fosinopril and hydrochlorothiazide ciprofloxacin bacterial infection scarlet fever augmentin dose antidepressants for tmj can you take advair and ventolin together tadalafil cialis or vardenafil levitra isoptin retard 240mg bactrim autre nom how many times can a man cum taking viagra maximum dose hydrochlorothiazide harga obat acyclovir cream generik are seroquel and abilify the same levothyroxine therapeutic category metronidazole nome commerciale lamisil creme effet secondaire will valsartan affect vardenafil dose of furosemide congestive heart failure swollen lymph nodes after accutane cipros obat jerawat prednisone burst for lower back pain paroxetine sale cost doxycycline tablets uk singulair deep sleep can you take cymbalta and levothyroxine sodium como puedo conseguir viagra is viagra available in bali cost of prescription ciproxin tablets in nigeria levitra peru 10 milligrams of celexa como colocarse las pastillas cytotec generic plavix image nexium side coupon can you take 2 once a day cialis se vende cytotec en argentina tamoxifen citrate and clomid metoprolol succinate nz wellbutrin ambien tamsulosina clorhidrato 0.4 mg topamax bipolar dosing taking blood pressure medication with cialis olanzapine fluoxetine hcl ciprofloxacin convert into body zyprexa kritik deltasone and night sweats price xenical ireland side effects of ciprofloxacin 500 lexapro side effects pimples how much does metronidazole cost for pets. tenormin 25 mg street value para comprar viagra ? preciso receita american viagra cialis medication interactions esomeprazole domperidone pdf metoprolol tartrate compared with innovator tamoxifen 10 mg role in male body can doxycycline cure a uti mi az ampicillin viagra tablet 5800mg twins can you take diflucan while taking cetrizine cymbalta no prescription canada how do you get high from gabapentin how much does strattera cost for 30 days supply antibiotics for strep throat doxycycline difference between toprol xl and lopressor fluconazole dosage for thrush in the intestinal topiramate 25 mg used for weight loss orlistat 60mg online spain revatio dci neurontin generic brand get cialis at walgreens clomid ovulation calculator uk estradiol test results fertility should you take cipro and flagyl together cytomel synthroid combination keflex dose in cats amitriptyline for treating ibs cialis viagra cost comparasin levothyroxine antibiotic acyclovir miracle cialis pills what are for buy provera and clomid lisinapril versus lisinopril with hctz augmentin farmacologie taking nexium for gerd nolvadex tamoxifen testosterone cost of acyclovir without insurance customer reviews of cymbalta aldactone suspension mucinex d zoloft how much valtrex for herpes rovex nexium 7000 forum ciprofloxacin 500 anwendungsgebiete accutane 50 kg what to expect when you take cialis misoprostol amning high prolactin and clomid feel sick after taking celexa seroquel dose for bipolar depression nickname for nebulizer albuterol my son relese presser levitra amoxicillin clavulanate overdose viagra cymbalta combination india female viagra plavix and spinal surgery how many viagras will medco pay for in a month is doxazosin mesylate a ace effect of glucophage with nifedipine in pregnancy amitriptyline for ocular migraines quetiapine liquid form uk doxycycline how fast ciprofloxacin cold medicine levaquin false positive for opiates propranolol for cirrohiss buy indomethacin capsules is amoxicillin safe for 6 month old reductil ou xenical moon face while on prednisone can my 14 year old take bactrim for strep throat how long does sildenafil lasts antibiotic to cover strep and uti what is the average age man use viagra how long tell septra starts working avodart 5 mg price lamisil ointment tinea versicolor amlodipine tri benh gi trazodone for zoloft clopidogrel and fish oil dapoxetine work sertraline agitated depression danazol def 50 levofloxacin hydrochloride zoloft luvox china pills with cialis in it wysoki poziom estradiolu in vitro amoxil y embarazo 500mg cipro for uti times 3 days side effects of metoprolol and lisinopril in men retail price of maxalt adalat 17th june effects of accutane on hair amoxicillin cinfa 500 mg dawkowanie ciprofloxacino 100 mg para que sirve ivermectin dose chart for dogs lasix conversion from iv to po lexapro 5mg tablets price celexa dosage mg can cialis be prescribed for incontenence generico e viagra metronidazole pediatric doses cymbalta coupon eli lilly efficacia vardenafil dose of zoloft for ocd bactrim ds recommended dosage provera 5mg tablet lamisil pronunciation can neurontin cause erectile dysfunction premarin vaginal cream and lisinopril for pregnant women cipro back pain glucophage metformin price in peshawar diflucan is used to treat what fluconazole dose uti what happens in lungs with lisinopril and albuterol prednisone and root canal what happens if you drink alcohol with doxycycline diy cialis aciclovir 400gr men tamoxifen finasteride linezolid hypoglycemia what to expect with 20 mg prednisone generic propecia expensive ask com is nexium over the counter recreational adderall use while on zoloft can ngu be cured with ciprofloxin trazodone cost without insurance vitix ok with levothyroxine zithromax 1 gm for sale without a prescription fluconazole dosage by weight does zoloft withdrawal go away cipro for td seroquel dosage schedule ciprofloxacin drug summary amlodipine asce what if i take cialis one time zoloft tested on animals does lisinopril 10 mg have m 89 on it singulair 10 mg tablets fluoxetine and pregnancy plavix 450 mg montelukast can treat gerd taking pepcid with prednisone azithromycin antibiotic for chlamydia propranolol when pregnant augmentin ou pyostacine dapoxetine for over 70 years old bisoprolol vs propranolol in tetralogy za sta sluzi lek plavix ingrdients in generic levitra can albuterol cause diaper rash bystolic versus metoprolol amoxicillin for tulo sildenafil kypros right dose of accutane sertraline 100 mg cost without insurance funciona el lamisil 1 quest diagnostics clopidogrel hyderabad contact purchase sildenafil doxycycline renal failure what are the effects of too much prednisone plavix erectile please can flagyl tablet reduce or cure staphylococcus clomid cycle day 14 metformin clomiphene citrate metronidazole benzoate compound recipe famciclovir msds normal dose for singulair zoloft and security clearance side effects of baclofen in female patients misoprostol venta sin receta en morelia flomax 8 pump parts uses ofprazosin hydrochloride 5 mg who was on 100mg clomid and got no side effect at all can you take clomid day 6 10 prednisone hurts my stomach lisinopril cycling plavix tabletten losartan with tadalafil in india levitra does it need prescription how do i take 50 mg diflucan for oral thrush taking both allegra and zyrtec tamsulosin weight gain side effects of lexapro when coming off of it viagra pour adolescent azithromycin dosage first day how long does it take prednisone to leave body viagra bayer leverkusen .8 mg levothyroxine equal to mcg bactrim avelox cyproheptadine syrup in the uk is viagra become generic next month can you mix delsym and azithromycin can you get pregnant whilst on tamoxifen pityriasis versicolor metronidazole how long should one take doxycycline lamisil oral manufacturer acheter cialis welfil 20 is celebrex better than vicodin amitriptyline low dose migraine paxil is what class of drug doxycycline hyclate before bed tamoxifen and urinary problems nitroglycerin contains 60 as many why dont i have side effects to propecia doxycycline hepatotoxicity maxalt smelttablet zwanger plavix 150 mg jour lipitor cost vs generic duloxetine head pain fluoxetine 6 weeks where to find otc generic lamisil for toenail fungus theanine with prozac zofran scrubs isoptin sr 120 mg cena how long does it take for zoloft to exit the body inderal dosaggio ansia cheap viagra uk sale time for strattera to take effect mekanisme kerja disulfiram difference between 50 and 75 mg zoloft using albuterol smoking lasix side effect constipation seroquel 300 mg street value can cialis give you spots associacao de clomid e premarin misoprostol miscarriage orally topamax and fainting hydroxyzine 50mg price ondansetron icd 9 accutane out of breath tinidazole to buy avodart class drugs nexium iv oplossen break zoloft in half bactrim dosing pediatric uti doxycycline malaria mechanism of action why isnt generic cialis sold in the united states can u drink alcohol with ciprofloxacin lamisil atsauksmes nexium icd 9 code doxycycline osteoporosis abilify coupon code generic med valtrex lexapro side effects what to do sony 8 bengali adalat time saturday would half of 25 milligram of seroquel help me sleep how long am i contagious after taking valtrex cara aman konsumsi viagra ketoconazole shampoo causing peeling of skin bactrim i canesten vaginalete nifedipine images ciprofloxacino produce dolor de cabeza does metronidazole 500 mg cause brown discharge amoxicillin dosage for ear infections in dogs how much flagyl to take for bv tamoxifen avastin finasteride tablets 5mg metformin and skin sensitivity plavix dosis indikasi gabapentin with effexor amoxicillin 15 ind diflucan pink pill lipitor and calcium levels viagra overnight best price cialis heart rhythm thyroxine effects on menstruation arimdex plus clomid low testosterone para que sirve clomiphene citrate 150mg how long for bactrim to work on uti dog took lexapro escitalopram generic antidepressants red viagra cialis 200 blood donation propecia does meloxicam come in 30mg valacyclovir in mexico hcg aromasin nolvadex pct amoxicillin effectiveness cartilage piercing infection cymbalta makes me sick amoxicillin and mono rash duration teva metformin odor lipitor elderly levitra 400 mg can you drink alcohol with olanzapine 2.5mg nexium tablet dissolution ciprofloxacino pode beber bactrim ds pricing taking metformin while on birth control allergic to penicillin can i take zithromax mankind vardenafil tab in delhi valtrex dosage adults allegra di viola dizzy spells on clomid recharge mobicart orange internet smoking pot while on abilify eddie bravo propecia side effects of lexapro women levitra play week azithromycin for gonorrhea dosage men viagra in hindi tapering dose prednisone abilify life allergic reaction ciprofloxacin case report ibuprofen and lisinopril duracion tratamiento levofloxacino bcs classification on gabapentine drinking alcohol and spironolactone zestril composition accutane pregnancy after taking what does allopurinol do for gout dapoxetine nps doxazosin uses would overdose seroquel avanza alcohol suicide lasix safe in pregnancy glimepiride in pakistan xenical online shopping site para comprar clomid hyderabad pharmacies viagra furosemide injeksi ciprofloxacina ino clomid 12.5mg ed metronidazole dosage for bv 500 tamoxifeno tab best herbal viagra bactrim para la prostatitis buy isotretinoin gel dog panting after prednisone stopping lipitor and gallstones zyban frequent urination safe to take viagra young olanzapine 15 mg azithromycin unexplained rash what is estrace 2 mg used for azithromycin 1g tablet how to take misoprostol vaginally

Easter Evidence

Scholars Now Tend to Believe the Resurrection
by TIM DRAKE | Source:
SAN DIEGO — If the so-called “Jesus Family Tomb” proves anything, it’s that efforts to discount the resurrection continue. It’s a mystery that remains a stumbling block for many.

Last month, the Discovery Channel aired James Cameron’s documentary on the “Jesus Family Tomb,” claiming the discovery of a tomb with ossuaries bearing the names of Jesus, Mary Magdalene, and “Judah son of Jesus.”

Scholars and archaeologists disproved Cameron’s findings, saying that the text on the Mary Magdalene ossuary actually read “Mary and Martha,” and that the tomb was more than likely the tomb of St. Paul’s friend, another Jesus, who was also known as Justus, son of Joseph. Following the revelation, Discovery pulled its planned repeat of the program.

Yet, according to several Catholic theologians and apologists, there’s a new trend in Scripture scholarship. That trend is away from the skepticism and suspicion of the past four decades toward an acceptance of the Gospels and toward the fact that Christ’s resurrection is the only explanation that makes sense.

The Catechism of the Catholic Church teaches that “the mystery of Christ’s resurrection is a real event, with manifestations that were historically verified, as the New Testament bears witness” (CCC 639).

Pope Benedict XVI has said as much.

“I trust the Gospels,” he wrote in the introduction to his forthcoming book on Christ, Jesus of Nazareth: From the Baptism in the Jordan to the Transfiguration.

“Being a Christian is not the result of an ethical choice or a lofty idea, but the encounter with an event,” he said in his first encyclical letter, Deus Caritas Est (God Is Love).

Protestants often turn to other sources for proof. The popular Evangelical speaker and author Josh McDowell writes about the significance of the moved stone and the grave clothes.

That’s natural, says Steve Ray, an Evangelical convert to the Catholic faith.

“In the Catholic world, we trust in the authority of the Church,” he said. “Evangelicals are always looking for facts. If all you have is the book, you’re constantly trying to prove that the book is true. We believe when the Church told us that Christ rose from the dead, the Church is the voice of Christ in the world today, and we can trust it. It’s a whole different methodology because of what we see as our source of authority.”

“What puzzles the world, and its wise philosophers and fanciful pagan poets, about the priests and people of the Catholic Church is that they still behave as if they were messengers,” wrote the British Catholic convert G.K. Chesterton in The Everlasting Man. “A messenger does not dream about what his message might be, or argue about what it probably would be; he delivers it as it is.”

“The Church would never use things like the Shroud of Turin or the gravestone to try to prove the resurrection,” said Michael Barber, professor of theology at John Paul the Great Catholic University in San Diego, Calif. “There is a distinction between public and private revelation. The shroud is not part of the deposit of faith.”

Instead, Catholics rely on the authority of the Church, the Biblical evidence, and tradition that has been passed on.

“The compelling evidence for me is the unanimous testimony of all the apostles and even a former persecutor like St. Paul,” said Brant Pitre, assistant professor of theology at Our Lady of Holy Cross College in New Orleans. “There was no debate in the first century over whether Jesus was resurrected or not.”

Scholars say that the witnesses to Christ’s resurrection are compelling for a variety of reasons.

“People will seldom die even for what they know to be true. Twelve men don’t give up their lives for a lie,” said Ray, who recently returned from France, where he was filming his “Footprints of God” series at the amphitheater in Lyon, the site of a persecution in A.D. 177. “The martyrs of Lyon underwent two days of torture and all they would say is, ‘I am a Christian.’ They knew the resurrection was true and didn’t question it.”

Barber also highlighted the diversity of sources and how they include different details as well as passages that do not paint the disciples in the best light.

“In the Road to Emmaus story, they write that they didn’t recognize him,” said Barber. “Our Biblical accounts are our best evidence.”

Several of the scholars pointed to 1 Corinthians, where Paul states that Christ appeared to 500 people.

“Some want to shy away from the Gospels because they say they were written later,” explained Barber. “If you want to believe that they were written later, then why wouldn’t the Gospels have made use of this piece of evidence from 1 Corinthians?” asked Barber.

Barber also pointed to two non-Christian sources that make reference to Christ. The first is Tacitus. The second is the Jewish historian Flavius Josephus, who, noted Barber, actually mentions the resurrection.

“In Antiquities of the Jews, Book 18, Chapter 3, paragraph 3, Josephus references Jesus’ resurrection,” said Barber. “The problem is that most scholars think it’s a later Christian addition to Josephus. We don’t have his original work.”

Recent Scholarship

Belief in resurrection was not completely foreign to Judaism.

“A belief in the resurrection of the dead is a major element of traditional Judaism,” said Jon Levenson, professor of Jewish studies at Harvard. “According to the Mishnah, the first rabbinic law code, belief that God would resurrect the dead is an obligation, not an option, for Jews.”

But, as Barber pointed out, such a belief was only found in one segment of Judaism at the time of Christ.

“The Pharisees believed in resurrection; the Sadducees didn’t,” said Barber. “But along with that belief was that with the resurrection would come the dawning of the restoration of the Davidic kingdom.”
Barber also points to the fact that Christ’s resurrection is not the only resurrection attested to in the Gospels.

He referenced the resurrections of Lazarus and Jairus’ daughter.

And in the Gospel of Matthew (27:52-53), when Jesus dies, “tombs were opened, and the bodies of many saints who had fallen asleep were raised. And coming forth from their tombs after his resurrection, they entered the holy city and appeared to many.”

“The fundamental conviction in a scientific age with our post-enlightenment views is that these things didn’t happen,” said Barber. “People have determined that any source that talks about resurrection is unreliable and rule it out. What kind of science is that? You don’t just dispense with evidence that you don’t like.

“Many scholars are now recognizing that one should not so easily dismiss the reliability of the Gospel of John,” added Barber. “Some have compared the Gospel of John with the Pauline epistles and found numerous points of contact, so it’s very plausible that John’s Gospel may have been written earlier than previously thought by many historical critical scholars.”

Gone are the days where the Jesus Seminar dominated. The Jesus Seminar is a research team of New Testament scholars founded in 1985 by the late Robert Funk and ex-priest John Dominic Crossan to use historical methods to determine what Jesus may or may not have said or done. The seminar’s reconstruction of Jesus portrayed him as a wandering sage who did not found a religion or rise from the dead.

According to Barber, there’s an alignment of scholars in support of the original Gospel texts.

“The dominant strain in mainstream Biblical scholarship is from those who are convinced that the Gospels are indeed reliable,” said Barber. He cited the work of N.T. Wright, Craig Evans, Craig Blomberg and Richard Bauckham as some examples.

“These people are not on the fringes. They are in the mainstream,” said Barber. “At the Society of Biblical Literature gathering in Atlanta last year, Eerdmans Books sold out of all of Wright’s book before the three-day conference was over.”

“In The Resurrection of the Son of God, Wright argues that the bodily resurrection of Jesus is the best historical explanation for what happened, given the evidence,” said Pitre. “Whenever others posit alternative scenarios, such as that the body was stolen or that people only saw his spirit, you have to discount all kinds of evidence from the Gospel. Those alternatives lack evidence to back them up.”

Skeptics discount the resurrection, said Catholic apologist Dave Armstrong, because no one saw the event itself. Yet, Armstrong pointed out, “not many people witness murders, either, but we manage to scrounge up enough evidence to punish murderers. Nobody witnessed the Big Bang or the whole process of macroevolution, but atheists and agnostics have no trouble believing in those things.”

Finally, all of the scholars agreed that Christ’s resurrection ran counter to Jewish monotheism. Therefore, they wonder, how else can you account for the rise of Christianity aside from the resurrection?

“Look at all the data from the Gospels and the eyewitnesses, and there is no other way to account for the rise of Christianity than the rising of Jesus from the tomb on the third day,” said Barber. “There’s no other way to make sense of the data we have.”

No matter what evidence we have, noted Barber, we’ll always come up short.

“The resurrection is a mystery. We can’t demonstrate the mysteries of faith empirically. We don’t know all the details, we just know the tomb was empty,” said Barber. “The mysteries go beyond reason.”

Tim Drake writes from St. Joseph, Minnesota.

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular