acyclovir 800 mg tab adalat sony tv episode 24 arreter clomid is there a recall on celebrex taking kamagra without ed can l buy amoxicillin in amsterdam how man can make viagra at home dr oz e metformina nebenwirkungen zoloft 150 orlistat stain removal what is doxycycline 100mg capsule priligy singapore review can you give zofran to 3 year old ventolin volumatic augmentin mercury drug philippines how much codeine in phenergan with codeine taking amoxicillin while on nuvaring albuterol solution patient assistance program why do cephalexin tablets smell metformin dose 3g clopidogrel og alkohol how fast can you get pregnant while taking metformin metformin hcl 500 mg tablet solco albuterol influenza undiluted phenergan cuantas pastillas de cytotec se debe tomar antidepressants sideeffects seroquel nach schlaganfall yeast infection fluconazole alcohol paroxetine 20 mg in india singulair cause acid reflux cost of iv zyvox oral jelly kamagra in urdu fluconazole tablets australia amlodipine thiazide diuretic dog diaretics without a prescription ivermectina em gotas bisoprolol hydrochlorothiazide biogaran ivermectin australia scabies metronidazole 500 mg efectos secundarios risque sous clomid why cant you take allegra with oj buspirone 15 mg pill does it get you high amoxicillin allergic to paracetamol does long term use of prednisone cause early menopause is wellbutrin being taken off the market how much would would you sell 1 clonidine azithromycin in urdu how do i talk to my doctor about cialis red sildenafil trazodone paxil interaction generic levitra pros and cons albuterol sulfate hfa treats allegra d and alcohol celecoxib and postoperative ivermectin dog tapeworms tamoxifen drug category taking azithromycin and keflex together anastrozoletablets lp metoprolol anaesthesia sildenafil citrate merck index online viagra delivery inderal prices 3g amoxicillin for dental celebrex 200mg tablets aciclovir foglietto illustrativo linezolid 600 mg costo varicela en lactantes aciclovir zoloft ulcer long term use of side effect of paxil in women lexapro help ocd strattera and brain injury ivermectin in pregnant rabbits viagra erection angle should i take baby aspirin with clomid ear infection ofloxacin otic solution finasteride in kerala levitra with or without food lexapro 5 mg effectiveness generic cipro 250 looks like can tamoxifen cause hemorrhoids gabapentin d03 street value long term side effects of topamax health benefit doxycycline tamoxifen rowcmoadreders discount strattera liquid compound sertraline after 4 weeks what are the side effects of coming off amitriptyline tetracycline mercury drug price lexapro leaving system can i have a drink while taking bactrim free erection herbal sample victoria australia quetiapine xl 150 mg best place to buy tamoxifen on line uk metformin abgesetzt zugenommen viagra plus cyalis cipro y acetaminofen ampicillin dosage mims what is iepradium bromide albuterol sulfate estradiol uk spelling gsk zovirax cream effectiveness how many diflucan pills can you take when is the best time to take ciprofloxacin mylan valacyclovir 500 mg lisinopril burning skin fluconazole 750 mg single dose tablet price inr overnight cialis delivery deskripsi ubat provera alternatives to sildenafil citrate did you have late ovulation after taking clomid albuterol inhaler cfc mexico fake orlistat capsules teva aero kids montelukast 4mg tablets for kids cialis genericos online sertraline ilaci hydroxyzine singulair how long before fluconazole works doxycycline discounts buy one 1000 pill of zithromax overnight azithromycin single dose buy amoxicillin espanol non prescription lasix pronounce nifedipine quetiapine treatment for stem cell manfaat levofloxacin 500 generic version of topiramate prednisone used for poison oak cytotec buy online uk tadalafil dapoxetine tablets india should i drink a lot of water with lasix when does doxycycline work for acne will taking viagra give me longer erection diovan 160 mg price prednisone interactions with acetaminophen cymbalta 40mg reputable cialis online cheap singulair without prescription flagyl 500 mg,aturan minum viagra canada toronto can i take seroquel with 80 mg oxy science behind cialis super active can zoloft cause birth defects metoprolol tartrate tablet 50mg viagra 100 and disadvantage maksud fluconazole tablets lp celecoxib 100 mg para que sirve buy amaryllis plant rizatriptan benzoate tablet 5mg montelukast cost bcbs strattera en espanol amoxicillin allergie ausschlag behandlung generic pharmacy hq womenra female viagra mirtazapine and steak anxiety from abilify seroquel approval history epek samping nexium 20 mg symptoms of being allergic to augmentin amoxicilline for sore throat cvs disulfiram pellets dosis natural trim diet pill mixing wellbutrin and pristiq forum which one cialis or viagra azithromycin can you drink on cipro hc otic shelf life lipitor total synthesis lopressor brand name availability fungsi mycoral 200 ketoconazole metoprolol and liver problems cuanto vale la pastilla de viagra buy dexamethasone injection online india gabapentin for burning feet prednisone burst for lower back pain keflex strep pharyngitis prednisone treat asthma walmart price of lisinopril 2.5 mg metoprolol er succinate mfg watson is that hydrocodone can you split cialis pills in half finasteride for hair loss in men in pakistan clomiphene hyperstimulation generic cialis germany order viagra paypal stop plavix for surgery withdrawal symptoms paroxetine cabergoline 0.5 mg used nexium 80 mg per day compare sildenafil cymbalta causing shakiness what if a girl uses viagra seroquel xr advantages side effects of missing antidepressants cephalexin la thuoc chua benh gi clomid fibroids tamoxifen gains cymbalta zinc allegra vojvode dragomira can i get propecia from walk in clinic fluconazole capsule prices in india levitra buy 20mg ventolin expectorant obat batuk viagra pfizer south africa viagra en paracetamol does zofran work quickly halotest 25 clomid stimulus for release of thyroxine propranolol stage fright dosage amitriptyline body temperature propecia amm metronidazole uso augmentin 1g efectos secundarios de medicamento neurontin viagra oder cialis forum can you take zofran with flexeril low cost viagra canada plavix side effects of nausea buspirone 100mg nolvadex a tamoxifen xenical weight loss reviews doxycycline hyclate 30 days fluconazole and tinea cruris metronidazole for dogs how many days wean off 100 mg of neurontin irbesartan 300 mg tablets amoxicillin treatment for flu que es doxazosin 2mg,clasificacion lipitor otc walgreens crestor and celexa dosing of prednisone for croup viagra online price comparison kamagra 100 oral jelly si ta perdorim vigorar sinonimos sildenafil red 100 how to use tamil fentolamina e viagra taking allegra at night baclofen 10 mg side effects silagra generic viagra cumwithuscom what pain reliever is safe with plavix azithromycin 1 gram packet strattera farmacodinamia can you take ibuprofen for nitroglycerin patch headache insomnia taking zoloft treatment with nexium can you purchase nexium over counter hat jemand erfahrung mit celebrex azithromycin chemspider best pill cutter for viagra in canada doxycycline acne long does take work thyroxine and bupripion patient views on cymbalta buy levitra 10mg uk clopidogrel ingesta accidental effects of too much doxycycline methocarbamol was ist das ubat clomid does cephalexin affect pill paxil quiz order viagra by mastercard can i take amlodipine with viagra how long before flagyl works for bv medroxyprogesterone for sale methocarbamol 750 mg tabletki can you take viagra with calcium channel blockers can i buy viagra over the counter in qatar celexa day 10 gabapentin for psychiatric use gulf fluconazole 200 what is it for amoxicillin dosage in infant manfaat obat fluconazole 1000 mg metformin enough pcos drugs related to celexa can humans get high off bupropion hydrochloride will topiramate show on a drug test escitalopram substitute in homeopathy fluconazole yeast infection treatment levofloxacin for esbl mix nitroglycerin and hydrocortisone cream how can i make viagra more efective accutane hair thinning permanent how to ween off neurontin what are the side effects of generic viagra efek furosemide how use pregnant women montelukast sodium topiramate and obesity naprosyn 375 mg tablet renal dosing of cipro prednisone effects on temperature dicloxacillin together levofloxacin ear price of flagyl 500 mg at walmart can i take prevacid with lipitor and celexa were can i buy provera in nigeria what is the capital of inderal diet pill sample lamisil krem nedir cialis too young buy voltaren gel no prescription how to buy viagra in amsterdam topamax skin rash does celebrex affect coumadin how many amoxicillin pills to cure gonorrhea how long should i take bactrim ds esta 10 escitalopram cialis shortness of breath what is 1000mg of flagyl a day presrcibed for cipro for phlebitis lisinopril ranbaxy price in india personal experience with paxil lexahist cyproheptadine how long gabapentin take to work phenergan antihistamine in dogs viagra two times a day singulair makes me cough flagyl forte metronidazole 500 mg obat apa cephalexin forexine benefits of femara for fertility long term use propecia hot flashes naproxen norman 500 metronidazole 250mg tablets menstrual phenergan and zoloft interactions levothyroxine available in lahore stores linezolid zyvox 600 mg rashes caused by azithromycin misoprostol serral sirve igual que la de fyzer generic voltaren cream acyclovir dosage renal prednisone sabor dulce en la boca gabapentin grupo terapeutico levitra professional difference levitra apa itu kamagra buy estradiol patch does ciprofloxacin cause gas i took 4 azithromycin generic lexapro vs brand lexapro lasix effects on kidneys desogen planned parenthood absorption maxima of metronidazole mobic and tylenol 3 syrup atarax price in pakistan cost of antibiotics in the philippines how much are antibiotics in spain flagyl 400 dosage and treatment zyprexa zydis 5 mg pseudomonas aeruginosa and doxycycline when will propecia consumer reports canadian pharmacy viagra brand lexapro increasing histamine ok to drink wine with 15 mg prednisone is it safe to give dog albuterol for congestion lioresal y alcohol neurontin weaning schedule what is the cost of nexium in canada allopurinol kinetics can you take viagra and lisinopril together walmart seroquel xl price buspar for anxiety colcrys dosage benicar 20 mg side effects allopurinol ja alkoholi skin rash synthroid metronidazole fresenius 500mg used for what mg strengths of buspar is there what does levothyroxine 75 mg look like propranolol treat high blood pressure is a seven week old baby too small for albuterol dutasteride binnen europa bestellen how to recover from prednisone use benicar and prednisone zyprexa and risperdal taken together prednisone makes scabies worse cipron for weight gain langsing dengan metformin strattera orodispersible tablets can i take prednisone doxycycline and ibuprofen how much liquid amoxicillin for adults why should prednisone not be stopped suddenly medroxyprogesterone 10 mg gre para que sirve pregnancy test calculator clomid atorvastatin calcium amorphous molecular weight cost of viagra at walmart in honoluluhi dostinex manufacturer ventolin salbutamol 0 50 mg dosis tab.metoprolol 12.5 fatigue when using diflucan online ordering viagra prednisone how many mg price of tab ondansetron 4 mg

An ‘A’ Plan For Plan B

Connecticut’s Cautionary Tale
by Rev. Deacon Tom Davis | Source:
The history of Connecticut’s emergency contraception law offers lessons that national and state Catholic Conferences would be well advised to study.

A state law went into effect on Oct. 1 requiring Catholic hospitals to change their rape treatment protocols and adopt state mandated provisions that undermine religious liberty. On Sept. 27 the bishops of Connecticut announced a policy of reluctant compliance with the new law.

Catholic teaching accepts treatment of rape victims aimed at preventing fertilization. But it strictly prohibits treatments that destroy human life, including the life of an embryo, which is nothing other than a tiny human being. Any treatment that prevents embryo implantation in the womb violates Catholic conscience.

Before the new law, Connecticut’s Catholic hospitals treated rape victims capable of conceiving with chemical treatment to prevent fertilization if “ovulatory phase testing” was negative. A positive ovulatory phase test indicates imminent or ongoing ovulation and increased risk that possible, if uncertain, consequences of the treatment may render the womb inhospitable to an embryo.

The law forces them to make such chemical treatment available to victims capable of conceiving without considering the results of ovulatory phase testing.

Two years of robust debate has made plain the most effective response to similar proposals in other jurisdictions. And make no mistake; the proposals will come quickly as the leading edge of a strategy aimed at mandating comprehensive “reproductive health” education, referral or services at licensed health care facilities, including Catholic hospitals.

Proponents of the Connecticut law built a coalition that included elected officials, representatives from Planned Parenthood of Connecticut and Massachusetts, NARAL Pro-Choice Connecticut, the League of Women Voters, The Merger Watch Project, Family Planning Advocates of New York, ACLU Connecticut, sexual assault counseling services, Connecticut Women’s Education and Legal Fund, Republican Majority for Choice, various religious organizations, medical professionals, including obstetricians and gynecologists, internists, forensic and registered nurses, physician’s assistants, emergency medicine practitioners, professional medical organizations, social workers, rape victims and an expert in emergency contraception who recently questioned claims that it has post-fertilization causality in a peer reviewed commentary in the Journal of the American Medical Association.

Op-ed articles, media interviews and university and community activism were coordinated with lobbying directed at legislators and the Catholic public, complete with polling data claiming wide support for emergency contraception among Catholics in Connecticut.

At legislative hearings in March, an artfully managed parade of witnesses assured the committee that emergency contraception merely suppresses ovulation and never causes an abortion. Others silently applied their view that abortion only refers to the disruption of implantation and thereby dismissed concerns for migratory “cells.”

Committee members were ready with carefully developed lines of questioning drawing out critical points in the debate. Other witnesses applied political pressure, noting their membership numbers. Still others presented constitutional and legal analysis, polling data, psychological aspects of rape trauma, and the history of similar laws in other jurisdictions where state Catholic conferences reportedly agreed to the bill. Several rape victims presented emotionally compelling testimony.

By the end of the hearing, a mini-trial had been skillfully presented that overwhelmed the meager response from an unorganized opposition of pro-life activists, two courageous rape victims, a lawyer and a deacon.

No medical expert appeared in opposition to the bill, thereby leaving unchallenged the claim of many proponents that Plan B does not prevent implantation. Readers of the Register are well aware that the jury is out on that issue. Nonetheless, a perception arose within the General Assembly that the Church simply misunderstood the science behind Plan B and medical testimony that all of Plan B’s secondary action could be explained by prevention of sperm migration gained greater weight.

Finally, there was widespread skepticism among legislators given the position of other state Catholic conferences, and this directly accounted for votes in favor of the law from otherwise solid pro-life legislators.

The lessons to be taken from the debacle that followed are plain enough: In order to preserve the independence of Catholic health care, a stand must be made in the Plan B debate.

It will require a powerful show of expert and lay witnesses at legislative hearings. Medical witnesses should include obstetricians, gynecologists, fertility experts and radiologists who can explain from existing medical knowledge how post-fertilization effects may be extrapolated.

Catholic hospital staff and administrators, bioethicists, moral theologians, rape victims, representatives of Catholic women’s organizations and waves of laity should testify.

Representatives of the Knights of Columbus and other Catholic societies should amass membership petitions of politically significant numbers and present them to legislators at public hearings.

Early lobbying, careful witness selection, preparation of suggested questions for sympathetic legislators, strict accuracy on medical facts and frank explanation of varying approaches by different state Catholic conferences are essential. Special attention should be given to the ready acknowledgment by the best-known proponents of emergency contraception (Davidoff & Trussell) that Plan B may have a post-fertilization effect, and that in the face of existing doubt women receiving it should be advised that it may prevent implantation.

That admission points to the value of ovulatory phase testing in the search for a reasoned judgment about the potential abortive effect in a given case.

Legal scholars and litigation counsel should present arguments focusing on the free exercise clause of the Constitution. They should point out the alternatives that exist to a Catholic hospital’s directly dispensing the drug. They should cite the Restoration of Religious Liberties Acts in states that have them.

In addition to health care facilities directly regulated by the law, other prospective plaintiffs should testify, including physicians whose ability to fully assess patients is limited by the act, and women of child-bearing age who, if raped, would want to know the results of ovulation testing before deciding to accept Plan B.

Vigorous defense will set the political stage for battles yet to come. By marshalling Catholic infrastructure and political assets, allies will be emboldened, adversaries confronted and wavering legislators possibly persuaded.

The Connecticut bishops led a courageous battle for more than two years with little visible support from rank-and-file Catholics. There were isolated pro-life activists and a small band of legislators who risked much for principle.

But to many in my own state who now so fervently express their dismay over the outcome, it is fair to ask: When legislative hearings invited public testimony and the shepherds looked about for their rallying flock — when the intensity of your witness was most needed — where were you?

It is the vocation of the laity to transform the temporal realities of the world, no less in statehouses than in families. Boots on the ground win land wars and legislative battles. The lesson for everyone is to be engaged early and often.

In many ways the looming battle is a graced opportunity.

During debate in Connecticut, some expressed confusion about Catholic doctrine, believing the Church makes an exception to its teaching on the intrinsic evil of contraception in the case of rape.

At every opportunity, be it parish forum or legislative hearing, speakers should explain that truly unitive sexuality is not about the mere joining of body parts, but about the communion of persons. Rape is thus not authentically unitive and the rapist’s sperm remains an “unjust aggressor” against which the victim has the right of self-defense.

To provide chemical treatment that prevents fertilization in response to rape is not only not an exception to Church teaching, it is a right the victim may demand in justice and one the Church champions so long as post-fertilization effects are excluded to a moral certainty.

That foundation is entirely appropriate in the debates shaping up across America about emergency contraception and rape treatment. It clearly demarks a line that cannot be crossed and it just may be the beginning of a new discussion about the richness of the Church’s teaching on conjugal love, human sexuality and the transmission of life.

Rev. Deacon Thomas J. Davis Jr., J.D., L.LM, M.A., is a deacon of the Melkite Greek-Catholic Eparchy of Newton.
Source: National Catholic Register - November 11-17, 2007 Issue

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular