generic benicar at wal mart cara minum cytotec 500mcg tips for taking cialis does cipro cover impetigo where can i buy misoprostol pills in kenya generic topiramate manufacturers neurontin adderall chest pains how will prednisone 6 day pack do for me cozaar uk esomeprazole vs omeprazole studies cytotec 500 miligramas norvasc 10 mg for sale provera 30 mg daily cymbalta online no prescription price for atorvastatin calcium tablets 20mg voltaren gel el precio buy generic plavix 75 mg famvir 1 how many montelukast do you take for a high bactrim for blood poisoning metronidazole long lasting diarrhea cytotec 300 mg buy maxalt rpd information compra en san juan misoprostol cymbalta day 8 amoxicillin dosage english precio cytotec farmacias del ahorro kalmethasone dexamethasone definition buy nizoral shampoo 7 oz irritability zoloft withdrawal cab u take acyclovir for urinary tract infectiin stop remeron after 3 weeks debrox 200 mg celecoxib dosis can you snortbuspirone pasta cytotec para 18 semanas antibiotic metronidazole for cats with liver shunt azithromycin for chlamydia for sale brand levitra uk flagyl time to work muscle strain and prednisone how long do albuterol side effects last provera tablets price in the philippines levitra buy online canada effects of garlic on ciprofloxacin can antidepressants cause dermatitis does plavix have sulfer in it ketoconazole 2 cream uses metformin from horse urine can you take clomid for more than 6 months buying lexapro amoxicillin for tulo amitriptyline 10mg overdose cims azithromycin how to use dapoxetine hydrochloride donde.conseguir.misoprostol yucatan stopping lisinopril abruptly cause nosebleeds price of celebrex200 in south africa cozaar 50 mg tablet price remeron 15mg. versus 30 mg. lasix push via po dolo voltaren 46.5 how to use liquid sildenafil how long will lexapro increase anxiety walgreens terbinafine cream purchase viagra discount 50mg clomid for men safe efek samping diflucan can azithromycin be bought ocer thr coubter kamagra online bestellen 800mg gabapentin street value zoralin ketoconazole 200 mg untuk apa linezolid oral kaufen valtrex 1 gm cold slfe how long does viagra keep you hard hydroxyzine skotki uboczne uzaleznia neurontin and omneprozole maksimal dosis obat acyclovir varicella difference between crestor and atorvastatin calcium price of ciprobay 500 mercury sustituto natural del tadalafilo para que sirve la cytotec en costa rica orlistat capsules 120mg benefits acyclovir 5 mirtazapine street value propranolol 40 mg costo metformin ic50 when does fluconazole 200 mg start to work can singulair be used to make meth propecia results 2 years hydrochlorothiazide otc alternatives viagra 25mg price in india dexamethasone 2mg tablets side effects cipro 1000 mg dose fluconazole 150 mg tab ivax pharm generic alendronate package insert how to order diltiazem ointment online stopping accutane after 5 months can a female use kamagra oral jelly what is the work of bactrim forte how long does zyprexa tiredness last does metformin interact with fenofibrate atarax caducado azithromycin 250 mg price cvs zithromax iv for gonorrhea how much gabapentine to kill me temoignage strattera what auxiliary labels would you put on metronidazole will doxycycline help otitis externa 2.5 mg of celexa cialis online pharmacy prescription viagra in west bengal available viagra tablets makes dick big que cuesta cyproheptadine to much celexa symptoms buy furosemide 40 mg cymbalta price canada what will 450 mg of trazodone do to you cipro xr 1rm nose bleed after taking cialis viagra 8000mg review can you purchase viagra in mexico chloromycetin suspension fluconazole 150mg dosage doxycycline hyclate after expiration date tinea corporis nizoral review tizanidine tab baclofen vs soma street value ketoconazole 2 cream for sale at 6 months pregnant can i have an albuterol treatment linezolid antibiotic price in india kesan sampingan glucophage 850mg what is similar to lamisil 250mg over the counter will gabapentin help with tooth pain no prescription cialis overnight flagyl for diareha in dog not working cheap ivermectin cipro company registration alternatives to phenergan for babies taking flomax with grapefruit biotech ciprofloxacin 500 how to use celexa for anxiety acyclovir not working anymore can elevated alkaline phosphatase be due to levaquin generic viagra 24 hours viagra for sale for women in the uk where to buy propecia malaysia gabapentin effects on testosterone did clomid make you feel thirsty at 8dpo walmart levitra 20mg price wellbutrin weight loss purple pill dosage chart images benzoylmetronidazole in hindi soma and topiramate taken together amoxicillina e acido clavulanico indication francais chia seeds substitute plavix off brand propecia how much do naproxen street value clomiphene for 21 days cymbalta 60 mg price costco cialis how does it affect blood pressure can finasteride drugs cause tooth gum swell can you take a gravol while taking an antibiotic plavix drug card amoxil 1gr makedonska apoteka cialis telmisartan brands in bd augmentin 125 dawkowanie clopidogrel kairos cialis prices at asda msds of bupropion hydrobromide how to maintain erection after coming revista 15 minutos laura acu?±a generic lexapro alternative psychosis singulair isoptin press anger when withdrawing from celexa uses for the antibiotic flagyl captopril 6.25 infarmed thuoc indocin 25 cortana can you buy viagra over the counter cymbalta versus paxil can i take painkillers with gabapentin clonazepam quetiapine length of side effects of zoloft paanu gamitin ang cytotec what is mylan quetiapine 200mg can diflucan cream be taken during first trimester generico de lamisil. en mexico precio es amitriptyline and gabapentin used together cats phenergan dm price shelf life propranolol tablets can you take buspirone with pain killers bupropion xl no prescription siete semanas q dosis necesito de misoprostol lasix bladder infection side effect gabapentin appetite suppressant what is metronidazole 100 mg pills side effects in cats amoxicillin 500 mg dosage for urinary tract infection topiramate in creams tab flagyl 400mg uses ad composition finasteride resultados a los 9 meses wellbutrin with lexapro jitters is sulfa an ingredient in apo baclofen 10 mg prednisone and ammonia after taste viagra gold 800mg reviews SUNNYDUVET.COM cialis order online prescription mobic 7.5 bid prednisone dosage for poisen ivy what is the dose of augmentine 1gm in sinusitis bv antibiotics and morning after pill augmentin prospect bis supradoza cabergoline 0.5 mg uk first dose of fluconazole doesnt work amoxil dosage for uti neurontin mg dose of injectable prednisone for poison oak for humans cialis price in australia celecoxib y simvastatina mecanismo de accion cymbalta lexapro paxil together otic antibiotics without alcohol can i drink alcohol while taking prednisone levaquin online overnight weaning off gabapentin metformina hcl 150 mg hydroxyzine 25 mg for dogs buy propecia online to australia can overdose of mylan quetiapine kill a person can i take cialis with advil i take clomid and have 6eggs celecoxib availability how long can i use diflucan cream when pregnant 30mg remeron and abilify propranolol test anxiety clomiphene citrate mode of action in urdu does cyproheptadine get you high avapro plus metoprolol combination amoxicillin diagram plavix cost per month how long does it take provera 10mg to induce period micardis duo existe en generico weight gain or loss on zoloft and wellbuturin ubat kurus xenical depo provera every 3 months flomaxtra molecule azithromycin 7 days can you take fluconazole with amoxicillin zofran 4 mg 8 mg tablet adult effects of stopping avapro 75mg tamsulosin side pelvic floor diovan accidental ingestion zyprexa relprevv dosage how long does side effects from lexapro ast where can i buy ivermectin pills does valtrex shorten the length of an outbreak strength of doxycycline flagyl while on my period does ketoconazole cures sinus infection pet store amoxicillin vs prescription amoxicillin dienogest 2 mg ethinyl estradiol 0.03 mg picking skin side effect strattera do hair transplants require you to take propecia is it ok to mix doxycycline hyclate with vyvanse premarin 1.25 viagra online best price cara pemberuan cordarone ciprofloxacn 250 mg tab wes levothyroxine uptake and side effects if not sufficient cost of generic combination of flomax and avodart can i take clomid first thing in the morning lipitor dari farmasi mana did you lose weight on wellbutrin xl zoloft penicillin anxiety escitalopram for nervous breakdown fluconazole can be taken by g6pd deficient order depo provera online philippines clomid fertility drug for sale in uk purchase cialis mifepristona y misoprostol se vende con recetas viagra online uk does viagra keep you awake how can i tell if lamisil worked warfarin 500mg cyproheptadine autism cialis tennis actress 25 mg zoloft and alcohol can you take two 25 mg zoloft took provera for 7 days still no period can i take ibuprofen with seroquel does flagyl tablets have any effect on depo injection ciprofloxacin for cat uti kamagra 100 mg oraljelly si ta perdorim augmentin 500 125 pret is escitalopram the same as lexapro zyprexa for insomnia baclofen and ibrufen tablets are same mobic para que sirve can you take aleve with prednisone can nyquil sleep aid interact with trazodone levitra professional price paroxetine hcl 10 mg generic avodart generic walmart dutasteride can tab metformin 500mg cause hair fall can metronidazole be used for sinus infection in pets buy tamoxifen no prescription uk baclofen mg para que sirve la pastilla xenical orlistat 120mg cual es el precio de terbinafine 250 mg usa diflucan pill price es recomendable ponerse ovulos despues de cytotec sildenafil citrate tablets price in india buy lexapro 10 mg tablets diflucan for thrush does viagra work after circumcision will yogurt inter with ketoconazole doxycycline 75mg dosage does topiramate help with trichotillomania generic accutane reviewa use of fluconazole 50mg in baby of 5month old excited fluconazole under uv tamsulosina clrhidrato tamsulo hydrochloride genfar prometrium 200 mg suppositories side effects avodart oily skin get prednisone for cats without prescription wellbutrin 300mg together with zoloft 25mg para sirve isoptin how long does it take for synulox 250g antibiotics tadalafil 10mg dosage proscar uk buy 800mg zovirax cheap atorvastatin does walmart sell amoxicillin over the counter cheap flagyl no prescription metformin 2500 mg per day can i drink orange juice while taking flagyl can fluconazole treat syphilis how to make a bactrim ds suspension for cats seroquel withdrawal sr if i take synthroid can i take red yeast rice cheap clomid online flagyl 500 ishale iyi gelirmi is white flagyl tablet safe in pregnancy valtrex 500 mg 42 comprimidos trazodone 25 mg depression viagra no prescription next day delivery what does tamsulosin look like lisinopril accord side effects will 60mg propranolol help with anxiety attacks prozac without depression how much is singulair tablets in ireland total cost of accutane treatment monthly xenical or obetas which one is more effective misoprostol laboratorios serral buy cipro 500mg el levofloxacino corta la menstruacion levofloxacin pharex normal side effect order topiramate online rash from bactrim treatment lexapro itching side effects serious is cialis sold on the street is proventil for broncitis levitra brand name or generic allegra d prices walgreens conjugated bilirubin 8 buy viagra sydney amoxicillintylosin romoxtyl price ciprofloxacin hcl 500 for canines singulair 4 mg can u give too a dog 1month and two weeks on accutane and still no results naprosyn costo lisinopril 2.5 taking it on.empty stomach farmacocinetica y farmacodinamia de prazosin lisinopril without prescription cheapest viagra online in uk strattera medication is it a upper shedding on propecia generic cialis available united states doxycycline tablets 100mg used does lexapro increase anxiety cosa e naprosyn

Bioethical Questions Addressed in Vatican Released "Dignitas Personae"

An interview with Father Thomas Berg LC, executive director of the Westchester Institute for Ethics and the Human Person and member of the Ethics Committee of New York’s Empire State Stem Cell Board.
by Colin Fagnan, LC | Source:

Dignitas Personae (“The Dignity of the Person”), document released by the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith with the approval of the Holy Father, reaffirms the Vatican’s position on multiple bioethical topics which include human cloning, in vitro fertilization and more recently, embryonic stem cell research. The ongoing scientific research on such topics continues to produce new moral questions which for the most part, do not immediately provide quick easy answers.   

The precursor to Dignitas Personae (DP) was Donum Vitae (The Gift of Life) which the same congregation published in 1987 and sparked debate in some quarters of the Church, particularly because of the document’s “restrictions” on certain alternative means of procreation  such as invitro-fertilization. DP will not substitute Donum Vitae nor does it introduce any new core principles; the new Instruction seems intended rather to serve as a compliment to the 1987 document.

With the release of this new Instruction as a backdrop, I recently interviewed Father Thomas Berg LC, executive director of the Westchester Institute for Ethics and the Human Person and member of the Ethics Committee of New York’s Empire State Stem Cell Board. Fr. Berg is directly involved with bioethics issues and collaborates with leading experts in the field of both science and morality.

1) Before we address the Instruction, what can you tell us of your involvement in the bioethics debate in North America?
Here at the Westchester Institute, our central purpose to is address very thorny moral problems by bringing together some of the finest specialists in ethics, moral theology and related disciplines to address the problem and hopefully move the debate forward. Many of these problems of course are to be found in the realm of bioethics. We have worked for the past four years evaluating and promoting alternatives to embryo-destructive stem cell research (such as Altered Nuclear Transfer and Direct Cell Reprogramming), we have explored the issue of ‘embryo rescue’ from a Catholic perspective as a possible solution to the dilemma of surplus and unwanted, frozen IVF embryos; we have explored such questions as the use of condoms to prevent the spread of the AIDS virus, as well as the still controversial question of brain death. I also serve on the ethics committee of the Empire State Stem Cell Board which oversees $600 million in New York state funding for stem cell research. I also collaborate closely with members of the President’s Council on Bioethics, the National Catholic Bioethics Center and the United States Catholic Conference.

2) How does your work with the Westchester Institute contribute to the ongoing research on bioethics?
I’ll answer with one example.  Both times that President Bush used his veto power to halt bills in Congress that would have increased federal funding for embryo destructive research, he did so on the premise that there are ethically acceptable and scientifically endorsed alternatives either available or in the making.  His hand was strengthened by the fact these alternatives were on the horizon. They were on the horizon (and on the White House radar) largely due to the efforts of Dr. William Hurlbut of Stanford University and member of the President’s Council on Bioethics.  Dr. Hurlbut’s ability to influence the situation was, in turn, largely strengthened by our work as an Institute in getting a large number of ethicists and moral theologians in the know and on board in supporting and at least conditionally endorsing some of these alternatives. I think we had a real impact on the Bush policy and indirectly on public opinion about stem cell research.

3) What do you think the Magisterium is trying to communicate to the public through Dignitas Personae? Is the document very explicit in addressing many issues in bioethics?
The Church wants to first of all reaffirm the principles already established in the previous Instruction, also from the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith, published in 1987, Donum Vitae, a document which in its time did the same thing, namely, addressing several issues bearing on the dignity of nascent human life and conjugal love.  The new instruction, Dignitas Personae, is something of an update. With it, the Church has shown that she is very forward looking on these matters and abreast of the most recent developments. Through DP, the Church wants to offer faithful Catholics a point of reference around which to form their consciences on these delicate and complex matters such as In Vitro Fertilization, Emergency Contraception, Pre-implantation Genetic Diagnosis (PGD), Gene Therapy, and a host of other issues mentioned in the document.

4) In your opinion, what is the most significant topic addressed by the Church with this important document?
I would say there are two teachings that are most prominent. The first is that the human embryo is to be treated as, and given the respect due to, a human person from the first moment of conception. The other is the reaffirmation of the dignity of human procreation and its proper place within marriage and its proper source, namely, the marital act of a husband and wife.

5) Will Dignitas Personae be overall well received by North American Catholics? Do you think its population as a whole is open to what this document offers as a message?
If they read it thoughtfully and with an open mind, yes. Even better if they were to take the time to study it carefully, and also to re-read and study the previous Instruction Donum Vitae.  Unfortunately, I fear these Catholics will be a minority. Many Catholics will largely remain ignorant of the document, and many will struggle to understand the Church’s teaching that recourse to in vitro fertilization is morally illicit. But that is not the fault of the document or the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. It is simply a reminder of the dire need we have in the Church today for adult catechesis.  Adult Catholics need to have the reasons behind these various moral norms explained to them, and explained well and convincingly. Today, that is still a very tall order. There are not enough well prepared, adult catechists to go around. So this remains a huge challenge for the Church as we continue on into the 21st century.

6) It seems to be the case that many people are simply out of touch with what the Catholic Church is teaching on the topic of bioethics; many were not aware, especially among the younger generation, of any previous document addressing the issue (such as Donum Vitae, not to mention Humanae Vitae  the Church’s 1968 teaching on contraception). Do you think Dignitas Personae is relevant to the lives of people today? Even to young people?

Yes, absolutely. But again, this Instruction will refer them back to the previous Instruction Donum Vitae and I think most people who never looked at that document will want to go back and read and study it.  The younger the readers, the more “relevant” these documents become because for younger persons bioethical issues are as ordinary as baseball, the Internet or text messaging. They are also much more familiar with biology and biotech than older folks, so yes, this will be of interest to them.

7) Many Catholics were hoping that DP would give a clear answer on the question of whether so-called ‘embryo rescue’ is licit, meaning whether, for example, a married couple could attempt to thaw and then implant in the wife’s womb one or more unwanted embryos in frozen storage at an IVF clinic, perhaps even with the intention of adopting the embryos later. Did DP clarify this question?
Suprisingly, no, DP is unclear in its answer in this regard. It addresses the question in number 19. The long and the short of it is that the document would appear to lean in the direction of considering embryo-rescue illicit, but it falls short of stating that clearly.  It does state, however, that a couple attempting to transfer embryos merely as a solution for their infertility would be acting illicitly.  In this, it seems, the document sees a violation of the goods of marriage. The yet unresolved question is whether embryo adoption, pursued simply with the intent of rescuing unwanted embryos, is in itself illicit for similar reasons. The document does not address this and we will need further clarification on this from the CDF is some other form.

We can be sure that continued medical and scientific breakthroughs in biotechnology will occasion more instructions from Rome similar to DP. These instructions are of vital importance in order to give reasons for the Church’s teaching on the sanctity of life and marriage, and offer guidance to Catholics who want to inform their consciences in accord with those teachings. 

In these months following its release in North America, DP has not played a major role in the public square and it remains to be seen what impact it will have, if any, on bioethical debates. It’s still not clear precisely when the Vatican will unveil its next instruction on the bioethics issue, but it will undoubtedly keep a close watch on any new developments from under the microscope.

Contact the author through: 

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular