ebusiness-lab.gr wholesale kamagra uk metronidazole and oral contraceptive augmentin 375 corral88.org nexium 20mg esomeprazole finasteride online uk buy anafranil no prescription dutasteride binnen europa bestellen does the itching ic bupropion hcl xl 150 mg go away quetiapine indications australia metronidazole for pigeon prize philippines tamoxifen uk buy meccanicanova.com sildenafil nursing consideration raloxifene australia inflason prednisone can metronidazole use in treatment of endometriosis lisinopril coughchemistry generic montelukast not working estradiol valerate 2mg tm perforated what antibiotics can be used asiliahomehealth.com how much is clomid in mercury drug what is used syrup augmentin 625 mg for prednisone 5mg not working for pinched neck nerve cat costa o cutie de augmentin 650 can i crush azithromycin and mix it in a drink metformin philippines xn--b1afpdqbb8d.xn--p1ai amoxicillin how much water dextromethorphan hydrobromide 30 mg side effects viagra dose for 200 pound male doxycycline costco japan ran ondansetron how long to work can people taking plavix take lemon juice 15 day prednisone for poison ivy multi-monety.pl timminsfamilycounselling.com people taking 5mg of paxil during pregnancy horners.org.uk cheap viagra without rx what are quetiapine value on the street tedmitew.com can you take anti depressants with mirapex accidentally took double dose of 20mg celexa cardizem 30 mg efeitos colaterais sobrietybyyourside.com prednisone 10 mg 6 day pack side effects can you take montelukast with viagra cara penggunaan olanzapine reviews on lisinopril and hydrochlorothiazide strattera vs adderall for energy side effects of flagyl weingutkohl.de amitriptyline costochondritis propecia works in 3 months ftortho.net allegra jarrett icsliberia.org cvs amoxicillin gluten free plavix pret buspirone 15 mg reviews buy viagra com marashthermal.com ketoconazole shampoo 100ml naproxen 375 wal mart cost long term side effects of pamelor astakaryaindotama.com isoptin sr 120 a alkohol generic nizoral tablets flagyl psoriasis lisinopril 20mg enalapril 5mg which is stronger dose metronidazole 400 dosage for vaginal infection emberdomme.com micardis 80 25 price out of pocket cost for flagyl side effect of periactine medicine. amaryl price in pakistan 2exhibitions.com order cialis cheap will antibiotics 600mg kill depo pill can i take flagyl without food cytotec parral chihuahua obat tetracycline 1000 mg ca amoxil cap kill sperm austel amoxrckin antibiotic amitriptyline price increase buspirone hcl 5mg side effects terbinafine in polish language zithromax and herxheimer generic for lexapro at walmart ciprofloxacinoxr500 e o mesmo ciplofacino fr 500 ebusiness-lab.gr kegunaan amoxicillin para que serve cyproheptadine hcl where to buy viagra in vancouver bc beli tamoxifen nolvadex jakarta what is ciprotab tn lovedrop.us order ketoconazole online vodoun.org cheap cialis usa westregion.org amoxicillin clavulanate and eggs reaction dapoxetine sildenafil side effact ciprofloxacin for dry socket premarin cream buy without prescription atenolol and massage contraindications tamsulosin for females with kidney stones uk should i take 100mg of clomid so as to have twins thebestkindofdifferent.com buscomi.com gauntletpress.com teflaro antibiotic firsttimetravels.com horners.org.uk seadoo-maldives.com safe prednisone cat dosage how much phenergan gel can a 22lb baby have dunnacupuncture.com mobile-pharma.com voltaren gel generic name ondansetron 4mg tablets pregnancy mirtazapine 15 mg h.s. debtspecialistcentre.com doctors in richmond va for erectile dysfunction cialis 20mg price at walmart uspmw.com lisinopril 10 mg hydrochlorothiazide 25 mg fosamax life threatening effects viagra spray for men singulair h1n1 eude.es cipro 1000mg for 3 days torsemide 200 mg 10mg cialis daily snort clonidine high azascd.org sobrietybyyourside.com took fluconazole 2 days in a row am1320.com 40 mg of fluoxetine and cost canada does flagyl give brown discharge after treatment side effects for taking 30mg of amlodipine meloxicam tablet 15 mg obat apa how do i cut down 2.5mg zyprexa leowelcome.com micardis plus 160 does amoxicillin is crystal light liquid gluten free fluconazole dose avvsagradafamilia.net etodolac 300 mg dosage cost of 10 days of prednisone for cats nasminc.com corral88.org cost of diltiazem cd 360mg trazodone 100 4th night of topamax 25 mg no bad side effects minoxydil can be used with sampoo ketoconazole floryakurye.com.tr adderall xr prednisone levaquin vs levofloxacin dexamethasone 1 mg suppression test injecting neurontin ebusiness-lab.gr erythromycin ratiopharm 1000 mg db meccanicanova.com bladder infection after taking clomid levitra online pharmacy metformin500sr should be taken before or after meal rantical.com generic proscar pain in groin dulan duloxetine 30mg pakistan price levofloxacin ornidazole tab mode of action habitat.tj floryakurye.com.tr grandcanyonbrewery.com clomid 50g progesterone less than 1 nizoral 2 percent and hair losss valsartan remedio will 2 500mg azithromycin cure chlamydia in men is it safe to take viagra after giving blood bigdaddyssigns.com generic avapro side effects antibiotic for tooth swelling available in hong kong lowest priced cialis paxil breast cancer lawsuit taking topiramate for sunct poss side effects azithromycin sandoz 250 mz levitra online paypal buy amoxicillin hong kong g6pd and albuterol sulfate inhaler tamsulosin prices at walgreens pharmacy alternative herbal medicine to montelukast prometrium after ovulation for trying to conceive brownhousephoto.com side effects takin 40 mg lexapro plavix generico 200mg flagyl for c diff infection miconazole elavil 75 mg side effects americangovernor.com what does 40mg lisinopril look like how many days to take azithromycin how much flagyl is need for divet voltaren 25 mg crema akademia-active.pl deserteichler.com nexium hp7 contoindications and side effect cosar amoxicillin 500 warfarin 5 mg synthroid without lactose webworksandgraphics.com buy atorvastatin usa diflucan 150mg oral thrush can diflucan 200 mg treat a yeast infection vardenafil 5mg colchicine 0 6mg ireland price of viagraat walmart role of levofloxacin injection in enteric fever debattartikel.se plendil frequent urination chinaskinny.com what is ip clomid furosemide 40 mg price illinois walmart metrodinazole containing antibiotic tablet obat amoxicillin 500 untuk herpes mata where can you buy nizoral shampoo over the counter side effects spiramycine metronidazole finasteride same as propecia hydroxyzine hcl 10mg and heart arrimathia tab. lasix 8,its company,price molecule adalat 10 mg azfamilylawattorney.com thuoc neurontin singulair 4 mg granule pret is estalopram 10 mg strongerthen celexa 20 mgz do you need a prescription to buy zitromax buy tamsulosin hydrochloride clopidogrel 1200 mg webbrowsers.lv how much is clomid 50mg price in mercury drug metronidazole in jamaica how long does diovan stay in your system amoxicillin oral suspension ip dry syrup pets should a female bodybuilder take clomid at end of cycle gratisdiscotecas.com castwell-castings.com sideinfo.com.br how long does it take prednisone to work for asthma doxycycline after 6 weeks thebestkindofdifferent.com nglturf.org nexium effects on stool aatif.lu is montelukast sod 10 mg a steroid azfamilylawattorney.com periactin 2mg company name mylan 752 clonidine hcl can you take niacin and cialis together tadalafil 20mg for women order amitriptyline online levaquin side effects master cleanse after 10 days cialis 10 mg price getting high off quetiapine sandoz celebrex per tendinite gkris.com isotretinoin capsules india best company dosi letali di inderal clozaril patient registration form australia cytotec buy online usa flagyl and augmentin together heliobacter lamisil difficult swallow generic zovirax canada brand levitra benicar dr moller nizoral cream in the philippines daisylcreations.com contrave taken with paxil avodart og selen lisinopril 5mg price dosage of cytotec in 16 weeks of pregnancy albuterol sulfate infants dosage seroquel xr 25 mg for sleep dosage instruction on prednisone can i take buspirone and cyclobenzaprine same time piroxicam 10 mg obat untuk can i buy nizoral cream over the counter naproxen 7.5 tamsulosin kidney stones wordsalamode.com acyclovir 400 mg cost content-catalyst.com virtualsem.com martinus-schule-baesweiler.de nexium gas palpitations groganstudios.com brownhousephoto.com cytotec costo en farmacias buy orlistat from mexico gabapentin 300mg 5027 does medroxyprogesterone work is it ok to mix cialis with aleve everyday niwali.com sichtwandel.ch montelukast tabletas 10 mg mexico plendil 100 mg 1001.org bupropion 300 street drug flomax 350 granulado proscar price in india shepardspropertyservices.com cost of remeron without insurance webbrowsers.lv alcohol and amlodipine besylate 4kom.it augmentin treats chest infectiins how do i insert flagyl gel welbutrin better than generic bupropion alexcitypr.com mobilestoreoperators.com cytotec with myoma lisinopril 5. mg cuanto cuesta will a half a diflucan work ryman.pl amitriptyline and gabapentin used together cats sniffing trazodone or clonidine how easily can a kid overdose on phenergan gel symptoms antidepressant dose too high can predental antibiotics discolor urine augmentin x 32 gluten free escitalopram fatigue side effect 2.5 mg lexapro side effects can coreg and clonidine be taken together is zofran zydis safe in 6 week pregnancy yalovadaarsa.com cellulites treatment with levofloxacin discount viagra drug taking prednisone while on epistane childlabor-payson.org szcy5.com forgot to take my bupropion does propranolol cause bad breath latest price of augmentin injection buy metformin xr online foods to eat when taking metformin monikagawor.pl the price of dapoxetine 60 mg in bangladesh walgreens lexapro prices taking zofran for hangover bdxmen.com does cialis give you instant erection denimandlace.ca iranstrick-tiregroup.com plavix dr mercola diflucan for yeast infection inderal 320 kimlearningcenter.com monikagawor.pl albuterol 8mg tablets can you take immodium for diarrhea from cipro can augmentin 625mg used to treat typhoid walmart lexapro price how high dose cialis liquid doxycycline msds tab amaryl 1mg price metronidazole 200mg data sheet ciproxin u srbiji baern nortriptyline 10mgs. for anxiety how do you wean off lexapro moa of coumadin vs clopidogrel manfaat obat doxycycline untuk jerawat uspmw.com can augmentin 625mg cure gonorrhea cflailesi.org lisinopril hctz generic name finasteride 0.25mg lisinopril hctz 20.25 mg espanol baclofen tramadol interaction ciprofloxacin mixed with flagyl together cure the uti comprar diovan 80 mg en mexico on line zoloral ketoconazole cream transition ratio of lexapro to celexa viagra 8 difference between augmentin 625 and augmentin 625 duo bactrim compositum cycle day 13 of clomid sore nipples where is metoprolol 831 manufactured abilify to seroquel conversion cost of lexapro 20 mg dunnacupuncture.com can azithromycin give you diareeah secretlives.me happyknits.com can prednisone affect vision in dogs rizatriptan odt vs nacala mlt aliikayaks.com cardura 9 celebrex price south africa how much does acyclovir tablets cost in south africa escitalopram faz engordar thepointofcare.com vpdcorp.com micardis 80 mg martinus-schule-baesweiler.de melvilleauthor.com incation du clopidogrel pppt why do bodybuilders use evolve nolvadex 20mgs diovan hct 160 beta blocker habitat.tj doxycycline 100mg 30 tablet how much cost amoxicillin eg 1000 mg paroxetine 30 mg price priligy 30mg side effects zovirax indications for aft can i buy antibiotics for chlamydia at walmart cialis suppliers on line lovedrop.us firsttimetravels.com amlodipine 5mg uk can you take 50mg viagra 3 days in a row thebestkindofdifferent.com furosemide class action order ketoconazole online monikagawor.pl olanzapine average sleep cyproheptadine syrup appetite shoppers drug mart seenonstage.pl baclofen 200 mg help with heroin withdrawal where was celebrex add filmed chrisandradeforcongress.com tadalafil costo mexico carlosfloresmusic.com gabapentin 300 mg capsule getting high buy anafranil 25mg numero de telefono para adquirir cytotec high dose prednisone withdrawal fever menafilmfest.com amoxil 100mg can you take zoloft and percocet together can i take tylenol and maxalt twentynineinches-de.com mcmceylanmobilya.com lasix long 30 mg retardkapseln escitalopram price comparison how long do red eyes last when sulfa antibiotics kmmvin.eu how soon does bactrim work how long does it take for lamisil to leave your system prescription drugs poison ivy steroids obat cytotec 500mg sobrietybyyourside.com citalopram 20 mg vs effexor amoxicillin 500mg brand names and prices fluoxetine 60 premarin 6.25 mfg name zyvox generic date difficulty ejaculating flomax zovirax tablets uk buy cipro johannesburg offices levitra generic uk long term effects of dapoxetine coreg 6.25 and zoloft 50 mg estradiol 2mg buy levitra 10mg women v dizzy rush on sertraline nexium replacement tomar cytotec con 3 meses de cesarea viagra shipped overnight flushed face seroquel size of albuterol inhaler purchase prometrium online who makes generic amiodarone in canada zimbabwean dose for ciprofloxacillin paxil cedrina what type of antidepressant is celexa clopidogrel cost uk alexcitypr.com stendhal.com zyprexa 5 mg sublingual buy montelukast cheap addictedtoallthingspretty.com terbinafine kenya what happens if a man takes 1 premarin pill tenormin 25 discontinued nausea after taking metformincozaarand vitamin d coffee7.com difference between propanol and metoprolol voltaren 25 diclofenac sodium buy orlistat medicine flagyl over the counter walmart cardizem 420mg significado en espanol animaswellbeing.com mightyrabbitstudios.com westwoodhomesinc.com grandlakehistory.org obat nizoral untuk panu mankind prazosin topiramate drug induced lupus firsttimetravels.com

Both Species from an Extraordinary Minister

If no priest or deacon is available to distribute the Precious Blood in the circumstances where Communion under both kinds is permitted and customary, then it cannot be considered an abuse to avail of the services of an extraordinary minister of Communion
by Father Edward McNamara | Source:
Answered by Father Edward McNamara, professor of liturgy at the Regina Apostolorum Pontifical University.

Q: I am a convert to Catholicism. Little if anything was taught to me during RCIA regarding the liturgy, yet I was immediately encouraged to become a Eucharistic minister as soon as I received the sacraments. The training I received amounted to about four hours on a Saturday. When I transferred to a different parish, all I had to do was sign up to be a Eucharistic minister. There was one brief training focusing on where to stand depending on which station you were assigned. My husband, a devout cradle Catholic, tells me that it is not appropriate to receive under both species at a Mass unless there are enough priests or deacons to administer both the Body and the Blood. He sees the use of Eucharistic ministers to distribute both species as an abuse. Is it wrong to partake of both species if both are offered, albeit by Eucharistic ministers? – R. E., Glendale, Arizona

A: While the preparation required before appointing someone as an extraordinary minister of holy Communion may vary from place to place, the norms issued by the diocesan bishop (see Redemptionis Sacramentum, No. 160) should always be followed.

Most bishops delegate the rite of appointment to parish priests, although some dioceses organize special courses for those called to serve in this capacity.

The 1973 instruction Immensae Caritatis, No. 6, outlines some of the personal qualities demanded of the extraordinary minister:

“The person who has been appointed to be an extraordinary minister of Holy Communion is necessarily to be duly instructed and should distinguish himself by his Christian life, faith and morals. Let him strive to be worthy of this great office; let him cultivate devotion to the Holy Eucharist and show himself as an example to the other faithful by his piety and reverence for this most holy Sacrament of the altar. Let no one be chosen whose selection may cause scandal among the faithful.”

It is thus clear that due care must be taken in selecting and forming the extraordinary ministers, presuming of course that they respond to an authentic need, because of the delicate and sacred character of the office that they are called to fulfill.

Before appointing them, the priest should have a sufficient knowledge of their moral stature and their standing in the community.

He should also ensure that they fully adhere to all of the teachings of the Church especially those regarding the belief in the real presence of Christ in the Eucharist and the Catholic understanding of the holy sacrifice of the Mass.

They should be trained not only regarding where to stand but also with regard to proper procedures to follow when approaching the altar to receive the sacred vessels from the priest; how to return them; how to avoid accidents; and how to proceed if accidents occur. They should also be instructed on the limits of their office with respect to purifying the sacred vessels and approaching the tabernacle.

Those who officiate to the sick will need supplementary instructions regarding the proper rites to be followed.

I would recommend that, in order to appreciate the importance of their service, extraordinary ministers of the Eucharist be encouraged to foment their love for the Eucharist through adoration or frequent visits to the tabernacle.

They should also have at least one retreat a year as well as other instructions in Catholic doctrine and the norms and spirit of the liturgy.

This brings us to the second part of your question.

If no priest or deacon is available to distribute the Precious Blood in the circumstances where Communion under both kinds is permitted and customary, then it cannot be considered an abuse to avail of the services of an extraordinary minister of Communion.

You write from the United States, where the distribution of Communion under both kinds at Sunday Mass has been approved by the bishops and validated by the Holy See. When needed, an extraordinary minister of Communion may assist the priest and deacon with the administration of the Precious Blood from the chalice.

There is no reason to refuse the chalice if offered in this way, although there is no obligation to do so.

While receiving Communion under both species is more perfect from the point of view of the sign, it is important to remember the Church’s teachings that Christ is received whole and entire under either species.

Thus, one’s Communion is perfectly complete when it is received under the species of bread alone. One is not deprived of extra graces by not receiving from the chalice.

While your husband is obviously a good Catholic with a sincere love for the Eucharist, his ideas in this area do not correspond to the reality of liturgical norms.

Follow-up: Why “For All” at Consecration?

There was quite a reaction from several quarters regarding the column on the question of translating the “pro multis” as “for all.” Some readers even sent in tracts arguing that this change of translation made the consecration invalid.

In some cases it was clear that the readers had read the article with excessive haste and attributed to my pen what was in fact a translation from an official source of the Holy See. In one case it was an official response to a doubt and in the second an article by the theologian M. Zerwick which cannot be considered official as such but which received the approval of the Holy See and was published at its request.

I certainly do not possess the theological and exegetical capabilities shown by Zerwick in his brief but dense article.

A reader from England stated that the article basically accused 2,000 years of popes, saints and theologians of being wrong in their interpretation of the “pro multis.”

Rereading the article I cannot see how this can be true. The article does not create an opposition between the past and the present; it accuses nobody of ever having being wrong.

The thrust of the article’s argument was that the expression used by Jesus, which literally means “the many,” did not exclude, and probably included, the connotation that he died for all.

The argument also recognizes, and indeed could not do otherwise, that “for all” is not a correct literal translation for “pro multis.” It does sustain, however, that it is a correct translation from a theological standpoint and does not substantially change the meaning of the consecration.

The article also defends the position of all those, including some saints and popes, who distinguished between the Lord’s sacrifice being sufficient for the salvation of all, while being efficacious only for many and especially those who cooperate with grace at Mass.

This is a valid and true distinction that is not challenged by the translation because it is true as such even though the doctrine can no longer call upon the text of the consecration in English, Spanish or Italian, as supporting evidence.

Indeed, this doctrine would still have been true even if, hypothetically, the Latin text had said “pro omnibus” instead of “pro multis.” It does not stand or fall on this point.

Zerwick’s article thus did no more than reaffirm and elaborate what the Holy See had explicitly and officially stated in its brief earlier reply.

Regarding the accusation that this change could render the consecration invalid, I cannot analyze here all of the arguments offered. But to say the least I remain unconvinced.

St. Thomas Aquinas in the Summa (III pars q. 78 art. 3) teaches that the complete consecration formula, and not just “This is the cup of my blood,” forms part of the substance of the sacramental form. This opinion is generally accepted in Church documents.

Therefore a change which would alter the essential meaning of the formula would render the consecration invalid.

This is where it appears to me that some of the objectors tend to beg the question, for they assume that the translating of “pro multis” as “for all” constitutes such an essential change. But this is exactly the point to prove.

If the expression “pro multis” were essential to the consecration, then this formula would necessarily be found universally in the consecration rites of all ancient Eucharistic Prayer texts. And indeed the vast majority of them do use “pro multis.”

However, the oldest known Eucharistic Prayer of all, the Apostolic Tradition of St. Hippolytus of Rome (circa A.D. 225), uses the following formula: “This is my blood, which is shed for you. As often as you do this, do it in memory of me.”

Since this formula has been used continually in some Eastern and African Churches for almost 1,800 years, it is difficult to sustain that “pro multis” is absolutely essential even though in some cases the “pro multis” has been added to this prayer at a later date along with other modifications.

Finally, since the Holy See has taken a clear and official position on the non-erroneous nature of this translation, the only logical conclusion — unless we consider ourselves wiser than the Church — is to accept that the change does not constitute a substantial or essential modification of the formula and that to effect such an adaptation falls within the Church’s power over the sacraments.

Theological arguments aside, we can be sure that God would never allow the Church to err on a point so essential as the valid consecration of the Eucharist. From the moment that these translations have been approved by the Church, there can be no doubts whatsoever as to their validity.

One may discuss their opportunity, literary correctness, etc., but not their validity.

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows Catholic.net to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to Catholic.net right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular