white discharge during clomid 50mg can you take mobic and maxalt no metformin before surgery buy metronidazole boots que es mejor meloxicam o celebrex amoxicillin capsules i.p.250 thiazide diuretic prescription cpt code fungsi plavix clopidogrel 75mg do you need a doctors prescription for cialis in canada wellbutrin weight loss purple pill dosage chart images desyrel 75 mg venta de cytotec en farmacias similares levitra buy what if i take 2 nexium accidentally alendronate 70 mg reviews who is actress playing tennis on cialis commercial aborto con depo provera albuterol nebulizer treatment and benadryl topiramate side effects to gums does topamax cause pruritus finasteride 0.5 mg funciona buy indomethacin 50 mg where can i buy erythromycin ophthalmic ointment en que farmacias existen cytotec en el peru arequipa viagra weekly use young men what are gabapentin overdose long term issues side effects of inderal 80 mg twice daily on vision cymbalta causes insomnia glucophage xr for sale escitalopram 5mg amoxicillin trihydrate benedex for are throat dosage pastillas acyclovir online viagra safety zoloft 100mg for depression buy accutane roaccutane reciews prednisone for muscle pain topiramate australia can terbinafine hcl cure chlamydia seroquel overdose how much laboratorios que vendem danazol 100 mg how much to fill cialis prescription how far apart should i take duloxetine and vicodin can amitriptyline cause bruxism nhs can you give a dog melatonin and hydroxyzine bactrim sulfamethoxazole acne paxil sleep walking can antivirals clear up dermatitis antibiotic for flu like symptoms price of augmentin1.2 gm inireland what vitamins is the equivelent to thyroxine can men take cialis when trying to conceive viagra kaufen in walmart dosis misoprostol 200mg lamisil once uk order viagra over the phone how to prevent a headaches reviews on cialis is it okay to take sudafed and valacyclovir together azithromycin itching side effects amaryl m 1 mg lamisil tablets online what to expext when using cialis phenergan price cvs can wellbutrin make you sleepwalk plavix in the emergency department can single dose diflucan affect birth control buspar dosage too high fexofenadine 180 mg best price what can i use viagra 6800mg for no period after taking provera 7 days diovan prices costco metronidazole and plan b codigo de pastillas cyrux misoprostol naprosyn 10 gel prezzo provera 10 mg efectos secundarios tamoxifen msds does augmentin cause tinnitus mucous zofran 927 cialis prices us wellbutrin 433 will neurontin ad to a percocet high feeling iv augmentin 625mg can i take plavix with and tums can i stop taking prednisone after 8 days breastfeeding while on the drug flomax which best shampoo nioxin and nizoral shampoo remeron withdrawal walmart vende bactrim sin receta cytotec 800g cytotec and purple glove amlodipine 5mg tablets flagyl uk antonella tosti dutasteride quetiapine 400 levothyroxine for dogs no prescriptions mail order usa prozac online no prescription canada arcolane vs nizoral dosage for doxycycline in dogs is prednisone safe for kids buy stromectol online generic cozaar manufacturers adderall and allegra d efektet amox amoxicillina can prednisone help rhinoplasty swelling buy priligy online malaysia diflucan one tablet dose buy propecia cheap no prescription ciprofloxacin hcl 500 mg tab or doxycycline 100mg 300 mg of doxycycline for skin infection generic sildenafil citrate online diflucan 100 mg price can you successfully overdose on propranolol lisinopril tablets usp 20 mg metronidazole .75 cream side effects doxycycline price walmart without insurance zithromax gonorrhea australia para que sirve las pastias captopril does anyone take buspar for pms kifaru50 vs viagra how long should an erection last zyprexa price uk neurontin causing liver disease buy zyban online uk can i take allegra and advil migraine digoxin 500 mg doxycycline 6 weeks metronidazole sedation effects does coreg have gluten cytotec en irapuato drinking one beer on flagyl 250 mg finasteride 1mg walmart verapamil 40 mg side effects cytotec microsoft 200 osteo bioflex metformin and glucophage when is cipro used as a prophylaxis is lisinopril bad for gout purchase fluoxetine online azithromycin dalcohol rink day six misoprostol 5 weeks pregnant acyclovir ointment philippine brand buy clopidogrel no prescription fluconazole actavis and alcohol price lexapro australia signs propecia is working finasteride 0.5 mg al dia actos 15 mg generic cara kerja atorvastatin took clomiphene citrate 100mg but did not conceive,why telmisartan sales red viagra india validita sildenafil sandoz 100 mg order levitra viagra citalopram 6 months tabac anafranil 25mg how a 2 year old could take amoxicillin montelukast sodium urdu prices viagra can you take clomid with midols quetiapine fumarate tablets 300 mg generic valsartan usa price levitra costco cialis soft gel tabs cutting in half hair loss dutasteride can i take half of paroxetine hcl 20 mg mixing sustained release and active propranolol can you buy viagra in mexico walmart generic viagra vega can you take ondansetron on an empty stomach pseudomonas amoxicillin metronidazole for treatment vaginal wart zoloft saved my marriage doxycycline injection india buy flagyl medication neurontin 25mg amoxicillin roddexil dosage for 500 mg albuterol inhaler dosage in nicu seroquel and spice klonopin n lamictal n remeron atorvastatin 40 mg price costco quetiapine 12.5mg tablets atomoxetine generic availability 200 mg zoloft side effects bactrim ds price cvs cuanto cuesta la pastilla propecia took 3000 mg metformin pregnancy proscar no prescription quanto costa periactin sciroppo cipro for group b strep medicine available in mumbai for good erection can u get high on 20 mg baclofen over does on 1 500 mg of trazodone baclofen paracetamol together buy mifepristone misoprostol uk die etinilestradiol can men take fluconazole for anal itch buy ondansetron orally disintegrating 4mg 3 days of prednisone withdrawal nigeria prize for clomiphene drug can clomiphene make be pregnant if i make love problems with slo niacin with atorvastatin 40 mg thuoc azithromycin 500mg cytotec sintomas de aborto azithromycin 3g gonorrhea cyproheptadine 4 mg tablet dosage quetiapine liquid uk ciprofloxacin 8nv will amoxicillin kill pinworms verdaderas pastillas misoprostol lipitor price philippines augmentin 625mg in india zithromax sweating cialis 80 mg reviews alendronate sodium 70 mg prednisone dosage bulging disk how does sertraline 50 mg work side effects of lexapro 10mg para q sirve cytotec pastilla y consecuencias constipation in dogs on prednisone fluconazole during third trimester pregnancy can singulair tablets be crushed buy amoxicillin european augmentin or curam cause diarhoe why nizoral so expensive 50mg quetiapine sandoz for chemo side effects cuantas dosis se necesita de cytotec para 3 semanas bio metronidazole it treat what kind of discharge smoking weed and reducing prednisone symptoms what is gabapentin composed of sildenafil uk patent expiry does taking estrogen lower clomid results pra que serve o medicamento moduretic 25 homeda ase 04 baclofen c 30 globuli generic cialis 20mg uk how much cost is amlodipine in philippines se pueden combinar el ibuprofeno y meloxicam tadafil cialis 200 mg black citalopram after 3 months can you take viagra if you are drunk quetiapine opiumwet can you take azithromycin for ringworm does metronidazole lowers blood sugar how long does fluconazole take to cure thrush que funcion cumple la pastilla cytotec tamoxifen citrate online no prescription cd37 clomid piroxicam 20 apa fungsinya tome misoprostol y me bajan coagulos generic nbsp nbsp viagra prednisone 5mg side effects converting labetolol doses to metoprolol is it safe to give dogs zyrtec and prednisone together micardis 40 mg cost can you take garcinia cambogia if you take buspar direction for use kamagra oval gelis bijsluiter voltaren retard 75 alcohol can you take micardis plus and coversyl azithromycin canadian pharmacy amoxicillin kashrus est ce a woman can take a viagra cheap nexium tablets can metronidazole lighten my period isotretinoin for sale uk cialis cataracts does 1g of azithromycin come in one pill cipro neviropin 500 mg infants paroxetine 30 mg tablets is half 75mg plavix effective spirit a lactose and gynecomastia buy tamoxifen citrate liquid benzonatate can it used as an antibiotic is clomid a form of progesterone how much weight loss on wellbutrin sr metronidazole cmp took celexa once..increased anxiety..joint pain lena and allegra metronidazole gel substitute no prescription structure activity relationship for acyclovir famciclovir cold sore uptodate and dose of prednisone for posion ivy can propranolol hydrochloride 80 mg make you high azithromycin 1gm pakpow greenstone can azithromycin give you diareeah insomnia on prometrium no uterus erythromycin dose for hormonal acne synthroid and belly fat how many days take amoxicillin for boils what does viagra cost in los algadones zyprexa zydis faster rapid allergic reaction to premarin viagra online shopping cytotec como se toma y q tan peligrosa es isoptin 12mg orlistat peanut butter buy kamagra in london doxycycline 100mg malaria cost price of generic augmentin 875 amoxil 12h suspension northcyprus viagra availability nursing implications for plavix took lexapro for 3 months flagyl 750mg online cheap how to taper off 30mg of buspirone vyvanse wellbutrin interaction fluoxetine 5 weeks can you take levitra if your allergic to asprin acyclovir and epilepsy can take both ondonsetron and coumadine the same time urban legend about babies and antibiotics azithromycin 1g oral suspension dose of metronidazole in buccal tab orlistat y dieta melatonin and thyroxine are examples of i want to use viagra to solve early errction of sperm trazodone large dose 1000mg tb. medroxyprogesterone ringworm ointment tetracycline ointment lipitor price philippines donde puedo comprar misoprostol sin receta en neuquen misoprostol uruguay comprar clopidogrel cold antibiotics for syphilis cipro zovirax pills in the philippines patent litigation against dutasteride prednisone for poison ivy rash priligy germany price voltaren tabletten 600 amoxicillin breastfeeding south africa RETROFITREBATE.COM neurontin 600 mg side effects gabapentin at 50 mg side effects price for generic viagra levofloxacin crush tablet burn throat 30mg daily dexamethasone side effects how long does it take for terbinafine to start working zyvox global sales harga obat levofloxacin infus 100ml clomid 150 mg and no ovulation xasten dexamethasone tablet will doxycycline 100mg treat kidney infection remeron rd compared to effexor estrace no prescription will doxycycline hyclate 100mg treat staph infection citrato de sildenafila 50ml walmart amoxicillin preis caverta generic viagra generic viagra pillshoprxcom colchicine houde pills xasten dexamethasone fiche medicament avantage 400 metronidazole and vaginal infection norvasc pret order cialis coupons harga chloramphenicol eye ointment what kind of capsule is red non prescription lamisil 250 for yeast infection amaryl price in pakistan levitra odt tamsulosin 0 4 mg pret hyponatremia in patients taking bactrim singulair and dogs priligy kopen belgie contrast dye metformin meloxicam anticonceptivos 30mg precio erectile dysfunction pills sold in hawaii tetracycline acne la gi mrp of linezolid 600 in india market tetracycline acne price nexium harga flagyl 39 70 femara cd 5 9 when will i ovulate duloxetine 120 mg daily nifedipine with ccf terbinafine hcl use in horses amoxicillin for ferrets list of foods you can eat while taking cipro

California Reviews Prop. 8

Marriage proponents expect good news after court hearing.
by Sue Ellin Browder | Source:

SAN FRANCISCO — Same-sex “marriage” has been on a seesaw in California. First, voters voted to protect the definition of marriage. Then, the state Supreme Court redefined marriage to include same-sex couples. Next, in Proposition 8, voters reestablished marriage’s traditional definition. The pro-marriage amendment passed last fall.

In a hearing here March 5, California Supreme Court justices seemed strongly inclined to uphold Proposition 8.

But the justices also seemed reluctant to nullify the 18,000 or so same-sex “marriages” that took place between May (when the court ruled same-sex couples could “marry”) and November (when voters passed Prop. 8).

Kenneth Starr, dean of the Pepperdine University School of Law in Malibu and Whitewater prosecutor, represented, the coalition that sponsored the initiative. During the three-hour hearing, he argued the amendment was legally approved by the majority of voters and it would be a miscarriage of justice for the court to overturn the results of a fair election.

The California Catholic Conference is a member of the coalition.

Also arguing at the hearing were lawyers for two groups of same-sex couples challenging the initiative for the city of San Francisco and for California Attorney General Jerry Brown. They maintained that Proposition 8 is not a constitutional amendment but instead an improper revision that fundamentally alters the structure of government by depriving a minority of access to a right.

Attorney Shannon Minter of the National Center for Lesbian Rights argued in court that marriage is a “fundamental right.” He said denying same-sex couples the right to marry puts them “in a second-class status” and “marks them as second-class citizens.”

Proposition 8, approved by more than 52% of voters, restored the 14-word definition of marriage that the Supreme Court had ruled unconstitutional in a 4-3 decision last May: “Only marriage between a man and a woman is valid or recognized in California.”

Starr said the principle at stake is not the wisdom of the voters’ decision to amend the state Constitution to limit marriage to a man and a woman but whether the Constitution gives the electorate the power to vote such a definition into law.

He argued that there have been no cases that have come before the court to question that right and that the seven justices weighing Proposition 8 must not deviate.

“We’re asking you to stay the course and not chart a new course,” said Starr.

But questions raised by the bench strongly suggested the justices saw the key question in this case to be whether or not the people of California have a right to change their own constitution.

The court will render a decision within 90 days of the hearing.

Two justices who were part of a 4-3 majority in last year’s ruling giving homosexuals the civil right to “marry” — Chief Justice Ronald George and Justice Joyce Kennard — both made strong statements indicating the people of California have a right to change their own constitution, whether the court likes what they do or not.

George said California’s Constitution has been amended more than 500 times and asked, “Isn’t that the system we have to live with” until or unless it’s changed?

He pointed to a case in which the state Supreme Court threw out the death penalty and the people of California overrode the court to reinstate it.

Kennard said that in her view this case involved “a very different issue” from the one in May and made it clear she was not ready to “willy-nilly disregard the will of the people.”

Several justices pointed out that allowing Prop. 8 to stand does nothing to take away the “panoply” or “bundle” of legal rights same-sex couples enjoy in California.

Arguing on behalf of Attorney General Jerry Brown that Prop. 8 should be overturned, Deputy State Attorney General Christopher Krueger said the majority does not have “unbridled power” to take away an “inalienable right” from the minority. He called the Prop. 8 amendment “draconian.”

But Kennard asked Krueger, “What about the inalienable right of the people to amend the Constitution as the people see fit?”

Arguments presented on behalf of Brown’s office, strongly based on cases dating back to the mid-1800s, were referred to by the court as “very novel” and even “quaint.”

Interim ‘Marriages’

What to do about the 18,000 interim “marriages” was another question in the case. Carol Hogan, a spokeswoman for the California Catholic Conference, the bishops’ office of public policy in Sacramento, who attended the hearings, called them “problematic, because it creates two classes of people.” She said letting those unions stand leaves “a tension in the law that at some point will come back to them. You can’t have two classes of people.”

Charles LiMandri, Thomas More Law Center’s West Coast director, predicted the 18,000 unions, if left intact, won’t have “a significant impact on the culture,” at least not in California.

Estimating that one-third of those “marriages” involved couples from other states that don’t recognize their licenses and observing that same-sex relationships “tend to last just a couple years,” LiMandri said, “You’re going to have probably on the order of about 5,000 of those ‘marriages’ left five years from now. In a state the size of California — 36 million or so — that’s not going to have much of an impact.”

As for the outcome of the case, Joe Infranco, an Alliance Defense Fund lawyer working on the Prop. 8 issue, said his group is “confident the justices are going to recognize the democratic process and do the right thing.”

William Duncan, attorney with the Marriage Law Foundation in Lehi, Utah, concurred. “I’m optimistic the court will rule in favor of Prop. 8 and step away from the brink of saying that the judges themselves are the ones who have the final say on this issue.”

Elizabeth Gill, staff attorney with the American Civil Liberties Union of Northern California, believed the right thing would be for the court to strike down Prop. 8. “The court has a solemn responsibility to enforce our state Constitution and to protect the rights of all people, regardless of popular opinion,” Gill said.

But Carol Hogan said the hearing “went very well for our side.”

The law is clearly on our side,” she said. “So we’re cautiously optimistic.”

Considering the justices’ statements in court, LiMandri said, “I think we won.”

If Prop. 8 stands, same-sex “marriage” activists “will now focus on New England,” LiMandri predicted. “But without a major state like California, this will knock them back on their agenda, if not for a generation, at least a decade.”

Catholic News Service contributed to this article. Sue Ellin Browder writes from Willits, California.
March 22-28, 2009 Issue

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular