withdrawal symptoms of stopping prednisone can misoprostol damage the pregnancy of 3 weeks seroquel and breastfeeding substitution bactrim hiv prophylaxis hives from prednisone withdrawal acyclovir 200mg cap 30 para que sirve escitalopram cinfa 10 mg ceftin or augmentin flagyl 500 mg uses cheapest viagra 50 mg amoxicillin dose 6 month old what drug can replace lisinopril ciprobay helicobacter how is it possible that insurance pays for viagra azithromycin dysphagia baclofen and meth taking together is it okay 20 m of levitral q pasa si me he tomado la pastilla misoprostol order viagra online from india clomiphene and bleeding amoxil in second trimester flagyl sous cutan lamisil for thrush buy levitra no prescription uk metformin hcl can get you high do hydrochlorothiazide pills make you lose weight seroquel saved my life ed celexa organic version of lamisil presentaciones de diflucan accutane isotretinoin buy online buy cipla nolvadex kristen dalton allegra can you crush azithromycin tablets does nolvadex work with tren can take sertraline tylenol clomid psyche adalat darama 20 august how long does cialis last 5 mg does sertraline 150 mg make you tired ivermectin on chickens reviews prednisone dosage treatment gout synthroid and weight gain lopressor medical dictionary amoxicilline gamma gt bactrim for pcp prophylaxis drug interaction terazosin and tamsulosin nexium 20mg cide effect can cephalexin help pink eye zoloft 25 mg vidal itching side effects from ivermectin fluconazole dosage thrush is cetirizine the same montelukast lamisil 1x ar maksud fluconazole can i take cystex with plavix unat torsemide and gaut do misoprostol work for 6 months pregnant acyclovir augmentin for shingles flagyl walmart pharmacy ampicillin bei chlamydien viagra on dicks prednisone single dose can dogs take metronidazole for folliculitis acyclovir prevent infection abilify seroquel prolong course of finasteride 1mg order estradiol can clonidine get you high viagra mitral valve prolapse tetracycline 250mg tablet neurontin quinine doxycycline accord tabletten powerpoint presentation of viagra is zofran or phenergan better protonix 40 mgnexium 40 mg phenergan uses in urdu how much does amoxicillin cost at target lisinopril 10mg and ed clomid success rates with severe endometriosis ketoconazole at cvs otc gabapentin 100mg alcohol prezzi erboristeria viagra viagra acido urico celebrex uti metformin xr side effects cause loss sr weight wellbutrin can you mix losarton and cialis albuterol solution for nebulizer no rx ortho evra and ciprofloxacin celexa after 6 months zovirax cream patent paroxetine tablets 20mg viagra delivery to canada why men use viagra generic drug for micardis plus synthroid 37.5 mg kamagra gold review citalopram 20 mg for anxiety side effects baclofen half life can you take singulair and albuterol clomiphene no prescription what is clomid resistance septra suspension treat for cuanto tarda en hacer afecto anafranil de 10 mg harga obat ciprofroxaxine 500 mg neurontin 800 yan etkileri common uses of cialis nexium awp kamagra gel zagreb wo kann man legal viagra kaufen buy pet doxycycline tablets online dosage for cialis 20mg viagra best way to use 150 mg prednisone ok orlistat nigeria price lamisil at 1 spray 15ml can metoprolol succinate cause first degree heart block how long after clomid will i ovulate clomid thin womb lining diflucan 600mg dose first day candida when do side effects of olanzapine go away augmentin and serum sickness augmentin paeds dose generic estradiol cream lisinopril and rosacea is white flagyl tablet safe in pregnancy mylan metoprolol recall tips to keep libido while taking propecia cb viagra board ampicillin selective media metoprolol injetavel bula anvisa isotretinoin capsules usp 20 mg side effects neurontin for dog long term effects of using flomax can misoprostol work for 4weeks pregnancy getting off cymbalta symptoms cipro causing tendon rupture flomax rash alternatives eryson erythromycin base 250 review will viagra 10mg be sufficiant in old man case aciclovir 200mg neo quimica scared to take wellbutrin viagra generic 100mg ventolin and toddlers zofran side effects oculogyric nexium 40 zuzahlung does flagyl and amoxicillin cancel the the pill misoprostol ingrediente activo levitra tablets used for cost of generic zoloft without insurance dexilant nexium and prevacid how many mgs of azithromycin cure chlamydia pfizer lipitor brevet allergy to sulfa drugs and lasix can you snort clonidine esomeprazole 2c19 17 beta oestradiol trop bas nizoral shampoo price increase seroquel 100 mg comprimidos lisinopril tolerance bad effects of levaquin zyprexa depotmedicin missing dose of prednisone chinese name for topamax what if viagra pill broken puresis v lasix for cats how does cabergoline works side effect ng metformin kroger zovirax cream no prescription tadalafil jovenes does priligy works does gabapentin trigger ana genfar viagra bupropion y diabetes metronidazole heart palpitations azithromycin schl?gt nicht an effects if buproprion and citalopram does paroxetine reduction cause head tremour bactrim pharmaceutical dermatological antibiotic did you conceive on clomid and m2tone canine doseage singulair topamax male fertility side effects propranolol 60 mg side effects buy zovirax canada anafranil sr 75 faydalar?± fungsi dari clozaril misprescribed seroquel nizoral tablets in india does flagyl cause dark stool what is viagra age 50 lipitor rare side effects katalog produk cialis vand viagra baclofen addiction can i take lorazepam to reduce olanzapine withdrawals will one dose of zithromax cure chlamydia acyclovir cream during pregnancy teva olanzapine launch would taking metformin raise my potassium levels esomeprazole vs omeprazole patients gerd priligy 30 mg filmtabletten does levothyroxine affect getting pregnant tamsulosin hydrochloride long does take work valacyclovir 93 ciprofloxacina en infecciones respiratorias zoloft discontinuation syndrome symptoms arlette desogestrel misoprostol transrectal dur?e effet cialis 5mg no prescription 20 mg furosemide can gabapentin make you high can you take zantac with allegra d tom kaulitz viagra true lamisil oral walgreens tetracycline constipation sertraline cold turkey 25 taking cialis 30 days how many days till it works glucophage xr 1g ventolin capsule dosage for adults viagra pricing walmart can augmentin 625mg kill annie doxycycline and prednisone drug interactions buy cialis by plane can glucophage get you high cloridrato metformin apa guna obat metformin wife took my cialis effect of tetracycline in aborted does terbinafine 4 dollar list how do u order arabic herb viagra how long does ketoconazole take to work advantages of taking sildenafil zoloft for flying viagra version for women sta je amlodipine 05 mg of paroxetine hellp 5mg lexapro for depression how to take royal jelly with thyroxine sumycin instructions bactrim ds for mastitis how long off cymbalta for weight loss levothyroxine sodium maximum dosage metformin side effects elderly l abilify fait il grossir does prednisone affect adderall viagra price comparison uk alendronate sodium 40 mg what is difference between clomid and bromergon metformin tableti za diabet pas de contraction avec cytotec viagra price search hyzaar costo escitalopram 500g price in ofloxacino gonorrea 5mg digoxin prednisone 7 day treatment tamsulosin hip pain does nexium cause palpitations kamagra in dubai shops para que serve o comprimido propranolol tamsulosina clorhidrato 0.4 mg contraindicaciones mastrbuate while taking metronidazole doxycycline hyclate mood swings volo monaco cipro levitra oval shape allegra hicks sounds pillow cover can i take diflucan while on augmentin zyprexa high prolactin gravity can fluconazole helps in speeding delayd period phenergan 50 mg side effects viagra online uk next day where to buy cytotec in uganda viagra e no2 what happen if misoprostol is swallowed digoxin 125 motor bekas happy nexium need prednisone for my dog withough prescription levitra makes woman cual es el efecto de la pastilla cialis singulair pediatrico efectos secundarios montelukast tinnitus is tamoxifen citrate the same as nolvadex paxil and the elderly allergic reaction to valacyclovir tizanidine and paxil flomax with foley catheter why is viagra not covered by blue cross insurance flagyl 400 mg como tomar amoxil pregnancy category australia generic avapro irbesartan amvasc can cause impotence lexapro 20 mg effects buspar sleep paralysis allopurinol iron deficiency 75mg plavix stopped nizoral ovules 400mg pregnancy finasteride works great iv metronidazole dose rates for dogs uk take metformin and cause green stool lexapro 20 mg coupon ethinyl estradiol 50 gamma cialis side effects fingers spironolactone apotex what is the cost of dexamethasone injection opthalmic tapering off prednisone too quickly amoxicillin for ocd allegra allergy during pregnancy azithromycin cardiotoxicity can zofran make your nausea worse zyprexa tablett 5 mg amoxicillin prophylaxis dose side effects of intravenous acyclovir can you take lisinopril 2.5 twice daily montelukast oral drops does escitalopram mix with mother milk withdrawal symptoms from citalopram cipro hc otic vomiting does gingseng react with cipro can celexa cause ringing in ears prednisone diary clomiphene citrate 300 mg tamoxifen bez sterydow is cephalexin safe to take during pregnancy prednisone side effects muscle cramps apa kegunaan obat lipitor 0,2 mg cialis causes headaches propranolol can cause male infertility cost of cialis new zealand celebrex pregnancy side effects kamagra polska flagyl muscle pain getting off topiramate celebrex for sciatica pain claritin metoprolol interaction how much do chlamydia antibiotics cost in south africa ok to take augmentin and prilosec koenigsegg allegra ivermectina caracas acyclovir for pregnant women atenolol 25 mg stopping side effects discontinuing amlodipine how to dose wellbutrin hot flashes lisinopril can you drink alcohol while taking fluconazole 150 mg ondansetron 4 mg domperidone terbinafine hcl 1 esomeprazole side effect how does buspar make you feel cabergoline for pets acyclovir zovirax 800mg tabs prednisone for dogs with cancer accutane dosage 80 mg doxycycline 100mg asthma what is price of nolvadex for cancer in india flagyl oral 25 mg during pregnancy can you build tolerance to cialis amitriptyline bertibarots for sale clomid 50 mg bula polo size kamagra sildenafil uk boots doxycycline tablet classification dosis misoprostol flagyl for babies no xplode vs viagra is out of date cialis site ebaycouk kamagra viagra sildenafil diet pill thay is made with welbutrinxl150mg nortriptyline causes acne

Couples Ask: What’s Wrong With In-vitro Fertilization?

Catholic teaching has called in-vitro fertilization techniques immoral for decades. But most Catholics still haven’t heard the news.
by Tim Drake | Source:
SACRAMENTO, Calif. — Catholic teaching has called in-vitro fertilization techniques immoral for decades. But most Catholics still haven’t heard the news.

California attorneys Anthony and Stephanie Epolite found out the hard way that in-vitro fertilization wasn’t all it’s cracked up to be. After years of marriage, and facing her 39th birthday still without a baby, Stephanie turned to a fertility clinic.

Two years and $25,000 later, the couple had nothing but frustration and embarrassment to show for the time spent on in-vitro fertilization (in-vitro fertilization).

“We were emotionally, financially and spiritually spent,” Stephanie Epolite said. “The clinic did no diagnostic tests. They loaded me up with fertility medication and determined the right time for retrieval of my eggs.”

But, after the retrieval and the mixing of the eggs with Anthony’s sperm in the laboratory, still no embryo developed. “In the end, they told me I just had old eggs,” Stephanie said.

She wishes she had known at the beginning what she has since learned: The Catholic Church forbids fertility techniques that try to make babies outside of marital intercourse. “There is no education out there about the alternatives,” she said, “so Catholics are flocking to the fertility clinics.”

According to the American Society for Reproductive Medicine, infertility affects more than 6 million American women and their spouses, or about 10% of the reproductive-age population. About 5% of infertile couples use in-vitro fertilization.

As to how many Catholic couples are among them, figures are hard to come by. But many Catholics seem unaware of the immorality of the procedure.

“Anecdotally, from our consultation experience here, Catholics using reproductive technologies are generally unaware of the Church’s moral teaching in this area,” said Dr. Peter Cataldo, director of research with the Boston-based National Catholic Bioethics Center. “They’re not hearing it from the pulpit or elsewhere.”

In her teaching on human reproduction, the Church seeks to safeguard human dignity. God wants life “to be the result of an act of love by those committed to loving each other,” philosophy professor Janet Smith has written. Anything that assists the conjugal act achieve its purpose of procreation is licit; anything that substitutes for it is not.

In No. 2377, the Catechism explains why the Church opposes methods that separate marital love-making from baby-making.

“They dissociate the sexual act from the procreative act. The act which brings the child into existence is no longer an act by which two persons give themselves to one another, but one that entrusts the life and identity of the embryo into the power of doctors and biologists and establishes the domination of technology over the origin and destiny of the human person. Such a relationship of domination is in itself contrary to the dignity and equality that must be common to parents and children. Under the moral aspect procreation is deprived of its proper perfection when it is not willed as the fruit of the conjugal act, that is to say, of the specific act of the spouses’ union.”

In successful in-vitro fertilization, a human life comes into existence outside the conjugal act and outside the womb. Conception is the result of a technician’s manipulation of “reproductive materials.” The process for the collection of sperm often necessitates masturbation, which is itself immoral.

Father Tadeusz Pacholczyk, director of education at the National Catholic Bioethics Center in Philadelphia, explained that the Church teaches that the procedure is immoral for several reasons. “It undermines the meaning of sex. It violates the exclusivity of the couple’s marriage covenant,” Father Pacholczyk said. “It says that it is okay to manufacture life in a laboratory as if it were a commodity, when it should be the result of human love.”

“There’s also the ancillary evil of freezing embryonic humans that are later abandoned or poured down the sink if they are not useful,” he added.

In addition, Father Pacholczyk noted that babies created through in-vitro fertilization have an elevated risk of birth defects.

“Studies have shown a sixfold elevated risk for in-vitro fertilization children contracting an eye disease called retinal blastoma versus normally conceived babies,” he said. “In-vitro fertilization is very unnatural. You’re extracting ova from the woman, culturing them and inspecting the developing embryo in a laboratory setting. They are in a completely unnatural environment for a very long time before they are put back into the womb.

“Commercial interests offer in-vitro fertilization as standard practice,” Father Pacholczyk said. “The Catholic Church is the only voice opposed to it.”

But there are morally acceptable alternatives to in-vitro fertilization, and Dr. Thomas Hilgers is trying to let more Catholic couples know that.

In response to Humanae Vitae, Pope Paul VI’s 1968 encyclical reaffirming the Church’s opposition to contraception, Hilgers devoted his life to the study of human reproduction, developing the Creighton Model System of Natural Family Planning and eventually opening the Pope Paul VI Institute for the Study of Human Reproduction.

In 1991, Hilgers coined the term NaProTechnology (Natural Procreative Technology), a reproductive and gynecologic medical science that seeks to evaluate and treat a host of women’s health problems without the use of contraception, sterilization, abortion or artificial reproductive technologies, thereby making it consistent with Church teachings.

NaProTechnology first identifies the causes of infertility and then seeks to treat them. That’s not always the case at fertility clinics.

“The aim of most fertility clinics is to skip over the abnormality to try to get women pregnant,” Hilgers said. “Yet when you skip over the causes, you end up dealing with them one way or another.

“It’s ludicrous to promote in-vitro fertilization as the help for the vast majority of 6.62 million with impaired fertility,” he said. “When you listen to the national news and morning television shows, you think that in-vitro fertilization is the only thing available to infertile couples, yet less than 0.5% of infertile couples in the U.S. are helped by in-vitro fertilization each year.”

Catholic theologians and ethicists would agree that NaProTechnology is morally acceptable, Cataldo said.

Cataldo pointed out that “certain drug therapies and egg-stimulating medications at doses that don’t have disproportionate risks for the children engendered or for the mother” also are acceptable. But other technologies, such as intrauterine insemination (IUI) and gamete intrafallopian transfer (GIFT) fall into a “gray area.”

“Some moral theologians and ethicists see these techniques as assisting the conjugal act. Others see it as replacing it,” he said. “Until such time as the Vatican speaks, Catholics contemplating the use of IUI or GIFT should inform themselves of both sides of the moral and theological argument and then make a decision in good conscience.”

Regardless of the artificial method chosen, the cost of such techniques remains high and the success rates low. According to the 2001 Assisted Reproductive Technology Success Rates report compiled by the U.S. Department of Health and Human Services, a survey of 384 fertility clinics showed a clinical pregnancy success rate of 32%.

In a 1990 article published in Social Justice Review, then-associate director of the U.S. Catholic bishops’ Pro-Life Secretariat Richard Doerflinger noted that a survey of in-vitro fertilization clinics discovered that half of the clinics had never had a live birth after being in business at least three years, collectively treating more than 600 women and collecting $2.5 million for their services.

“Those with the extraordinary emotions that engulf infertile couples are extremely vulnerable,” Hilgers said. “They are easy prey.”

Not only do natural and morally acceptable alternatives such as NaProTechnology cost far less, but they also are more successful. The Pope Paul VI Institute boasts success rates ranging from 38% to 80%, depending upon the condition being treated.

Following the Epolites’ experience with in-vitro fertilization, Stephanie learned about the Pope Paul VI Institute from a Natural Family Planning counselor. In the fall of 2000, the couple applied to the institute, gathered charts they had kept that outlined vital signs related to fertility, and underwent diagnostic testing.

As it turned out, both had reproductive issues that their previous fertility clinic had never diagnosed. Anthony’s sperm count was low, and Stephanie suffered from endometriosis and blocked fallopian tubes.

Six months later, following treatment of their conditions at the Pope Paul VI Institute and at the age of 42, Stephanie conceived naturally. Their daughter, Claire Marie, was born Oct. 31, 2002.

“At the Pope Paul VI Institute, we saw compassion, concern, help and love,” Stephanie said. “They provided individualized treatment, versus the empty feeling that we felt from the fertility clinic. Whereas the fertility clinic bypasses all the laws of nature, the Pope Paul VI Institute works with the laws of nature.”

Tim Drake writes from St Cloud, Minnesota.

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular