin tablets for humans uk can you get kamagra oral jelly in the philippines bollywoodinformer.com is dutasteride safe drug interaction metoprolol and methamphetamine arrow generics finasteride zithromax salmonella allegra mcevedy magic beans can amoxil and flagyl cause bloating artdecade.com how much does 50mg of seroquel cost on the street kamagra holland apotheke griseofulvin pilz hnxxldb.com mycities.com.au upd315.com zoloft takes time arinijayapress.com much seroquel should take buying viagra online with paypal generic singulair availability childlabor-payson.org hillsboroughcountyfair.com clomid aos 41 anos mikezielinski.com if i take clomid will it change the time of my period informatyk-szczecin.com.pl fuck after taking viagra astrolab-consulting.com prednisone rapid heart rate najlepszykredytmieszkaniowy.com.pl does clomid increase cm using desogen as plan b metformin and no food celexa as pain relief wbstaffing.pl ventolin ila?pedia milodi.net nizoral shampoo itching why cant u take viagra twice najlepszykredytmieszkaniowy.com.pl ventolin and toddlers remeron bula andiescafenapavalley.com bdxmen.com android-az.com yahoo answers how much viagra costs in indian market metronidazole uk price atenolol dosage bnf metspirit.com doxycycline 40 mg how long to work wallflore.co.uk valores normales beta estradiol getting off finasteride millteksport.pl westward lisinopril 40mg awp tamoxifeno rosacea effects of overdosing on synthroid maxalt dilated pupils can i use terbinafine cream for ringworm on vagina can i get periactin in bangladesh moravskavina.cz wysoki poziom estradiolu in vitro momandfitness.com nexium stesolid seroquel urination prednisone 5 day dose pack instructions apo sertraline happydeal4u.com nizoral shampoo reviews uk tamsulosin beta blocker acyclovir 10 days eonfr consegur.misoprostol en cuenca tadalafil citrate price bd flomax cough side effect singulair to treat cold uticaria hollisterlancasterlaw.com momandfitness.com aml.ca hnxxldb.com kamagra jelly where can u get it in durban ondansetron oral bioavailability vintagevideo.co.uk can u snort naproxen 500 abilify mecanismo accion bupropion interaction with dextromethorphan bayrakogullari.com sarasotacojail.com 80 year old erections famvir online does phenergan have penicillin colchicine price in canada irishphil.com combining doxycycline and amoxicillin mobilepushnotifications.org mechanism of ampicillin resistance in e.coli are generic clomipramine can you get 10 mg age most men take viagra muslim-academy.com tomar escitalopram en el embarazo albuterol sulfate retail price estradiol injection thyroxine absorbtion when taking nexium can celexa start working right away viagra for kvinner najlepszykredytmieszkaniowy.com.pl websitedesignportcharlotte.com conjugated estrogen cream price albuterol absorption quitting cymbalta after 5 days generic zenegra viagra online tenormin 25 mg dosage ivermectin dose demodex dogs flomax uk fluconazole over 60 myexactamundo.com mobicom sa satu mare anastrozole online buy flagyl europe enthesopathy ciprofloxacin mediatrax.com does topamax cause liver damage erythromycin and myasthenia gravis zithromax dosage 11 year old what are the parameters to hold for metoprolol er 25mg chengdong.net will taking a norco interact with augmentin 500mg is tetracycline bad for you boredstop.com is valtrex bad for your liver httwp.com brtop.net momandfitness.com vuongminh.com skin.effects of wellbutrin clomid its uses internetowe-szkolenia.pl synthroid 4 weeks o que acontece se eu tomar clomid estando gravida acyclovir experiences 812222.com hortexpo.com what is stronger amoxicillin or augmentin metro2034.pl iheartjonahbees.net levitra how long does the effect last how long does erections last with viagra does cialis really work for normal male wast.org.uk uncn.org horyniec.com.pl will phenergan help gastritis metronidazole and soy sauce abundantgraceandcharm.com viagra sales market baufinanzierung-aktuell.com how much can you sell a meloxicam 15 mg for per pill warchiwach.pl drug withdrawal antidepressants breedspectrum antibiotica ciprofloxacine cialis loses potency plavix sales data amoxil in third trimester zofran daily dose kamagra kutno s?ntesis del estradiol bayrakogullari.com diltiazem 90 vizioescort.com muslimdate.com infokurye.com 20 mg of prednisone and motrin michaelgahler.de prozac dosage australia 1judaica.com atenolol de 100 mg para que sirve generic for lexapro side effects what can amoxicillin cause kamagra and dapoxetine when does cialis peak in your bloodstream clopidogrel bcs classification captionedit.com michellestockman.com momandfitness.com zoloft after 7 weeks clomid aromasin nolva pct bactrim f suspension para que sirve does cytotec show in blood test glucophage gnc viagra in dubai duty free how much lexapro for panic disorder viagra sale physician lipitor interactions niaspan viagra utah pharmacy metronidazole chlamydia allergic generic wellbutrin what is the medication metronidazole 400mg used for vermogensbeheer.net allegra 180 and azithromycin can it be taken together insideinsights.net metoprolol 25 mg er tab wats took viagra with no one around nexium iv infusion kegunaan obat licodexon dexamethasone pediatric dose of furosemide brakke ofloxacin dosage 12.5 sertraline does escitalopram reduce blood sugar clomid pct side effects vit c and clomid study from celexa to cipralex metro2034.pl seroquel 12.5 mg elderly celebrex dtc xenical 120 mg 84 caps. prijsvergelijk metronidazole through iv oxytetracycline in pregnancy qual o valor do remedio orlistat michaelgahler.de metro2034.pl blog.fiberwire.ca nuspojave doxycyclinevibramycin aciclovir dosificacion herpes labial millteksport.pl mkvisio.pl augmentin france antibiotic tablet for pimple in kolkata imwithpete.net muslim-academy.com provera and clomid fertility treatment uk informatyk-szczecin.com.pl lipitor spain research chemical supplier clomid diflucan bv revopac.com can i take vaginal flagyl withbirth control morbidoutlook.com when should i take a pregnancy test after taking clomid metro2034.pl what would happen if i snort 30 mg of buspirone zovirax eksi s?zl?k meastcompany.com streetstylesinfo.com seroquel 25 mg reviews vapplica.org american viagra isvicrede spiramycin metronidazole et alcool similarity between cipro and amoxilin tablet accutane 40 to 80 buy amitriptyline 10mg veziris.com norvasc monitoring parameters prednisone makes me hyper is augmentin safe for women ttc does unitedhealthcare pay for viagra ampicillin genfar besttop mobicom doxycycline hyclate 500mg digoxin and tums mind mirtazapine 15 what the name of azithromycin in usa ansbach-direkt.de lexapro generic drug sertraline hcl forum lamisil effects on kidneys 50 mg of prednisone during first trimester zoloft quanto durano gli effetti collaterali napabusinessadvantage.com zoloft and difficulty urinating ciprofloxacin for diarrhea zithromax dosage mg kg nicetouristanbul.com generique du cymbalta mooboos.com doxepin hcl 10mg for sleep para que sirve la crema premarin liquid cialis research hbtaoxian.com metronidazole 400mg at once during breastfeeding olmesartan sales mildreddeskinsjewelry.com do u notice pimples after clomid before period inderal 60 mg half life does mylan quetiapine make you sleepy will amoxicillin make you sick if left out refrigerator quitting 10 mg of paroxetine cold turkey how much does warfarin cost without insurance wiki tamsulosin mosteckoonline.cz lasix cpt codes muslim-academy.com kamagra vs apcalis is it safe to give fish tank amoxicillin to cats vermogensbeheer.net clomid ricetta rossa vad kostar aciclovir

For Humanae Vitae, Life Begins at 40

Discussion during Pope Benedict's Vvsit suggests better reaction.
by Nona Aguilar | Source: NCRegister.com

NEW YORK (NCRegister.com) — The 1968 publication of Pope Paul VI’s "Humanae Vitae" (The Regulation of Birth) was greeted by criticism, and dissent has followed ever since.

Kippley should know: He has been “in the trenches” for decades. In 1971 he and his wife, Sheila, launched the Couple to Couple League in response to a suggestion by Pope Paul VI: to launch apostolates where married couples become apostles and guides to other married couples.

Today, just weeks from its 40th anniversary — and given its continued support by Pope John Paul II and now Pope Benedict XVI (see story, page 5) — can we expect fresh denunciations?

If the reactions to a New York Times blog post published during Pope Benedict’s U.S. visit are any indication, the answer is No.

In “Silence on Contraception,” Rosemary Radford Ruether, described by The Times as a leading Catholic feminist theologian, complained about “the failure of the Catholic Church to credibly reform its teaching.”

She also thumps "Humanae Vitae." Published under a special “Papal Discussion” section, Ruether concludes her article with a warning: “If Catholicism in the U.S. and worldwide presents the appearance of a hierarchical leadership which has lost credibility with much of the laity, the most important cause of this is the failure to rethink its teaching on sexuality and birth control.”

The overwhelming response to Ruether? “Not so fast!”

Of the 59 comments, only two supported Ruether’s observations. Five were genuinely questioning. The remaining 52 commentators revealed that they do not view Humanae Vitae through dissident lenses. Or, to put it another way, the overwhelming majority complained about Ruether’s complaints. Their reasons ran the gamut.

To many, Ruether is out-of-date. “Ever hear of natural family planning?” one commentator wondered. “Ruether’s comments are straight out of the ‘70s,” said another.

Some considered Ruether not only out-of-date but also out-of-touch.

“Hello?” wrote a commentator self-described as Catholic, female and a family physician. “Is she even familiar with the newer literature reaching laypeople on marriage and family issues? ... Or that fertility awareness methods are being taught with great success in the poorest countries?”

Several young spouses — sometimes a husband, sometimes a wife — supported Humanae Vitae and also reported using NFP with success and significant contentment.

Ruether declined to comment on the controversy.

If Ruether’s article was bromidic, most of the comments were not. The likely reason for this difference: Nearly 40 years later, Humanae Vitae has proven prophetic.

To the average 1960s Catholic — and anyone else — Humanae Vitae’s description of the consequences of contraception seemed far-fetched. Widespread marital infidelity? The “general lowering of morality”? Treating women as mere instruments for selfish enjoyment instead of respected, beloved companions? These possibilities (and others) seemed unimaginable 40 years ago. But not today.

Indeed, one commentator decided to read "Humanae Vitae" “to prove it was stupid” after getting into a debate about it. Her reading ended in surprise and tears.

“I could see that [an old man … five years before my birth] diagnosed the problems of my generation: women not valuing themselves, men treating them as disposable things to be used, relationships falling apart and more. I started crying — and that was the moment that I realized that the Catholic Church really knows and teaches the truth.”

Because "Humanae Vitae" was met by a world that had not experienced the consequences of the truly widespread use of contraception — it was the 1960s, after all — it was ridiculed. Today’s climate is different.

Like some of Ruether’s commentators, economist Jennifer Morse has personal experience with the world of unmoored sex.

“I committed just about every sexual sin in the book,” she wrote. As an economist who taught at Yale and George Mason University, she sees the social consequences of unbridled sex. And, like many “been there, done that” former sexual revolutionaries, Morse grasps the wisdom of the Church’s constant teachings, a matter detailed in her book, Smart Sex: Finding Life-Long Love in a Hook-Up World.

Does this mean the tide is turning as we approach the anniversary?

Kippley offered a wise observation: “There are just enough signs to indicate that it might be turning, but comparisons with nature are dangerous: They imply a sort of inevitability — and tidal changes don’t ‘just happen.’ They occur only because there is a great force that causes the change.”

Likewise, a similar force is demanded in the birth control debate, one that has been largely unused for 40 years: the ordinary magisterium exercised by the bishops in union with the Pope, said Kippley. It’s not just ordinary Catholics that will be the beneficiaries of firm pastoral guidance.

“I keep stumbling over Evangelicals who are interested in the Church’s teaching on contraception,” said Morse. “Some embrace it; many more are looking for reasons to give up their pills.”

Nona Aguilar is based in New York.

Make a Donation Now!

Your support for Catholic.net helps to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church’s new evangelization by donating to Catholic.net right now. God bless you for your generosity.

Click Here to Donate

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows Catholic.net to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to Catholic.net right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular