ovaries hurt while on clomid clopidogrel mechanism of action animation cialis availible in doha lexapro cyclothymia bactrim para garganta inflamada amoxicillin 1000 sore throat kamagra 50mg jelly ibizaglobalradio.com uniquesarawak.com hanhvyshop.vn avastan.pl michellestockman.com hastings-print.co.uk can a 80 pound pitbull have meloxicam 15 mg diflucan mg dosage price of cialis at costco is this a reflux ic cyproheptadine medician buying viagra online uk robaxin y ibuprofeno asylum-booksandgames.com ile-au-tresor.net hopemedicalinstitute.org preferable time to give tamsulosin tablet is viagra safe if try to get pregnant zoloft withdrawal manic viagra pil 100mg trade names of gabapentin to treat sciatica in pakistan eighteen dollar nexium ciprofloxacin picaturi pret allegra 93 7252 la viagra informacion balkan-area.com meloxicam 7.5 para que sirve en gatos uk classifieds cheap generic viagra kamagra diflucan 250 compresse compatibility of linezolid with tpn cytotec misoprostolsearle 1461 tadalafil online rx4u doxepin 10 mg cialis permanent side effects akademia-active.pl bikerlawblog.com catholic.net can zucchini adverse the effects of warfarin idesignawards.com ascbelfast.com buy 1200mg gabapentin online ivermectina para perros via de administracion azithromycin oral suspension dosage fatigue is cialis maximum daily dose of rizatriptan benzoate cost of viagra in the local chemist diflucan dosage treatment ebodesign.com valtrex chest pain mkvisio.pl lamisil once krem kullananlar finacare finasteride cream phenergan at walmart what can viagra do to a girl flagyl in iv citalopram 40 mg if snorted hollisterlancasterlaw.com hollisterlancasterlaw.com contraceptive pill contraindications with clomid will i last longer in bed with cialis internationalintellectualproperty.org are lamisil and lotrimin the same taking propecia and trying to have baby quetiapine effects on pupils can you take rimadyl and amoxicillin price propecia walmart shawniverse.com mkvisio.pl levitra side effects women uses of metronidazole in leishmania mynitor.com levaquin insomnia side effects cheap viagra sildenafil viagra sellers in lahore pakistan cipro for treatment of boils do viagra and cialis mix happydeal4u.com taking diflucan is itching die off where can i order nizoral capsule here in philippines tamoxifen w?hrend der schwangerschaft gabapentin degenerative myelopathy is it safe to excercise after taking cialis celebrex side effects taking 300mg a day for ra augmentin 400 nexium ptr copii lamisil crema pret dona najlepszykredytmieszkaniowy.com.pl diflucan and chlamydia ivermectina en sarna demodecica kamagra 100mg how many celebrex can i take in a day que contiene el montelukast 10 mg bushidozazen.com can i drink a glass of wine while on azithromycin vuongminh.com amoxicillin with or without food how long until cialis most effective levofloxacin 500 mg tablets cost michaelgahler.de how long does levitra last after expiration side effects discontinuing nexium viagra store in calgary septra mp 85 was ist priligy buspirone as using diflucan and monistat together the effect on women of men taking cialis how does tadalafil work will 100 metformin 850mg tablets kill me day 29 on clomid no period ciprofloxacina abscesos citalopram and ciprofloxacin albuterol sulfate for 1 year old cheapest viagra 100mg buy metronidazole no prescription 500mg levofloxacin and citrus foods doxycycline dog dose tooth infection sandoz hla 20 atorvastatin buy chinese herbal viagra duro prednisone and proair informatyk-szczecin.com.pl voltaren k without food purchase finasteride cheap can you drink alcohol while on viagra buy clonidine 0.1mg celexa feliz information propecia online fake 1819wine.com generic flomax over the counter steroid forums where to buy nolvadex cuantas semanas dura la pastilla cytotec tamoxifeno ciclo durateston buy clomiphene legally adalat desi tashan all episode cdfeorellana.com ciprofloxacin used for ibs 20mg lexapro depression can i take bactrim with zoloft doxycycline with lactic acid bacillus mikezielinski.com muslimdate.com gabapentin bad reaction aliikayaks.com can flamar mx be used with dexamethasone mebletmd.pl njxdxx.com clonidine 01 mg and amitriptyline togther marchesa allegra ciprofloxacine eco 500 contient du gluten tetracycline anorexia dysfunction erectile result treatment doxycycline hyclate for dogs 100 mg metformina salbutamol w3asia.com metronidazole for dogs urinary tract infections henrycavillfan.org grifulvin howdotofound discount zithromax over the counter in vegas cialis precio farmacia ahumada 60 mg prednisone taper schedule buy fluoxetine hcl online juegos celebrex cialis ayunas wast.org.uk how long does it take for fluconazole to kill worms tussionex and allegra albuterol 4mg dosage for dogs apparel-chic.com will atarax help with an allergic reaction to tylenol 3 cat antibiotics and sneezing side effects wendy-unes.com icsliberia.org prednisone and fertility in dogs side effects of thyroxine sodium tablets 100 mg webfin.pl priligy shoppers drug mart kegunaan amoxicillin trihydrate phenergan suppository interactions eeroaarnio.cz late periods on clomid after ovulation upd315.com do not mix synthroid with cymbalta omeprazol biozole fluconazole antifungal agent wie einnehmen how much propecia per day buy nolvadex wholesale who sells generic cialis in the uk vapplica.org where to buy estrace cream cheap afdoor.com sarasotacojail.com can prednisone damage kidneys medicadent.ru side effects of flagyl in the first trimester will amoxicillin 100 mg treat gonorrhea moravskavina.cz zofran at 6 weeks pregnant can i have a drink on paxil baclofen and cerebral palsy how much cialis will insurance entropicity.com houseontheisland.com taking fluconazole during pregnancy reviews cialis over the counter dubai medievalcostumesandgifts.com valacyclovir kopen vrlaksaraytransfer.com clopidogrel purity flagyl nursing considerations lexapro kopen bupropion hcl sr 400 mg happydeal4u.com zofran and alcohol withdrawal zithromax buy online australia interaction strattera peanut butter hoxtonradio.com avodart psa mooboos.com amoxicillin and combined pill meblebrzozowe24.pl annsweddings.com.au generic levitra 2.5 mg side effects erection cream nottingham internetowe-szkolenia.pl price of metformin in mexico q serve remedio propranolol ile-au-tresor.net hoxtonradio.com avodart generic cost flagyl amoxicillin kombination olanzapine for itching ibicisi.com what time of day should i take premarin vardenafil costco nitroglycerin spray cost bupropion hcl xl 150 mg side effects zocor and viagra hedleyenterprises.co.uk gabapentin and naproxen can it get u high spearsecurity.com montelukast drug description costo diflucan 150 mg erection cream walgreens estradiol side effects weight gain purchase wellbutrin xl online jethroshouse.co.uk can u drink alcohol when on clomid idesignawards.com bikerlawblog.com mebletmd.pl hopemedicaleducation.com mehmetaliguven.com erythromycin treat std cialis blazer hydroxyzine hcl no prescription doxycycline neisseria generic viagra cheapest online wast.org.uk allegra printing rockford il cialis permanent cure lisinopril coupons does neurontin make you grind your teeth iheartjonahbees.net nolvadex 10 mg for pregnancy hillsboroughcountyfair.com have you taken levaquin viagra donde comprar peru accutane beta blockers abilify damla kullananlar does prednisone raise bp allegra 24 sailboat singulair mini granule cijena ascbelfast.com seroquel hypnotic newhollandcommunications.de buy plavix without gabapentin side effects in men vorrei prendere il viagra harbifilmizle.com where can i get cytotec searle pills in south africa dostinex 0 5 mg 2 comprimidos digoxin 0 25 mg 50 tablet spotting 9 dpo on clomid how much doxycycline for dogs buspar gi trazodone hydrochloride with mitrazipine cialis 10 mg tutti i giorni overdose of plavix for dogs apartamenty-kasztelanskie.pl do lisinopril 10mg have hctz uncn.org wendy-unes.com idesignawards.com msds nitroglycerin generic cialis switzerland 60mg remeron mechanism of action bactrim and keflex staph infection thefresnocojail.com shawniverse.com finasteride ipertrofia prostatica benigna ibicisi.com kosbonso.com experiencias con serophene ventolin oral side effects hopemedicalinstitute.org variamedia.com.pl zyprexa 10 mg nedir thyroxine and mitochondria amoxicillin capsule brand name in pakistan escitalopram 10mg coupons doxycycline hyclate tongue bad valtrex in mexico 8haotejia.com viagra cheap less xenical 60 mg 250 flagyl dosage for bv treatment weltrowska.com.pl can you take amitriptyline with bactrim ds metoprolol tartrato efectos adversos finasteride y minoxidil comprar can amoxicillin cure bladder infection clomid side effects burning donde comprar viagra granada which is better amoxicillin or penicillin propranolol hypertension metoprolol 50 mg ok with suboxon 50mg of viagra and weed irishphil.com yahoo levofloxacin 250 mg levaquin timeline for results caterina allegra tupperware prezzo dostinex 0.5 mg side effects synthroid 137 mcg side effects vizioescort.com cymbalta y colon irritable citalopram and amitriptyline and alcohol buying albuterol inhaler how long for 1000mg antibiotics to work out what is the percentage of weight gain in lexapro fluconazole 150 mg philippine price street price for elavil 10mg does a bigger cialis dose produce a better erection prednisone oysters bupropion hcl xl pregnancy mirtazapine 5ht3 atomoxetine 10 terbinafine hydochloride andmometasone furoate cream do you take suprax 200 mg and zithromax 500 for std angellsangels.com mrw-2012.pl can you take allegra while breastfeeding mediatrax.com valacyclovir for bladder infection zithromax cost ireland target pharmacy cephalexin cvs glucophage xr what will happen if one take viagra 25g every day will allegra d give me some energy arimidex 1 mg cost augmentin cach dung fervedor allegra celibar.pl buy acyclovir cream uk awam ki adalat veena malik full episode furosemide vs bumetanide atorvastatin alternative drugs clomid and dentist accutane 20mg a day benefits of ventolin inhaler michaelgahler.de average weight loss on metformin for overweight people can a guinea pig take doxycycline aygestin 5 mg price lasix high cholesterol what do they do for lexapro overdose how fast does clomid start working aciclovir sirve para las hemorroides anafranil 25 prezzo cialis 100 mg strength buy clomid online ireland amigosdeamerica.org mildreddeskinsjewelry.com dosage oxytetracycline salmon poisoning woodmizer.org.pl which is better levitra cialis viagra zyprexa increased appetite india made viagra 100 tablets for erectile naproxen 1000 mg and alcohol half life of wellbutrin xl 300 mg when is it not ok to give a dog amoxicillin heartworm without ivermectin axellerata.com scoat anafranil clomipramin hydrochl novartis for clopidogrel 75 mg drug action does quetiapine fumarate contain acetaminophen prospect augmentin 600 when do accutane symptoms start droguerias de barranquilla donde venden el misoprostol synthroid weekly dose augmentin prospect alaptare where can find propecia 1 mh tablet in uae tamoxifen and thrush propranolol use in heart failure how much does it cost to buy xenical from the uk arimidex for sale hillsboroughcountyfair.com side effects abruptly stopping synthroid acyclovir and potassium levels momandfitness.com tamoxifen 4 hydroxytamoxifen mipcperu.com nlpcloud.net sklepy-zoologiczne.pl mirtazapine 60 mg side effects olanzapine 2.5 side effects celexa changing effects from paxil side mikezielinski.com should you stop plavix before surgery seroquel xr 150 mg side effects wirkt metformin sofort drinking alcohol on 25 mgs seroquel flagyl iv given para q sirve piroxicam valler 20 mg can you mix celebrex and tylenol buy zovirax cream from canada ashton kutcher finasteride bactrim uti length of treatment vollemaan.org myexactamundo.com acyclovir whartisthebestin australia artdecade.com adalat xl 30 third trimester i 19 can i take viagra meastcompany.com quetiapine risperidone conversion how long do i need to take synthroid prednisone and the menstrual cycle do wellbutrin and cymbalta cause low blood sugar amoxilin daily dose for acne metspirit.com webfin.pl hlahlaaung.com is it safe to take clomid after preterm labour michaelgahler.de cialis 10 mg t?glich mynitor.com propranolol tablets for sale fingras orlistat lo recomienda el doctor cormillod clomipramine 50 mg capsule does hydroxyzine 25 mg get you high harelitasarim.com mycontradictions.com como funciona sertraline nlpcloud.net what is cephalexin 500 for can revatio be used as viagra worldtravelandtourservices.com ciprofloxacn 600mg 2.5 mg lexapro works for me gabapentin fibromyalgia side effects henrycavillfan.org buy viagra cialis online pharmacy pregnancy class for allegra ciprofloxacino intoxicacion alimentaria does probiotics affect metoprolol medication el flagyl es antibiotico ivermectina oral sarna buy esomeprazole dutasteride for hairloss proper dose baufinanzierung-aktuell.com napahappy.com wellbutrin negative thinking wonderlandae.com cialis generic 100mg cat albuterol inhaler can you take phenergan every 4 hours cialis 20 mg twice in 24 hours wpmodder.com can you chew amoxicillin metformin side effects nausea treatment viagra kaufen auf rechnung levothyroxine adverse drug reactions diverticulitis azithromycin cialis bij gezonde mannen alhafeer4dev.sy anaheimangelsjersey.com if lynoral prevent pregnency nexium 20 mg capsule online buy dog gabapentin harga cytotec apotik nizoral jel citalopram online no prescription informatyk-szczecin.com.pl directions for ketoconazole

An Evangelical Ignatius?

Rick Warren, pastor for Saddleback Church in Lake Forest, Calif., has written a kind of Spiritual Exercises for today’s evangelical Christian. While The Purpose Driven Life shares much in common with the work of Saint Ignatius, the differences …
by Jay Dunlap | Source:
Review of: The Purpose Driven Life, by Rick Warren
Grand Rapids, Mich.: Zondervan. Copyright 2002

The Spiritual Exercises of Saint Ignatius Loyola is one of the towering spiritual masterpieces of all time. Though originally designed for thirty days of silence with five intense meditations each day, the Exercises have been adapted for everything from short weekend retreats to a lengthy, nine-month process.

Rick Warren, pastor for thousands of families at the bustling Saddleback Church in Lake Forest, Calif., has written a kind of Spiritual Exercises for today’s evangelical Christian. While The Purpose Driven Life shares much in common with the work of Saint Ignatius, the differences are profound enough to call into question its usefulness for Catholic readers.

Ignatius’s program calls for four “weeks” of intense prayer (though the amount of time spent on each week can vary widely, depending on the retreatants’ needs). The first week focuses on God’s love and the call to reconciliation; week two emphasizes meditating deeply on Christ through the gospels; week three involves knowing Christ even more deeply through his Passion and death; week four looks at Christ’s resurrection and calls the retreatant to commit himself to serving Christ.

Warren’s book comprises forty chapters, each a meditation for a day. They fit into five categories, the “five purposes” for which Warren says we are created: “worship - you were planned for God's pleasure; fellowship - you were formed to be part of God's family; discipleship - you were created to become like Christ; ministry - you were shaped for God's service; mission - you were made to tell others about Christ.” Though not dependent on a retreat master or spiritual director, as Ignatius’s Exercises are, Warren does recommend going through his forty lessons with at least one companion for purposes of discussion, support and accountability.

But The Purpose Driven Life is not simply an updated or expanded Spiritual Exercises. In fact, nowhere does Warren even refer to Ignatius.

The first essential difference is one in Warren’s favor, at least at first glance. He has written in an engaging, readable, first-person style. His text is full of insights from Scripture and daily experience; he explains clearly and insightfully the difference between a Christian view of the human person and what one gets from pop psychology and self-help manuals. Occasionally he lets loose with a riff of rhyming slogans that bring to the mind’s ear the eloquence of an inspired evangelical preacher: “Don’t repress it; confess it! Don’t conceal it; reveal it. Revealing your feeling is the beginning of healing” (p. 213).

Ignatius, on the other hand, wrote a manual for a much deeper spiritual experience that puts the burden on retreatant and retreat director. Many read the Spiritual Exercises and come away unimpressed. That’s because the Exercises aren’t to be read, they’re to be explored through hours of deep meditation and contemplation. This is harder work than reading and reflecting on Warren’s forty chapters. It makes Warren’s book far more accessible, but at a price.

The second major difference is the most troubling. While Warren quotes from a number of Catholic sources – St. Iranaeus, St. John of the Cross, Mother Theresa, Henri Nouwen – this is definitely not a Catholic book. He doesn't embrace sacramental grace. Communion receives only a passing reference; baptism is hailed as necessary not for the saving grace it achieves but because it “symbolizes” the “fellowship” to which all Christians are called.

As one might expect, Warren makes several references to being “born again,” but this is never connected to baptism, which is the Catholic understanding of it.

What is missing here is not only sacramental theology but the Catholic sacramental imagination. For instance, consider his contention that “There is no such thing as ‘Christian’ music; there are only Christian lyrics. It is the words that make a song sacred, not the tune” (p. 66). Warren is tone-deaf, so to speak, to the reality that created things, including art, affect us because of their objective nature. As the Church has long noted and reaffirmed at Vatican II, some music is sacred by its nature; other music is profane. What else accounts for the recent popularity of monastic chant recordings? It’s certainly not because the audience has any idea what the Latin words mean. It’s the inherent sacredness of the music.

Another example of the absence of Catholic imagination: Warren rails against the contemplative life “alone in a mountaintop monastery.” He writes that we are called to remain engaged in the world. Perhaps he should read the Story of a Soul to learn how a contemplative nun could become patron saint of missionaries.

It is sad that Warren’s otherwise excellent book fails on these accounts. If one is a well-formed Catholic looking for a helpful, readable resource, The Purpose Driven Life could be useful. The risk, however, is the book in the hands of the poorly formed Catholic who, experiencing the many blessings it presents, is unable to discern its weaknesses. If Warren were open to it, it would make sense to edit a Catholic version of the book, one that would make it safe in the hands of those whose understanding of the faith is undeveloped.

Media commentator Jay Dunlap writes from New Haven, Conn. He is a contributor to the National Catholic Register, This Rock and other Catholic periodicals.

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows Catholic.net to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to Catholic.net right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular