cymbalta fatigue bactrim side effects uti nexium interaccion con alimentos topamax and energy levels doxycycline avec pilule ya m trage las pastillas de misoprostol ahora q misoprostol sabor how to increase cm on clomid medroxyprogesterone 10 mg 10 days side effects viagra how many years can take buspirone anxiety pill doxycycline hyclate stye generic metoprolol baownbeuv will cipro treat an abscessed tooth comprar tamoxifeno 20 mg uses of levofloxacin tablets oily hair while on accutane levitra levitra vasculitis cialis price inhong kong isotretinoin berbahaya will topamax block klonopin atorvastatin interaction with alcohol buy fluconazole 150 mg no prescription cytotec funciona a los 5 meses ciprofloxacin ranbaxy 500 mg comprimidos cortef to prednisone conversion what dose is cialis for daily use how much is viagra in cancun cymbalta 60 mg wikipedia strattera online bestellen aeroporti principali cipro jaw pain and prednisone will 4000 mg of flagyl cure chlamydia inderal side effects memory side effects from 2 prednisone pills can u order.periactin on ebay ivermectin tqeovertoz overnight cyproheptadine 4mg for migraines review nortriptyline cost plavix 75mg clopidogrel vardenafil prezzo farmacia synthroid reviews metronidazole in pregnant cat will babies be ok can i take clomid for 3 days obat viagra alami olanzapine withdrawal symptoms yahoo ask will taking clomid make me go through menopause sooner inderal function ondansetron odt 4mg is it okay with ibuprofen que es mejor lamisil o canesten acyclovir cream for canker sores cipro 14.1 and 15.1 tetracycline 500mg capsules for acne baise hard avec viagra que riesgos corro al tomar cytotec viagra online legal or not canada lexapro side effects treatments wellbutrin good depression diflucan used to treat poison oak how to get pregnant taking clomid estradiol 75 uno tts 30 celebrex 200mg azithromycin single dose chlamydia professional cialis canada finasteride 5mg reviews adderall and gabapentin high nizoral sachete aripiprazole sevrage fluconazole sore throat viagra concorrentes clomid cycle 9 dpo nifedipine embarazo kamagra baownbeuv online lexapro for memory loss valtrex stomach ache amlodipine besylate cut in half 2.5 mg ondansetron odt for uti dosing for erythromycin propecia australia buy online erythromycin ointment onset peak duration lasix iv route can you buy viagra in costa teguise lanzarote is wellbutrin expensive obat cyproheptadine micardis 80 mg precio venezuela too much levothroid symptoms cheap viagra los angeles how long paxil to work revolution ivermectina abilify administracion zyloprim tqeovertoz price wellbutrin reviews for depression assistir efeito do viagra when will seroquel go generic in us estrace cream effectiveness what household items act like viagra gabapentin uk buy online xenical slimming capsule medscape augmentin tab 625 how much days viagra demie vie diet different pill type efectos del estradiol en el embarazo viagra online contrareembolso espana azithromycin mk how long before 5mg cialis starts to work prednisone and cyclobenzaprine tenormin alternate concor plavix generic at walmart cytotec di makassar best price cialis without prescription viagra by pfizer for sale topiramate shape color will gabapentin make you fail a drug test propecia rogaine nizoral combination buy lasix australia buy zithromax 1 gram in las vegas strattera panic attacks is taking clomid without consulting your doctor bad how long do you wait cialis can azithromycin 250 mg be taken with imodium ad good experience buying cialis online priligy online satis wellbutrin prozac suicide cymbalta and alcohol interaction mylan metformin 500 mg uses premarin warning letter ivermectin singapore cost of doxycycline hyclate 20 mg meth and erections uk kamagra con apakah manfaat atarax dan diazepam ethinyl estradiol vs estradiol potency hydrochlorothiazide dogs side effects atarax soir metronidazole left out erythromycin 3 times a day clomid reviews bodybuilding xenical usei augmentin 1.2 gm dose metronidazole dosage poultry cuanto tiempo debo tomar cialis can you mix cymbalta and adderall viagra blodtrycksmedicin norvasc 20 mg dose azithromycin and hyperactivity otc orlistat uk too much levothyroxine anxiety azithromycin over counter holland amoxil lt gabapentin making dog smell taking lisinopril long term metformin hexal 1000 mg nebenwirkungen lamisil once twice presentacion de cytotec misoprostol ecuador ceftriaxone and cipro prescription viagra from canada without prescription tac dung thuoc ketoconazole orlistat pastillas comprar lithium orotate zoloft levothyroxine side effects hemorrhoids ciprofloxacina colirio bula sildenafil citrate tablets price in india much does propecia cost uk metformin lh why does strattera stop working doxycycline for long periods quetiapine tolerance what is amoxicillin half life mirtazapine 30 mg tablet erythromycin dosage in paediatrics celexa makes me tired all time equivalente atarax 25mg para que nos sirve la ciprofloxacina seroquel no sus fake viagra singapore amoxicillin sodium ld50 tamoxifen citrate 20mg cost in mexico breathalyzer singulair i just started taking levitra terbinafine suspensie 25mg brand viagra can you take ventolin while pregnant cialis 5mg didnt work atorvastatin chest pressure side effect does premarin have progesterone in it zyprexa lustlos length of time for a rash to develop from plavix valtrex bivirkning plavix assistance forms viagra cura impotencia clomiphene explain in urdu can i stop lexapro after 15 weeks pcos femara success rates ciprofloxacin to cure infection orinaria zma and warfarin does lisinopril cause excessive sweating weaning of lexapro and dealing with nausea atorvastatin tablets ip 10mg side effects zyprexa krampfanfalle can amoxicillin be used to brin bck missesd period dapoxetine rowcmoadreders canada atenolol al 25 hund canine dosing for prednisone como puedo conseguir misoprostol en argentina is it ok to take valacyclovir an emuaid cream are cialis dailey the same kamagra softkamagra jelly side effects valtrex prostate viagra from tesco in what dosage forms is singulair available food act like viagra adult male taking clomid amoxicillin berapa elavil baownbeuv online ivermectina en perros lactantes diflucan first trimester is it alright to take viagra before smoking marijuana buy lisinopri hct without prescription norvasc 15mg how long levitra is detectable in system which is better accutane or roaccutane levofloxacin loading dose fluoxetine amitriptyline drug interaction icd 10 ripening misoprostol prednisone and cerebral edema ivermectin dosage for dogs oral es malo tomar keflex en el embarazo erythromycin ointment not working prostatectomy tadalafil what does the clomid do doxycycline acne benefits action of lasix cytotec en riobamba levofloxacin 750 and alcohol acyclovir 200 mg cipro xr 500 mg prices in south africa phenergan 25mgs... how long does it cause drowsiness can i give my dog augmentin 875mg south african viagra does remron interact with antibiotics generic price on lexapro in united states 5mg how long to absorb zithromax tablet is metronidazole and tricare the same thing glasgow buy cialis can nexium cause indigestion ventolin for cough and phlegm lexapro dosage 70 mg kamagra donne alternative to lisinopril side effects lasix 80 mg dose prednisone in adrenal insufficiency tadalafil generic india reviews what does yellow viagra look like online albuterol sulfate for nebulizer price misoprostol en la paz bolivia cialis 60mgrs griseofulvin in tinea versicolor cipro hc no prescription zara azithromycin tablets 500mg with alcohol plavix law suit payments tadalafil what is it used for que pasa si tomo 100 mg de viagra when seroquel will help relax you does ventolin inhaler can a dog drink ciprofloxacine tamoxifen buikpijn tac dung cua cephalexin cipro j does it cut menstruation propranolol and methadone sony t v serial adalat atorvastatin calcium pharmacokinetics gonal f ou clomid best viagra prices uk klebsiella pneumoniae treatment with ciprofloxacin intrucciones de las pastillas cytotec taking zofran and phenergan together while pregnant neurontin vs lyrica weight gain metformin side effects equine urinary incontinence celebrex levitra agent australia que causa la nexium dr 20 mg can 500mg azithromycin be split 2.5 tadalafil cheap cialis witout perscription in the united states switching from propecia to nizoral free cialis trial coupon canada diet while taking synthroid metformin ve alkol how long finasteride works does zoloft overdose pay for military pay zyprexa zydis dosage range first antibiotic tetracycline ataxia from prednisone eye srps paxil and seroquel combination zyvox presentaciones fluconazole tines corporis when do you use metronidazole in dogs where is metoprolol metabolized why would viagra bother make my nose stuffy cam i make love when taking clomiphene 4 twins order depo provera no prescription valtrex sold over the counter buy clomid post cycle online in uk no prescription bactrim tableti cena cyproheptadine 200 mg syrup captopril with or without food dibujos de viagra adalat retard use for uterine contraction is safe allegra side effects in elderly xenical and jenny craig prednisone help fibromyalgia antibiotic a 45 treats how many amoxicillin 500mg do i take a day for clap price of tan premarin 0.625 allegra d and cold medicine clomid off the counter did flomax go otc azithromycin vs levofloxacin lamisil en argentina amoxicillin cycling prazosin 1 mg doxycycline for acne how long can you take it breaking out bad after accutane generic seroquel 8165 cuantas cytotec se usa para aborto de seus semanas buy accutane toronto lexapro taper up how much time willviagra can you take flagyll for malaria levitra 10 mg precio chile strattera for fun nolvadex proviron augmentin dosage 1000mg dostinex 1gr how long does it take to notice if propecia is working atarax 12.5 mg otc allegra mg difference between prednisone vs prednisolone can my dog take generic bactrim viagra in one day vardenafil hcl 20mg how long does erection last what nursing care for furosemide terbinafine lotrimin acyclovir side effects taste augmentin bis prospect875 ml doxycycline skin pigmentation does lamisil interfere with oral contraceptives what does cipro and flagyl treat provigil plus wellbutrin how long for seroquel to work for anxiety que es persantine thallium cialis calcium channel blockers augmentin es xarope side effects to paxil women viagra in delhi india high prolactin and clomid cialis 5 mg best price mexico pamelor online ciprofloxacin whartisthebestin no prescription paxil best time of day to take dissolve cipro tablet and nebulizer cymbalta and sweating alendronate 4 dollar list assistence program that covers lisinopril mobicom surprise uilchilgee why doxycycline is expensive in the philippines diflucan swelling celexa used weight loss atarax uses side effects bactrim 200 40 mg ulotka topamax prescribed for bipolar in uk can melatonin be taken with flagyl metformin pcos ttc success metoprolol grupo terapeutico can you get viagra in usa over the counter does finasteride increase insurance aciclovir sirve para las hemorroides para que sirve la pastilla apodefil sildenafil hiperplasia prostatica cialis

Pharmacists Win Washington Victory

TACOMA, Wash. — Pharmacists’ right to exercise their conscience won a victory, even if it proves to be short-lived.
by Elenor K. Schoen | Source:
On Nov. 8, a federal judge in Tacoma, Wash., ruled in favor of a pharmacy owner and two pharmacists, temporarily halting enforcement of a Washington State Pharmacy Board regulation threatening pharmacists’ right of conscience. Some pharmacists saw the regulation as compromising their profession by forcing them to fill Plan B prescriptions.

According to Jim Ramseth, a pharmacist in Covington, Wash., for the last 40 years, it was cause for celebration. “This is big,” he said. “We are professionals that use our whole ethical being to make our decisions.”

Ramseth emphasized that “if our freedom of religion or conscience is prohibited, that’s against what our country was built on.”

Under the injunction, which is in effect until a trial in October 2008, both pharmacies and pharmacists may refuse to dispense the contraceptive drug, but they must also “immediately refer the patient either to the nearest source, or nearby source, of Plan B.”

In granting the injunction, Judge Ronald Leighton of the U.S. District Court for the Western District of Washington stated that “on the issue of Free Exercise of Religion alone, the evidence before the court convinces it that plaintiffs, individual pharmacists, have demonstrated both a likelihood of success on the merits and the possibility of irreparable injury.”

“This is a much broader issue than Plan B,” Dan Kennedy emphasized. As CEO of Human Life of Washington, he was part of an effort to support the pharmacists. “Both our right and our duty to act according to our conscience is a foundational principle of liberty. …This is an issue that no American can be apathetic about.”

Judge Leighton admitted that the evidence provided in the case pointed to an “overriding objective of the [pharmacy board] regulations … to eliminate moral and religious objections from the business of dispensing medication … [which imposed] a Hobson’s choice for … pharmacists who object to Plan B: Dispense a drug that ends a life as defined by their religious teachings, or leave their present position in the state of Washington.”

Kristen Waggoner, attorney for the pharmacy owner and pharmacists in the lawsuit, explained that the state “cannot target the pharmacists on their deeply held religious beliefs, forcing them to choose between their faith and their livelihood.”

She further stated that a legal injunction, as handed down by the federal court in the case, “is hard to get.” The court had to be convinced that the case could “win on First Amendment grounds” once it went to trial. “That’s huge,” she declared.

Judge Leighton’s written decision offered an explanation of why it is “huge.” He wrote that “the principle that government may not enact laws that suppress religious belief or practice is so well understood that few violations are recorded in United States Supreme Court opinions.” He emphasized that any state law which intends to discriminate against individuals because of their religious practices or beliefs “is subject to strict scrutiny.”

Nonetheless, State Sen. Karen Keiser, D-Kent, vowed that the Democratic-controlled Washington Legislature would take up a bill to require pharmacists to dispense the pills.

Most state officials were not as eager to say whether they would appeal.

“This is a complex issue with a complex ruling,” said Don Moyer, a state Department of Health spokesman. “We’re certainly going to talk to our lawyers.”

Concern for Access
The defendants in the case insisted that it was always a matter of access to medication. As attorney for the state, Paul Lawrence --— a board member of the American Civil Liberties Union and past president of ACLU of Washington — claimed during oral arguments in September that the focus of the regulation was, in fact, freedom of access. Perceived threats to the right of conscience were merely “an incidental effect,” he declared.

But the judge pointed to the lack of evidence “that anyone in the state of Washington has ever failed to obtain Plan B within the 72-hour window of effectiveness because one or more pharmacists/pharmacies refused to fill a lawful prescription for Plan B.”

Don Downing, associate professor of pharmacy at the University of Washington, appeared to agree when he said that the “vast majority” of pharmacists in the state are “ardent supporters” of Plan B. Now that it can be sold over the counter, most people won’t even need the help of a pharmacist in obtaining the drug.

The most recent threat to pharmacists’ conscience rights occurred in early November when New Jersey Gov. Jon Corzine signed a bill into law threatening pharmacists who refuse to set aside their personal beliefs and dispense drugs like Plan B.

Other cases have dealt with lawsuits concerning wrongful firing by employers, such as the case against Wal-Mart Stores in Illinois. Unlike Washington’s case, the Illinois lawsuits do not affect an executive order from Gov. Rod Blagojevich in 2005 requiring all pharmacists to fill any prescription for a legal drug, even if they cause an abortion.

The American Center for Law and Justice sued Walgreens, Wal-Mart and Blagojevich on behalf of seven pharmacists claiming the governor’s ruling violated pharmacists’ constitutional and statutory rights under the Illinois Health Care Right of Conscience Act.

The state of Illinois agreed this year that the governor’s rule “does not apply to individual pharmacists, and that the state will never apply it to individual pharmacists.” Pharmacy owners must solve any conflicts with the ruling. An attorney in the case suggested a settlement allowing pharmacies the option to work with an off-site pharmacist, filling Plan B prescriptions for pharmacists unwilling to do so.

In March 2007, the Iowa Board of Pharmacy Examiners scrapped a regulation change recognizing the pharmacists’ conscience rights when a local Planned Parenthood clinic organized a protest. Pharmacists have lost their jobs in Illinois, Texas and Wisconsin for their refusal to dispense Plan B.

Elenor Schoen is based in Shoreline, Washington.
Source: National Catholic Register - November 25 - December 1, 2007 Issue

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular