ketoconazole cream philippines jock itch and ciprofloxacin neurontin 1500 mg can i take ventilin ingaler while on verapamil what s d dose fr amoxicillin for gingival abscess can you shoot up citalopram does melatoning react with zoloft pamelor next step for migraines xeloda 500mg price metronidazole for dogs cause shotness og breath does clomid cause brown spotting 9dpo lipitor 40 mg price malaysia ciprofloxacin price in manila amiodarone 6 months plavix polska can you give augmentin to guinea pigs provera 10mg for 5 days to start period neurontin and a drug test azithromycin packet without prescription gi bleed and flagyl is cytotec and misoprostol can cause infertility can i take levoxyl and prozac together flagyl 400mg could be used in third trimester how does mylan metformin 850mg help in women does remeron relax your muscles ciprofloxacin price philippines propecia minoxidil results at 2 years prednisone 40 mg taper over 12 days salep voltaren prometrium pprom arimidex cost walmart significado benicaramlo can i take tums with valacyclovir hcl 1 gram tablet difference between lipitor and generic en farmacias del ahorro en hondura venden cytotec 5oomg antibiotics syrup new years eve depression chronic pain while on flagyl can trich go away but bv stay what is the price of 45 day supply of strattera 80 mgs only clomid tab 100 mg useful in getting pregnancy how can u become pregnant while taking metronidazole 500mg im on fluoxetine and feel hungry all the time how does clomid work on men priligy in hyderabad citalopram 20 mg side effects weight gain sop manufakturing salep ketoconazole diflucan men candida dosing work tamsulosin 400 mg for frequent urination metoprolol 12.5 mg prix buy metformin online australia ivermectin uk what does chloramphenicol 250mg cure and dosage can i take azithromycin with pepto bismol amoxicillin and blood sugar levels can you take torsemide and furosemide together diflucan klonopin cost of po fluconazole levothyroxine 25 mcg tablet price side effects when going from 50 mg to 40 mg prednisone roaccutane 20mg no breakout buy lipitor 40 mg does premarin stop tinnitus furosemide tablets s3 terbinafine hair loss anafranil sr 75 forum phenergan 75 mg directions for albuterol for six month old bad side effects paxil cheap cialis next day cytotec to miscarry 4weeks pregnancy propranolol withdrawal symptoms a comprehensive view septra 25 zyprexa withdrawl shortness of breath is lisinipril zestril a calcium channel blocker azithromycin 250 mg 4 pills at once NEOHAIRINDO.COM doxazosin 16 mg acyclovir 800 mg tablets generic zovirax what similar ingredients do arimidex and femara have 1000 mg zithromax chlamydia has misoprostol doas in myanmar zofran 4 mg heart arrhythmia buy generic viagra usa most effective way to take viagra can you take vyvanse and lexapro together dosage for azithromycin for bronchitis can you take phenergan on an empty stomach how long does it take for 300 mg of doxycycline to work avodart price comparison estrace pills price olmesartan medoxomil api price pfizer brand viagra prednisone 20 side effects on first trimester non prescription doxycycline 100mg clozaril 25mg lioresal 5 mg nebenwirkungen cialis online online pharmacy buspar no prescription apa itu hydroxyzine can i give chicken amoxicillin take prometrium 5 dpo cialis 100mg pills obat flagyl forte 500 metronidazole 1st week of zoloft when avodart on the market for hair loss viagra online misoprostol cucuta difference between tab estranor and inj depo provera snuffy myers 1.0 mg avodart lisinopril 5mg tablets used kegunaan salep hervis acyclovir pada mata flomax 2mg how much tamoxifen do you take for cycle septran 480 tablet norvasc 5mg tablets side effects what is the shelf life of finasteride 5mg clozapine cost to nhs fosamax plus 70mg 5600 order premarin from canada remeron causes increases cortisol levels in urine doxepin hcl prices is ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg stronger than z pack apo azithromycin 1000mg replacement atenolol buy online cytotec in india sertraline 7177 is fluconazole used for yeast on skin too se puede abortar con cytotec en las 17 semanas what is clopidogrel 75 mg viagra for men use in telugu 8 comprimes pour une dose de metronidazole 250g cabergoline t what is novo gabapentin 100mg used on dogs for buy lamisil singapore does taking zoloft increase serotonin lanoxin dose peadiatric aha can 7 and a half mgs of mirtazapine be effective imexa azithromycin 250 mg dosage cipro bula medicamento de gamma buy zoloft uk sildenafil citrate 100 mgs prometrium 100mg what is it used for flagyl 8 tablets doxycycline and sun exposure side effects seroquel 200 mg recreational use acyclovir iv infusion rate can a pragnancy women can take amoxicillin 500 mg price 20mg nexium australia amoxicillin trihydrate dosage wounds deltasone no prescription inderal 40 uses i dc allergic to erythromycin can you take cleocin escitalopram no insurance amiodarone sildenafil olmesartan medoxomil price 6 day dose pack instruction for prednisone 5mg synthroid overdose during pregnancy can lisinopril cause excessive sweating guna zithromax generic clonidine names is clomiphene citrate causes painful ovulation is it ok to take sudafed with valacyclovir best mix for crushing azithromycin prometrium 200 ovuli costo kamagra quanto costa farmacia nexium pharmacophore will my cystitis go away when i get off topamax msds for zyvox tablets amoxicillin 250 mg chewable dosage nitroglycerin 5 minutes viagra pill mg can levofloxacin be taken with amoxicillin metronidazole 500 mg oral tab how long do metronidazole take to work on oral abscess prednisone 50 mg burst 3 days for headache femara blutungen buy proscar no prescription online can you take nytol and sertraline together isotretinoin 20 mg price misoprostol en huancayo peru price difference between diovan and valsartan 80 mg prednisone taper for bronchitis side affects doxazosina asofarma is.cipro a good a antiobotic mutual pharmacy doxycycline is 25 mcg of symptoms synthroid too low proventil 90 mcg what do i say to get viagra script clomid 50mg twice a day can you give augmentin duo forte for cats stomatitis how long remeron should be taken doxepin price increase fungsi voltaren gel what is ciprofloxacin used for witlo treatment 400 mg wellbutrin with 50 mg zoloft how much phenergan to sedate a dog order valtrex from canada amoxicillin toothache quetiapine 12.5 buy quetiapine online uk taking cipro for 30 days safe are vidalta and flagyl safe together digoxin 250 mcg side effects warfarin sodium 4mg atorvastatin side effects chemistry strattera 60 mg purchase online sildenafil pharmalife what is the price of amlodipine besilate 5 in nepal tablet flagyl voltaren retard price 75 mg buy propecia in thailand augmentin and sunbathing overnight viagra delivery is buying proscar online safe metformin weight loss diet cuanto cuesta la medicina de atorvastatin can i take fluconazole 2 days in a row for tinea pedis ultralow price viagra what is the cost of priligy in india voltaren emulgel 50g novartis feldene 0 5 is clomid a form of progesterone cn augmentin b used 4 candida getting on hydroxyzine has anyone had metronidazole affect birth control internationale apotheke online shop stromectol obat table misoprostol abortion untuk abortus can i mix oxycodone and metronidazole buy acyclovir pills online canada viagra discount flagyl side effects mayo clinic does fluconazole work for dogs valley fever happy nexium150r zovirax 400 mg for vaginal herpes 125 mcg thyroxine as armour esomeprazole tad 40mg can baclofen cause incontinence what is a holistic substitute for flagyl viagra falls band south bend long term taking cialis side effect vietnam kamagra gel nitroglycerin .4 mg patch azithromycin nursing responsibilities misoprostol ampul 900 mg neurontin a day celebrex fara reteta meloxicam tab7.5mg para q sirve misoprostol myanmar long term dangers of periactin how long will my urine smell after taking azithromycin 15mg or 7.5mg of mirtazapine for sleep azithromycin 6 pack dosage amoxicillin 500mg capsules msds rite aid antibiotics stds clonidine 0.1mg tablet does it make male sperm sterile how to treat bactrim rash can prednisone affect vision in dogs prednisone recreational use compare prices viagra generic 100mg how hard an erection will cialis give ivermectin birds 1 spot on meloxicam 15 mg tablet itu apa 300 mg doxepin clendamicia y levofloxacino juntos withdrawal from short term use of gabapentin can 250 mg metformin help in pregnancy viagra generic philippines price of metformin 500mg in the philippines is 400mg celebrex common dosage lioresal 10 mg dosage luvox cr 150 mg price indomethacin 75 mg dosage apo amitriptyline 25mg side effects order periactin cyproheptadine tetracycline make you sleepy tamsulosin mrs 0.5 mg caps can you deep sea dive while on cymbalta nama obat antibiotic untuk tipes di pakistan how much does propecia cost in cvs flagyl cost walgreens buspirone hcl 30 mg and oxazepam 10 mg side effects bio metronidazole 400 for oral how much zithromax 500mg philippines cymbalta and zopolcone and alcohol can i drink ginger ale with azithromycin paxil 5 mg withdrawal paroxetine day 6 feel crazy on 5 mg of lexapro nexium class b cuantos miligramos de clomid puedo tomar after three days amoxicillin rash amlodipine besylategen generic manufacturers order zovirax cold sore cream doxycycline dose for pleurodesis buy azithromycin powder packets claritin and montelukast same time why prescribed lisinopril 20 mg price amoxicillin uk brand name msds for colcrys singulair 4 mg chewable tablets price australian accutane survivors group levofloxacin dosage for pseudomonas price for cialis daily use gewichtstoename door nolvadex price of provera in mercury drug finasteride johnny depp how much does cialis cost and does insurance cover it prednisone 50 mg 5 day dosage side effects of decrease lexapro from 10mg to 5mg does long term cialis work buy hydroxyzine no prescription leg pain after lasix tablet tapering off 50mg gabapentin treatment for drug resistant depression acyclovir boston 800 can you snort naproxen 500 mg levitra buy mexico lamisil est bon pour plantar warts bactrim in dogs dosage per kg can you take hydrochlorothiazide and ativan together singulair paediatric 4mg side effects quanto costa augmentin supposte synthroid street value how much does dostinex cost diflucan dosage skin heat rash can fluconazole help a man yeast infections prednisone dosage protocol generic cialis price comparison generic tamsulosin cost zithromax for strep throat dosage injection augmentin nursing responsibility nebulizer albuterol dose for five year old does generic singulair work buy levitra discount metoprolol succinate er cut does in half atorvastatin price canada dengue y clopidogrel rulide and augmentin for sinusitis nizoral ml carvedilol 12 5mg nebenwirkungen half life of hydroxyzine hydrochloride 25mg synthroid 100 mg emagrece 5 mg of zyprexa augmentinsr medication accutane cleared my skin in 2 weeks why shoulg you not eat ice cream after taking viagra can zoloft take more than 8 weeks to work zovirax 800 mg dose singulair dosage for infants can seroquel xr 50 be cut to help sleep erythromycin es 600 chinese viagra red box zoloft missed dose symptoms reviews 2.5 olanzapine if you only have an iv dose of lasix can you give po diagram tadalafil propranolol vs enalapril salep feldene is clomid round and yellow seroquel irregular heartbeat australia warfarin guidelines thuoc atenolol 5mg mirtazapine side effects depakote erythromycin obat apa doxycycline 100mg 30 tablet how much cost metoprolol and telmisartan medicine.brands revista avon online albania dexamethasone 0 5 voltaren max gel uk metformin nursing responsibilities augmentin without dyes 10 mg amitriptyline to stop dream recall how long is reconstituted antibiotic good for a dog dosage for flagyl for 20lb dog bactrim forte in italia antibiotics tablet for jock itching is bactrim a weak antibiotic for utis acyclovir together with zovirax ointment is valtrex or acyclovir stronger why is my husband using cialis topamax 25 mg uses prednisone 20 mg tab watson indian herbal viagra formulation in urdu price of durvet ivermectin at cvs how much albuterol sulfate liquid do you give a 2yr old how long does seroquel xr last where priligy available in india ttc for 6 months can i start clomiphene order cialis no prescription online how long does metronidazole diarrhea montelukast chewable 4mg jak dziala cialis 20mg vs viagra 100mg how much of a dose of doxycycline for dogs anyone used metformin denk for pcos clomid and iui rate generic levitra au how erecto 100 work

Indulgences: The World´s Most Misunderstood Spiritual Gifts

A proper understanding of indulgences among laypeople is surprisingly helpful toward healing rifts in the Body of Christ.
by Mark P. Shea | Source:
Most Catholics live and die blissfully unaware that the Church even offers indulgences anymore. (A Catholic friend to whom I mentioned I was writing this article said, "They went out with Vatican II, didn´t they?") Practically no Catholic gives much thought to them. They languish in the Church´s attic of doctrinal knick-knacks.

So why bother with them? Two reasons. First, indulgences (while relatively insignificant in the grand scheme of things) are nonetheless minor tributaries to the Church´s river of grace and are therefore intrinsically interesting. But second (and most important), a proper understanding of indulgences among laypeople is surprisingly helpful toward healing rifts in the Body of Christ. For though indulgences are neglected by most Catholics, nervously curious Protestants looking at Rome still find them scandalous.

Indeed, the very word "indulgence" can set many a Protestant heart aquiver with the deep foreboding that, whatever papists say, they are slaves to works salvation -- a suspicion only enhanced when Catholic ignorance lends credibility to the fear that Rome keeps its flock in the dark about what she really teaches.

I know these feelings quite well. And I do not disagree that Luther had a point about the "scandalous traffic in indulgences" of which the Renaissance Church was guilty. Even the Council of Trent agreed with that. But, as a convert, I came to discover the Renaissance Church was guilty, not of the theology of indulgences (which is, as we shall see, simply a theology of charismatic grace) but of simony--that is, of sinfully selling that "grace" for cold cash like a stock investment. So then, Luther was right--partly. But Rome was (in her theology if not her Renaissance practice) right too. How?

Catholic theology has an incorrigible knack for obscuring marvelous insights in confusing terminology. Thus, for instance, she speaks of "temporal punishment for sin" which sounds to Protestants as though Jesus didn´t do enough and you still have to endure extra torture so you´ll be fully "punished" in addition to the 80% or 90% of the punishment He took for you.

In reality, "temporal punishment" is just Catholicese for what Protestants call "chastisement." That is, it is pain unto life such as Scripture refers to when it tells us God punishes all those he loves as his children. (Hebrews 12:5-6). In short, temporal punishment is part of how God redeems our sinful actions and turns their consequences into occasions of sanctity rather than damnation. For as Paul says, "suffering produces perseverance; perseverance, character; and character, hope. And hope does not disappoint us, because God has poured out his love into our hearts by the Holy Spirit, whom he has given us." (Romans 5:3-5). This is the common sense reason why repentant murderers are forgiven, yet not freed from prison. The consequences of the sin remain, but, by grace, they are turned to glory. Very well then, as with the confusing term "temporal punishment" this Catholic knack for packaging a great idea in opaque terminology is particularly acute in the notion of indulgences. For indulgences depend on a term which Protestants find especially sinister: the "treasury of merit."

What is "merit"? Well, it isn´t "extra righteousness earned by particularly nice people who pitched in to help our well-meaning but inadequate Savior´s effort at redemption" (which is what many people think "merit" means). Rather "merit" is an old-fashioned term whose modern equivalent(according to theologian Hans Urs Von Balthasar) is "fruitfulness."

Now we´re in Protestant territory! Christians, as all Protestants know, are graced to bear fruit by the work of Christ (John 15 and all that). We are commanded by God to bear grace to the world and to each other. For as C.S. Lewis observes, God "seems to do nothing of himself which he can possibly delegate to his creatures." We are thus to bear fruit by acting as agents of grace, doing the will of God and generally "wielding our little tridents." And the power of the Holy Spirit (as all Christians know) is absolutely necessary for this fruit to exist at all, much less ripen. So, in bearing fruit, we are not talking about "works salvation." We are talking about cooperation with grace.

Now one of the manifestations of grace, as every charismatic knows, is the charism or spiritual gift. Spiritual gifts are graces given via the members of the Church so that the Body is built up in love (Rom. 12, 1 Cor. 12, Eph. 4:11-16). Some of the gifts given to the Church are more famous (tongues, prophecy, healing, etc.). But nestled right in the middle of them is a gift which does not get talked about much. That gift is the gift of mercy. (Rom. 12:8)

An indulgence is a formal apostolic enactment of the gift of mercy. It is directed at members of the Catholic communion under apostolic authority through their baptism into the Church. That means that indulgences are not a form of earned justification (since that was already freely given in baptism), but are instead given to lessen the temporal punishment due to sin already forgiven. In short, they are an aid to growing in holiness, not a coupon for buying the forgiveness of God.

An example: I, a man with a bad temper, get baptized, calling on the Lord to be saved. What does that make me? Usually it makes me a Christian man with a bad temper since the gift of new life is grace, not magic. Baptism is not an instant cure-all. It is a gate into the transforming grace of God which, with our cooperation, can eventually heal our brains, hearts and bones So then, I come home from baptism full of transforming grace and, finding you did not give me the chocolate Easter bunny I wanted, break your window in a rage. I repent. I am forgiven by God and you. All my guilt is taken away by the blood of Christ the instant I repent. But I still must pay for the window and I still, by grace, have to do something about my temper. Moreover, I am strapped for cash (since I have several broken window lawsuits pending which did not magically disappear when I was baptized). But (asking for God´s help) I do what I can to pay you back. You (a Christian with the gift of mercy) forgive the remainder of the debt and even give me a little something so I can afford anger management counseling and legal fees. You have, in effect, granted me a partial indulgence, relieving the temporal punishment for my already-forgiven sin and helping me toward sanctification with your charism.

So it is with the Church. For she has been graced with all charisms, graces, gifts and fruit (called by medieval theology "the treasury of merit" but referred to by St. Paul as "every spiritual blessing in Christ" (Eph. 1:3). And as the communion of graced believers, the Church has the power to authoritatively administer that blessing where she wills, just as Paul had (Eph 3:2). Indeed she is simply doing as St. Paul´s told her to and using her spiritual gifts, especially the gift of mercy, in granting indulgences by her apostolic spiritual authority--the authority of the graced believer (1 Cor. 12:31).

Long ago, such mercy was visible in the lessening of severe penances required of those guilty of serious sin--penances which, but for indulgences, could last months or even years. (That´s why old Catholic prayer books offer "Indulgences of 365 days attached to doing thus and so." This originally referred, not so much to "days in Purgatory" [there are, after all, no clocks there], but to earthly days of penance.) But that leaves us in a bit of a puzzle since nowadays, the relaxation of those severe penances makes the grace of indulgences largely invisible. To be sure, the Church still says an indulgence can, in some unfathomable way, help us in the process of sanctification. (And proofs of a negative are hard to come by.) But the nature of that help is very mysterious. Maybe the grace comes in the form of "extra strength" to love under difficult circumstances. Maybe some other way. I, at any rate, don´t know.

"But," my Evangelical friends blurt out, "people have to earn indulgences. That´s salvation by works!" No, that´s pastoral common sense akin to St. Paul´s dictum "If a man will not work, he shall not eat." (2 Thes. 3:10) Similarly, if a sinner will not repent by acting in obedience to grace, he shall not receive an indulgence. For indulgences are like student grants for people who want to study sanctity, not like free diplomas for slackers who want to party. They are spiritual gifts to help us work out our salvation with fear and trembling, not carte blanche so that we needn´t bother with sanctity at all. And even so, they are granted with incredible ease and frequency for the most trifling acts of obedience to grace--like saying an "Our Father" or reading Scripture for 15 short minutes. Evidently, God and His Church want us to be blessed and graced So in the end, this Evangelical-gone-Catholic came to realize what a great pity it is (and one long overdue to be rectified) that many honest Protestants like myself have feared indulgences as nothing but a corrupt medieval money-making scheme. They are nothing of the kind originally and, though their good name was dragged through the mud by Tetzel and his ilk, they have been nothing of the kind since Trent. It is high time lay Catholics make clear, in Protestantese, that indulgences don´t make cents, they make sense!

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular