timminsfamilycounselling.com tamoxifen transition milk buy baclofen 20 mg uk weingutkohl.de resep metronidazole jika ditambah amoxicillin amoxicillin de 850 mg buy levitra brand name detox from prozac with essential oils fungsi obat novamox 500 amoxicillin can u take flexeril with baclofen how many dose of cipromax fort 500 should i take a day plavix price at walmart which is better fluconazole pill or nose spray cipro lawsuit settlements purchasing viagra in canada albuterol .083 nebulizer 3 year old 60 celebrex 200mg can ciprotab terminates early pregnancy zoloft 25mg reviews themetrogalleries.com peta premarin for mtf phenergan migraine buy metoprolol succinate online waterfrontalehouse.com boredstop.com metoprolol re 79 arilarotokiralama.com montelukast without aspartame neurontin gabapentin cough gerd avodart 2.5 mg hair loss yogaindailylife.org kmmvin.eu trazodone 450 mg how can i terminate pregnancy with st mom and cytotec micardis 20 mg zithromax 600 mg how to by parvoone metronidazole in south africa vpdcorp.com felodipine 5 gm content-catalyst.com warfarin 4mg tablet price of cytotec 200 mcg in india oeufspolis.com furosemide 12.5mg montelukast sod 10 mg tablet allergy treatment will leukopenia improve after zyprexa stopped waterfrontalehouse.com grandcanyonbrewery.com can u masterbate while on diflucan medication persantine 25 mg tablets clasificacion del avapro taking ibuprofen lisinopril and lorazepam how long does zyprexa stay in your body biofiredx.com naproxen 500 mg. online propranolol extended release 60 mg tremors can i take singulair every 12 hours famvir guatemala generic citalopram hydrobromide sandoz azithromycin price in pakistan bethubsportsblog.com generic famvir australia remeron ilacinin digerleri can you take probiotics whilst taking raloxifene siwe.be can mirtazapine 7.5 give you energy the next day can u overdose on a prednisone 7 day pack tapering off neurontin side effects fosamax 600 clonidine 0.1 mg price albuterol tablets no prescription philipines market price cipro xr 2 dosis de cytotec deja esteril augmentin jr 12 hrs side effects of forgetting to take synthroid bisolvon and azithromycin prednisone and alcohol uk neurontin and percocet 10 allcoinreviews.org doxycycline ambroxol capsule afekchess.com can you inject gabapentin 800mg terbinafine hci 250 piroxicam beta cyclodextrin 20mg price for singulair pediatric acyclovir dose for cold sores gothamistllc.com q2melbourne.com prednisone dosage for 25 lb dog how does glucophage looks like meccanicanova.com clomid side effects male azithromycin how long eye infection to clear buy synthroid online no prescription needed generic singulair united states uasa.co.za cheap viagra online tamoxifen citrate 20 mg pct gurning on sertraline generic viagra in san jose combination of tamsulosin dutesteride hplc method prednisone 20mg and blurry vision buy cheap anastrozole no prescription druge interactionwith metoprolol 25 mg and hydrocodone avodart require presription in rite aid fehmierduran.com harga strattera 50mg can you take quetiapine 700mg with codeine uses for levofloxacin yahoo buy levitra sample torsemide online atomoxetine vs bupropion cost of zyvox per pill phenergan for nausea ulcerative colitis doxycycline hyclate dosage for cats can i take 1000 mg of valtrex daily shelf life of premarin cream once opened hydrochlorothiazide 50 mg diabetes niwali.com lexapro price australia para q sirbe el amoxicillin infantil szcy5.com cipro appetite syrup generic for cardizem cd 360 hibiotic syrup with azithromycin can u get high off of mirtazapine 45 mg of snort them refineyourfeel.com taars.org die-liedertafel.de augmentin antibiotics and alcohol azfamilylawattorney.com clopidogrel poison atarax drops strength is synthroid 25 mcg safe during breastfeeding apartamenty-kasztelanskie.pl deltasone for bee sting se puede tomar la aspirina junto con el captopril cipro vs levofloxacin for tooth infection started nortriptyline will insomnia go away mirtazapine in mexico stem.neu.edu louielouie.net can i take 500mg metronidazole 3 times a day flagyl composition finasteride hair loss reviews where is metoprolol 831 manufactured nizoral 400 mg ovulos an secretlives.me can u buy bactrim in mexico over the counter strausser.com 10mg cialis daily how to dirise pt witg lasix allergy voltaren resinat v cz levothyroxine and buspirone daily esporaeventosycomunicacion.com free viagra samples before buying index can you take atarax for fever blisters isotretinoin 20 mg capsules webafest.com.au alexcitypr.com benicar cost with insurance tbr.pl aatif.lu lisinopril side effects delayed paxil mg fluvoxamine 400 mg biotech ciprofolixin common prednisone taper schedule russianfestival.ie metronidazole is used to treat side effects of metformin er 750 mg aspirin lisinopril 5 mg amitriptyline cause weight gain albuterol inhaler color who is taking metformin and fertilaid and got pregnant valtrex uk prednisone cost without insurance cvs viagra how many cost india prise what is the function of diflucan pessaries purchase prozac strangfuneral.org clomid and frequent urination groganstudios.com cara penggunaan olanzapine nyscaa.org difference entre ciprofloxacine et co tri metronidazole can fluconazole caps heal bad odour ascbelfast.com marontech.com.my il coumadin e compatibile con isoptin 40 mg 10 mg lisinopril by lupin for sale dapoxetine at singapore market haciendahotel-oldtown.com celebrex 75 mg does cansten vaginal tablets work well with doxycycline voltaren gel canada can clomid be taken during pregnancy hindi what is coreg 3.125 used for pristiq zyprexa elderly illusions seroquel flomax stomach cramps lean pcos metformin skin rash flagyl 200 or 400 for bv fluconazole 150 mg brand name in philippines paroxetine and pruritus can u shoot neurontin viagra 80 year old man levitra buy no prescription brtop.net duo decadron para sinusitis verapamil 8 in vanpen base flagyl metronidazole injection purpose 100 mg prednisone for cannine lymphoma i took fluconazole and my foot still itchy amoxicillin price uk misoprostol en chile how long to get over poison ivy with prednisone cabinetsbydesignsarasota.com does missing doses of lexapro cause nausea viagra 75 mg can i take lexapro with sudafed efek samping obat celebrex 100mg amaryl tab misoprostol bleeding 3 weeks erowids vault prednisone where in lagos can we see provera tablet buy com-tur.com citalopram hydrobromide 10 mg side effects bactrim combate e.coli stendhal.com verapamil hcl 40 mg tab cialis price in faisalabad what can a buspirone and a 400mg motrin to you propecia working after only stem.neu.edu cheap actos 45 mg soleaturk.com withdrawal symptoms of gabapentin in dogs cyproheptadine syrup appetite generic inderal side effects q es metformina sevban.com linezolid cost effectiveness millionaire-meena.com dws-xip.pl dose for 250 man nexium switching from effexor to cymbalta side effects louielouie.net prednisone for hot spots in dogs metformin sr 500mg how does it work viagra soft flavored sildenafil 100mg buy zovirax with discount post protate taking 5mg cialis finasteride success zithromax gonorrhea australia what is the effect of flagyl 500gm menstrual cycle yogaindailylife.org prednisone side effects yahoo eu-atp.org bactrim cats dosage twentynineinches-de.com albuterol duration pets 173 part adalat louielouie.net when can drink alcohol after metronidazole 500 canada is diltiazem 120 er an 120cd the same taking flagyl cloudy urine orlistat capsules side effects hindi prednisone 4 mg 6 day pack westregion.org herbal viagra 6800mg arthurstractors.com meccanicanova.com IMAJJI.COM amitriptyline 25 mg high content-catalyst.com ondansetron hcl 4 mg iv walterbruck.de 1001.org fungsi salep dexamethasone 0.5 mg can someone overdose on citalopram cost-monitor.com dunnacupuncture.com augmentin vitamin interaction unitedreporters.com tac dung zestrill cipro uses for std taking 75 mg seroquel and 150 mg zoloft erectile dysfunction buy herbal viagra india rs. soleaturk.com maigrir avec trazodone mylan 100 arroyograndecc.com piroxicam adalah obat apa penggunaan ondansetron 4mg thyroxine fetal movement how quickly does cipro work on uti for dogs excessive thyroxine levels wat is nexium purplepill in nederlands si tomo misoprostol caducado funciona majkb.com metronidazole and povidine use in dogs lexamil antidepressant with celebrex reviews buy lamisil online uk does viagra work if you are not turned on carpetandfloors.co.uk what time to take 1000mg azithromycin plavix purchase canada how much is propecia at walmart cialis 20mg tablets price in pakistan can i split a 20mg lisinopril be cut in half acyclovir 2gm bid metronidazole 500 mg iv drug study harga glimepiride 4 mg doxycycline for dog propecia price cvs wellbutrin 450 xl side effects sertraline side effects 21 year old webbrowsers.lv starting dose of seroquel for hallucinations zynaps.com plavix 15 dollar coupon metformin hcl 500 mg and fluid retention harga pil voltaren 50 mg themetrogalleries.com proactivelogic.com doxycycline suspension recipe side effects of prednisone in cats voice cialis commercial how much should cat antibiotics cost philippines cipro for uti price how to prevent a headaches reviews on cialis marontech.com.my para que sirve valacyclovir hcl autogiant.com costco allegra d generic erection better with cialis 40mg albuterol inhaler generic version coupon for valtrex or valacyclovir hcl 1 gram amlodipine besylate online pharmacy what the side effects of naproxen snow fun 5x5.hu wellbutrin xl 450 mg seizure risk chamber.md theburgeradventure.com trishm-ministries.com clomid and pregnancy rates in chart augmentin 625 plus uses can u take dramamine after taking zofran price lexapro 5 mg viagra cheap online uk nizoral salap false positive drug test buspirone usian.org how long does fluconazole bloating take redzigaismu.lv generic lexapro ambien my cat ate paxil nizoral for an an flagyl 125 treatedwhat thyroxine sodium clubdeayudaauditiva.com meccanicanova.com cuantas cytotec debo tomar si tengo 1 mes pastilla cytotec sirve para bajar la regla gkris.com acyclovir cream australia when to take next single dose of diflucan how many mg of zoloft does it take to kill you haciendahotel-oldtown.com paroxetine hcl 20 mg tablet how much rand does viagra cost in joburg s.a cheapest cialis canada camerata.com photoloco.com andrijastepic.renianstudio.com side effect zithromax 6 month old learninc.org sichtwandel.ch zyvox pfizer egypt reducing propecia dosage huntofalifetime.org minipress 1 mg tabletta artitself.com side effect on 1 g zithromax prednisone 50 mg burst 3 days for headache ryman.pl dapoxetine buy uk benazepril 10 mg side effects q2melbourne.com dapoxetine trade name in germany blakesgourmet.com diclofenac baclofen cyclobenz tetra cytotec 5 weeks pregnant generic celexa manufacturers advantagegolfcars.com purchase voltaren gel felodipine generic drug micardis hct generic alternative dapoxetine hydrochloride for sale can coreg cause stomach bloating is kamagra safe to take with lisinopril fluconazole side effects on day 2 estrace cream termitepestsolutions.com late period after taking clomid.what drugs can i take cialis price nz vpdcorp.com weingutkohl.de smallprint.netzoo.net can green tea help with weight while taking remeron quetiapine nursing interventions celebrex 200 after affects how much trazodone and alcohol will kill me can lisinopril be taken with aspirin photoloco.com corral88.org rating of cymbalda versus celexa as an antidepressant roaccutane day 30 names of indian no. 1 ketoconazole side effects of provera 30mg erythromycin cream in mercury drug ryman.pl cost cialis usa para que sirve nexium 40 mg hansrajcollege.info increasedlexapro to 15 mg cialis generic fda approved pharmacy etaflox cipro antibiotik augmentin prednisone dosage for poison ivy ciesielstwokukulak.com.pl monikagawor.pl addictedtoallthingspretty.com gabapentin cream how much does it cost cytotec en que farmacias de costa rica conseguir provera quantos dias para descer how long does 1000mg antibiotics take.com diflucan 150 mg pret compensat what is prednisone 20 mg used for aturan pakai cytotec 200mg untuk hamil 11 minggu amitriptyline gg 44 snort fexofenadine 180 mg no prescription zyvox metformin 1 g tablets olanzapine 10 clomid trigger shot and progesterone success rates dutasteride tab mirtazapine alcohol night sweat olanzapine 2.5 milligrams does it make fat wpodrozy.eu is 15mg of anti depressant a high or low does augmentin paediatric syrup in india brand adalat during pregnancy lbc4help.org provera 5 mg for 7 days cardura xl 4mg ampicillin mg ml taking lipitor, amlodipine and vitamin d nhs zithromax 1g chlamydia zovirax 400 mg price albuterol one year old daisylcreations.com price of cardura xl 4mg in ireland majkb.com proscar annual sales can you take singulair 10 mg twice a day levitra generic 10 order cialis canada how long should i take fluconazole 100mg digoxin 25mg obat apa. contraindications trazodone and pain killers levofloxacin 500 is safe during pregnancy or not where can i buy depo provera without a prescription lipitor side effects with vitamins side effects of buspirone 20 mg cabinetsbydesignsarasota.com how long does singulair stay in your system simvastatin amlodipine 20 mg can you take maxalt after taking tylenol am1320.com buy lexapro online no prescription nasminc.com berenboom.com where can i buy lamisil 200 mg 100 milligrams of clomid arroyograndecc.com hanhvyshop.vn strattera australia pbs levofloxacina ampollas 750 trade name for prednisone is fluconazole safe for 6 months pregnant withdrawal symptoms cymbalta australia amoxicillin jock itch adamstudio.pl twospy.com piroxicam fiale sandoz can you take chantix with wellbutrin and zoloft rf5.org naproxen 250mg nabing ton weingutkohl.de

Anonymity in the Confessional

And more on the Rite of Washing of the Feet.
by Father Edward McNamara | Source: Catholic.net
And More on the Rite of Washing of the Feet

Answered by Father Edward McNamara, professor of liturgy at the Regina Apostolorum Pontifical Athenaeum.

Q. Is it permissible, and/or is there any good reason for a confessor to ask the identity of a penitent when the confession is anonymous; that is, it is not "face to face"? -- L.L., Washington, D.C.

A: Anonymous confession, along with the confessional as we know it today, is generally attributed to an initiative of St. Charles Borromeo (1538-1584), the archbishop of Milan, Italy. Previously, the confessor would sit in a chair and the penitent, who usually was kneeling, was clearly visible to him.

In order to ensure modesty and discretion, Cardinal Borromeo mandated in 1564 that the confessionals in his diocese be closed on both sides with a grill between penitent and priest. Pope Paul V's Roman Ritual adopted this provision, which helped spread its use, although it did not become a universal practice until the 17th century.

Anonymous confession remains the norm although current dispositions allow for the penitent who so desires to request face-to-face confession. And confessionals may be designed to allow for both options.

Although the penitent may request face-to-face confession, the priest is not obliged to accede to the request and may insist on the use of the grill.

If a penitent desires anonymity, the priest should respect this desire and in the vast majority of situations he should never have any need or right to inquire as to the identity of the penitent.

Even if the priest recognizes the penitent it is usually more prudent not to make personal references unless the penitent makes some form of self-identification or the circumstances warrant it, such as could be the case of a regular penitent well known to the priest.

More frequently there may be situations when, in order to determine the exact nature and gravity of the sin involved, the priest may make a general inquiry as to the penitent's state in life, for example, if he or she is married, or a vowed religious, etc.

In some confessionals, where the penitent is almost invisible, it can happen that a priest may have to ask some detail of age, or even sex, in order to tailor his counsel to the penitent's specific characteristics.

Some very grave sins, such as abortion, also might incur excommunication reserved to the bishop or in some special cases, such as the deliberate profanation of the Eucharist, to the Holy See.

In such cases the confessor may not be able to grant absolution immediately, or only on condition that the penitent requests the lifting of the canonical penalty within a month from the competent authority.

As most penitents would be unaware of how to go about this process, the priest may offer to help by contacting either the bishop or the Holy See as the case may be. This is always done without revealing any personal data or identifying circumstances (see Canon 1357).

If the penitent wishes to remain anonymous then he or she may make an appointment to return to confession to the same priest after a certain time in order to have the sanction formally lifted. But in some cases it may be necessary to reveal some personal data so that the priest can inform the penitent of the arrival of the proper authorization.

* * *

Follow-up: Washing of the Feet

Our replies regarding feet washing and the use of the crucifix rather than a cross (March 23) generated a high level of correspondence some of which was very informative and which also leads me to review some of my previous statements.

Regarding washing only men's feet on Holy Thursday, several readers asked about a statement published by the U.S. bishops' liturgy committee in 1987 (see www.usccb.org/liturgy/q&a/general/feet.htm).

Paragraphs 4 and 5 read:

"Because the gospel of the mandatum read on Holy Thursday also depicts Jesus as the 'Teacher and Lord' who humbly serves his disciples by performing this extraordinary gesture which goes beyond the laws of hospitality, the element of humble service has accentuated the celebration of the foot washing rite in the United States over the last decade or more. In this regard, it has become customary in many places to invite that both men and women to be participants in this rite in recognition of the service that should be given by all the faithful to the Church and to the world. Thus, in the United States, a variation in the rite developed in which not only charity is signified but also humble service.

"While this variation may differ from the rubric of the Sacramentary which mentions only men ('viri selecti'), it may nevertheless be said that the intention to emphasize service along with charity in the celebration of the rite is an understandable way of accentuating the evangelical command of the Lord, 'who came to serve and not to be served,' that all members of the Church must serve one another in love."

One correspondent, a woman, asks: "Did the U.S. conference have the authority to change the rubric of the Sacramentary? Did it get the approval of Rome? Certain dioceses will allow men only to have their feet washed; Jesus chose 12 men, his apostles."

I was not unaware of this statement. But since the entire text is couched in ambiguous terms and does not claim any authority whatsoever (in spite of the aura of officialdom in its being published by the liturgy committee) I did not consider it a relevant source.

What is surprising in this document is that it does not question the premise that a pastor or even a bishop has the authority to change or vary a specific rite at his own behest. He does not have such authority except where the law specifically allows him to do so.

This said, other paragraphs of the above statement correctly recall that this rite was reintroduced into parish celebrations relatively recently (1955) and so, as a rite, cannot claim a long liturgical tradition directly linking it to Christ's action on Holy Thursday -- although this is the obvious interpretation.

Thus, at least hypothetically, it could be subject to a reinterpretation to "emphasize service along with charity" in such a way as to be also open to women.

Yet the proper authority for such a reinterpretation is the Holy See or a two-thirds vote of an episcopal conference ratified by the Holy See and not an individual bishop or pastor.

Another correspondent affirmed that the Holy See had informed an American cardinal that women were not excluded from the rite, but the writer was unable to provide sources. I have been unable to corroborate this affirmation from any official source. The above-mentioned statement from the liturgy committee explicitly states that no further official pronunciations have been made since 1987 (although the new Latin missal reconfirms the rubric regarding only men being called). If this affirmation is confirmed, then obviously our position would have to change.

Several other readers questioned the strength of my argument regarding the obligatory nature of using a crucifix during the Good Friday adoration of the cross.

They point out, and correctly I think, that the actual text of the rubrics does not specifically state that a crucifix be used. They also note that my use of the first form of the rite to uphold my point was more a description of how the rite is usually carried out than an analysis of the rubrics.

Also, some official documents such as the U.S. bishops' recent "Built on Living Stones" (No. 83) specifically allow either a cross or a crucifix for veneration on Good Friday.

Part of the difficulty is that Latin uses the same word for cross and crucifix, although in liturgical documents over the last several centuries the word "cross" almost invariably meant crucifix. A cross without the figure of Christ was practically unknown in a liturgical context.

Accordingly, I agree with a correspondent from New Zealand, who noted there is little significance in "the change to 'dextrum brachium Crucis' instead of 'brachium dextrum Crucifixi' as one of the many changes, some merely stylistic, that the Second Vatican Council revision of the Missal made in the rubrics of Pope Pius XII's reform of the 'Triduum Sacrum' liturgy. Rather, I see this change as acceptance of the inevitability, when uncovering the right arm of the figure of Christ crucified, of unveiling also the whole right arm of the cross."

The new General Instruction of the Roman Missal (GIRM) does at times specify that the cross used at Mass should have the figure of Christ. But this specification has only become necessary because of recent attempts to introduce figureless crosses into churches.

At other times the Latin document simply refers to this crucifix as the cross, such as when it describes the rite of incensing. Thus I do not believe that each time the Latin GIRM or the rubrics do not specify that the cross have a figure, it follows that either a cross or a crucifix may be used.

It is also true, as another reader states, that "a cross without a corpus harkens back to the original form of this rite, derived from the Jerusalem rite, in which the actual relic of the cross was venerated. For this reason the hymns all speak of the 'crux.'"

If a church were to possess a relic of the true cross of Christ, then of course it should be used on Good Friday. But this is a rare privilege and so historically the use of the crucifix as a substitute came to predominate.

Therefore, while admitting that my former argument lacked force, I would contend that the overall weight of traditional liturgical practice falls heavily in favor of the use of the crucifix.

I would further move that the use of the crucifix is much better from a pastoral point of view. Once more I concur with our writer from New Zealand: "'Venite, adoremus' is the response of the people at the Good Friday liturgical service, and we kneel in worship. We do not worship a mere cross ... but the Person who died on a cross." And it seems best to emphasize this by using the cross with the image of the Crucified.

Another reader asked where to find the document on the removal of holy water during Lent.

This document comes from the review Notitiae, the official organ of the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Sacraments, which unfortunately does not yet publish this review online. Fortunately this document was published in an interesting site called www.catholicliturgy.com.

Finally, I would like to thank all our correspondents, especially those who disagreed with me, for the exemplary Christian courtesy used in their communications. I desire a blessed Easter to all.


Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows Catholic.net to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to Catholic.net right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular