ca i take paracetamol while taking meloxicam 15 mg venta de cialis en usa can zoloft cause leg pain and weakness how much.does one tablet of fluconazole 150mg cost does accutane cure rosacea ampicillin side effects side effects of metformin hcl euform retard efter kur clomid does buspirone do brain propecia 4 free amitriptyline tunisie nifedipine embarazo cipro and herpes virus 1 loratadine or fexofenadine better for heart viagra for 21 sildenafil uk price association plavix et aspirine metformin hcl actavis 500 mg fluconazole 150 mg while 37 weeks pregnant order viagra from canada teva quetiapine xr 150 mg effet secondaire zithromax compresse posologia men viagra in hindi diflucan oral thrush dosage what happens if you take 2 levitra does amoxicillin 250 mg help.with pain in ear in kids levitra vs viagra uk does azithromycin have gluten in it atomoxetine cost walmart hair growth with proscar clomiphene 150mg effect of doxycycline on birth control acyclovir pfizer which brand of generic singulair works amitriptyline 50mg with promethazine dm cough syrup ambien spironolactone celecoxib 200mg la thuoc gi precio del aciclovir bactrim for cellulitis en espanol raloxifene for sale uk starting clomid with spotting topamax causing itching septra for dog uti where can i buy cytotec in japan prozac mg does comes super viagra shop allegra odontologia tatuape prednisone dosage for 60 lb dog with allergies does bluecross cover cialis can i use albuterol without a nebulizer cymbalta generic name duloxetine hydrochloride zoloft versus wellbutrin sr can a man take too much viagra viagra online sales does doxycycline cure chlamydia zestril sales azithromycin gastric motility i am on benicar 40mg and hctz 12.5 misoprostol precio en tacna comprar misoprostol argentina bactrim purchase no prescription famvir romania pret diflucan and conception when did you ovulate while on clomid sertraline side effects nausea amoxil 45 levofloxacine and sperm pdf allergic reaction to doxycycline hyclate 100 hydroxyzine hcl 25 mg dias de efectos propranolol a concor fluconazole 200 mg price name of albuterol from mexico does doxycycline work with food flovent ventolin when to use irbesartan patent australia bayou viagra norvasc tablets for cats use of lasix 40 mg for dogs liquid famciclovir acyclovir equivalent cost of propecia at walgreens singulair us sales can i have 1 drink with terbinafine nursing implications for buspar liquid thyroxine ingredients prednisone 10mg for 9 days avodart and xatral birth defects indapamide bcs classification misoprostol bertibarots reviews group g strep cipro zithromax chlamydia over counter lisinopril hctz advil neruda gabapentin 300 mg galpharm ketoconazole shampoo how much sildenafil should you take plavix for des stent is it ok to stop taking metronidazole in pets azithromycin 500 mg price philippines cost of bactrim at walgreens is it okay to take prednisone and cialis phentrimine diet pills substitution for acyclovir cream difference of proscar and flomax street use for clonidine hcl accutane side effects first month can you use monistat with fluconazole oral le viagra est il vendu sans ordonnance metformin alcohol liver does cialis increase sperm counts azithromycin 1g 250 mg treat levitra scaduto effetti lisinopril 2.5 mg used generic seroquel us double dose metoprolol accidentally should i worry does lexapro affect the central nervous system bactrim ds chemotherapy seroquel xr dosage for ocd vyvanse lexapro interaction comprar xenical online no brasil can i take amitriptyline and fluoxetine zovirax en tabletas seroquel prolongado levaquin from nigeria benefits of quitting diovan feline amoxicillin side effects phenergan for 2 year old cheapest brand name viagra cytotec et ivg par aspiration allegra open day 790 imipramine uk can i crush amoxil and put it on my acne bloated stomach clomid buy accutane in canada online how long can a cat stay on mirtazapine bactrim in the treatment of mrsa rizatriptan caffeine luxury hotel rome viagra sales online metronidazole furazolidone tablets and treatment zyprexa zydis 10mg pre lamisil erytheme fessier how much is doxycycline 100 mg in south africa cialis over the counter dubai methotrexate misoprostol mtx abortion how long do i have to wait to take another cialis 20 mg generic cardizem otc fluconazole brand tablet can you get high off of mobic how much paroxetine will kill you amoxicillin and pain in stomach levofloxacin for prostatitis difference between rulide and augmentin dermatologist against accutane generic levaquin levofloxacin uso celecoxib odontologia azithromycin tablets i.p 500 mg suitable for dry cough metoprolol ficha tecnica meteo cipro a novembre revatio galinos plavix tab 75 mg clopidogrel karvea interaction with voltaren problems kamagra fast farm checkout page . com viagra is flagyl compatable with d5ns metoprolol lage hartslag antidepressants body adjusted esomeprazole cas no erythromycin buy online uk gen ciprofloxacin 500 escitalopram oxalat wiki atenolol causa fadiga metronidazole 2g single dose how long for fluconazole to work uk sildenafil presentaciones ciprofloxacin typhoid fever purchase doxycycline online clomid 50 mg 30 tablet price shopper drug mart steroid burst prescription lamisil tablets no perscription propranolol tablets for anxiety ciprodar orange juice ketoconazole blocks dht doxycycline nom commercial usa can i take oxycodone with prednisone glimipiridemetformin brands in pakistan flu shot and plavix does prometrium shrink fibroids montair 10 montelukast brands bd how much cialis in mercury drug store baclofen 10 mg side effects priligy halbwertszeit priligy cena apteka zithromax for sale cheap nexium 40 mg 5 pill price will amoxicillin help rheumatoid arthritis viagra 60 mg lamisil at vs lotrimin af for jock itch fluconazole working for std buy propecia online cheap pharmacy si tengo un mes de embarazo puedo tomar cytotec does bupropion help from eating sweets paxil deadly azithromycin extravasation treatment can dogs have fluconazole can amoxicillin cause stomach pain in babies metoprolol succinate recommended dosage what if you drink while on flagyl clomid 3 follicles twins farmacia del doctor simi viagra nitroglycerin ointment over the counter australia orslim and glucophage for pcos dysphagia antidepressants citalopram buy amoxicillin 500 mg online cialis cheapest price of it progesterone symptoms on clomid sertraline 37.5 ranitidine hydrobromide what happen when you withdraw of metformin how can u tell terbinafine is working cabergoline online uk synthroid australia generic metformin er sildenafil red 100 how to use tamil effect of cialis on psa what is a normal dose of synthroid in a dog what would happen if i use lamisil cream in my scalp compra de viagra online cialis moment definition oxytetracycline use in humans cd3 estradiol low itching on celexa and lexapro lisinopril hydrochlorothiazide parameters hair loss forum nizoral tamoxifen renal function herbal equivalent to nexium cut glucophage in half metformin denk 850 side effects nizoral 200 mg used dostinex 1gr benazepril thins blood para que sirve medicamento ciprofloxacino apakah viagra di jual di apotik side effects of digoxin and coming off it zithromax dergboadre online is metformin safe in breastfeeding celebrex coeur bula de medicamentos nizoral feeling anxious and tired on escitalopram zoloft anxiety reviews howany hours apart to take cipro does augmentin cure staph infection generic seroquel cost 20 mg paxil eyaculacion precoz viagra prescription under nhs irbesartan 150 mg precio costa rica how to use misoprostol 200 mg synthroid 125 mcg price wellbutrin sustained release dosages singulair rage wellbutrin dr bob augmentin duo interactions axepta atomoxetine hydrochloride how fast should ciprofloxacin work abilify low dose depression naproxen costco allopurinol liver problems metformin xr manufacturer buy lamisil tablets high level of thyroxine how long does levitra stay in you body system cymbalta e pillola anticoncezionale amitriptyline for chronic pain taking valtrex drinking while trying to conceive fluoxetine 20 mg andskin general practicioner prescribe viagra is viagra available in sri lanka tamoxifeno asta zeneca meloxicam 15 mg tab teva cardura xl yan etkileri more trenors with lexapro or prozac is levofloxacin and ornidazole tablet safe in pregnancy tamsulosina anestesia acidity constants of the tetracycline antibiotics puedo diluir cytotec en un poco de agua para tomarla accutane mccarrell how long does it take to ajust go 80mg of strattera flomax mp more chance ovulating on 100mg clomid purchase viagra usa voltaren supozitoare 12.5 baclofen tablets uk fluconazole tablet dosage for foot fungus ventolin delivery system amitriptyline used as pain relief generic viagra cost at cvs atarax tapasztalatok purchase furosemide uk gabapentin and alcohol interaction ilosone t?pico solu??o como usar venda de misoprostol em natal neurontin high effect cistite ciproxin candida viagra for mann xenical prix en parapharmacie albuterol growth retardation dosis de cytotec para abortar 22 semanas sildenafil falom wellbutrin sr side effects in men what is the nexium commercial drug interaction warning drowsiness metronidazole side effects india levitra 20 mg tablet levitra es mas potente what is difference between prevacid and nexium telmisartan product monograph pdf premarin 2 5 side effects of carvedilol with hyerperthyriod nebulizer treatment albuterol 4 month old erythromycin tablets 500mg box price in pak buspirone and sertraline together costo flagyl ovuli se puede mezclar el sildenafil con alcohol meloxicam 7 5mg para que sirve can i buy ciprofloxin ear drops uk taking clomid with folic acid mecanismo accion clopidogrel fluconazole mg buy indomethacin capsules fluconazole can you take it with probiotic 10 levitra generic 40 mg le viagra en algerie what strength viagra side effects of seroquel sr diflucan 5 days can augmentin work where cefdinir failed how many times should take viagra is strattera sold in egypt how to buy baclofen in canada propranolol tapering half life hydrochlorothiazide 12.5mg capsules side effects amoxil 850 bula singulair 10 mg pret can flagyl be used for dogs avodart medscape estradiol level 6000 dog on plavix and prednisone for heart celexa discontinuation period what is the standard dose of lisinopril naproxen 200 mg zofran for dogs dosage cuantas pastillas cytotec se usan google duloxetine 60 mg twice a day buspirone 30 mg is it harmful duloxetine hcl dr caps 60mg inj.nitroglycerin prize dutasteride every other day viagra in frankreich rezeptfrei kaufen over the counter daily cialis finasteride 93 when will new plavix generic be available aciclovir creme kaufen cialis tablets used can metronidazole lighten my period does accutane cause headaches can ringworm be treated with metronidazole zyvox used treat mrsa doxycycline hyclate 500mg cap nexium y clopidogrel clomid testosterone basso buspar 5 mg amoxicillin 1000 mg twice a day

Teach Evolution and Ask Hard Questions

When the battle over the teaching of evolution erupted in Kansas, the New York Times picked Michael Behe, a Catholic, and a scientist critical of Darwinism, to comment on it. In this article, Behe offers an alternative approach to the problem.
by Michael J. Behe | Source:
The debate leading the Kansas Board of Education to abolish the requirement for teaching evolution has about the same connection to reality as the play "Inherit the Wind" had to the actual Scopes trial. In both cases complex historical, scientific and philosophical issues gave way to the simplifying demands of the morality play. If the schoolchildren of Kansas and other states are to receive a good science education, however, then we´ll have to forgo the fun of demonizing each other, take a deep breath and start making a few distinctions.

Regrettably, the action of the Kansas board makes that much more difficult. Not only are teachers there now discouraged from discussing evidence in support of Darwin´s theory, results questioning it won´t be heard either.

For example, let´s look at three claims of evidence for Darwinian evolution often cited by high school textbooks. First, as the use of antibiotics has become common, mutant strains of resistant bacteria have become more common, threatening public health. Second, darkcolored variants of a certain moth species evaded predation by birds because their color matched the sooty tree trunks of industrial England. Third, the embryos of fish, amphibians, birds and mammals look virtually identical in an early stage of development, becoming different only at later stages.

A relevant distinction, however, is that only the first example is true. The second example is unsupported by current evidence, while the third is downright false. Although light and darkcolored moths did vary in expected ways in some regions of England, elsewhere they didn´t. Further, textbook photographs showing moths resting on tree trunks in the day, where birds supposedly ate them, run afoul of the fact that the moths are active at night and don´t normally rest on tree trunks. After learning about the problems with this favorite Darwinian example, an evolutionary scientist wrote in the journal Nature that he felt the way he did as a boy when he learned there was no Santa Claus.

The story of the embryos is an object lesson in seeing what you want to see. Sketches of vertebrate embryos were first made in the late 19th century by Ernst Haeckel, an admirer of Darwin. In the intervening years, apparently nobody verified the accuracy of Haeckel´s drawings. Prominent scientists declared in textbooks that the theory of evolution predicted, explained and was supported by the striking similarity of vertebrate embryos. And that is what generations of American students have learned.

Recently, however, an international team of scientists decided to check the drawings´ reliability. They found that Haeckel had, well, taken liberties: the embryos are significantly different from each other. In Nature, the head of the research team observed that "it looks like it´s turning out to be one of the most famous fakes in biology." What´s more, the embryonic stages shown in the drawings are actually not the earliest ones. The earliest stages show much greater variation.

If I were teaching a high school biology course, I certainly would want my students to understand Darwin´s theory of evolution by natural selection, which explains antibiotic resistance and a lot of other things. I would want them to know the many similarities among organisms that are interpreted in terms of common descent, as well as to understand the laboratory experiments that show organisms changing in response to selective pressure.

But I would also want them to learn to make distinctions and ask tough questions. Questions we might discuss include these:

If it´s so difficult to demonstrate that small changes in modern moths are the result of natural selection, how confident can we be that Darwinian selection drove large changes in the distant past? If supposedly identical embryos were touted as strong evidence for evolution, does the recent demonstration of variation in embryos now count as evidence against evolution? If some scientists relied for a century on an old, mistaken piece of data because they thought it supported the accepted theory, is it possible they might even now give short shrift to legitimate contrary data or interpretations?

Discussing questions like these would help students see that sometimes a theory actively shapes the way we think, and also that there are still exciting, unanswered questions in biology that may require fresh ideas.

It´s a shame that Kansas students won´t get to take part in such a discussion. We should make sure that the students of other states do.

Emotions run very deep on the subject of evolution, and while the morality play generally casts religious people as the ones who want to limit discussion, some scientists on the "rational" side could fit that role, too. But if we want our children to become educated citizens, we have to broaden discussion, not limit it.

Teach Darwin´s elegant theory. But also discuss where it has real problems accounting for the data, where data are severely limited, where scientists might be engaged in wishful thinking and where alternative even "heretical" explanations are possible.

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular