acquisto tadalafil generico inderal for delay ejaculation clomid and merional fortamet vs metformin er buy lipitor 10mg pre?o orlistat bula meloxicam 15 mg price philippines rectal tadalafil digoxin 125 mg tablets how long cipro500mg stays in system viagra triangle reviews diet effects long pill term generic metronidazole gel 1 amoxicillin face itching neurontin facial twitching aygestin mg nuovo levitra orosolubile tamoxifen ebewe 20 mg side effects doxycycline muscles lamisil and nortriptyline flagyl 500 mg wikipedia diflucan price philippines sertraline 4 6 weeks ciprofloxacina x 500 lasix myoglobin is atenolol and losartan the same atorvastatin sodium generic lipitor metformin pet dr reddy viagra levitra 20mg en france is viagra covered by blue shield side effect withdrawl comparison of lexapro and celexa talk to frank xenical amoxicillin time above mic ciprofloxacin ciprodin price in the philippines periactin hormone pills when can i drink after septra mixing ativan and zyprexa xenical in caada cialis got in my eyes para que es la lasix where can i buy furosemide for my dog is clomid good for men how much dose avodart rapor 6 ay cipro oral for ear infection cialis kelowna how often should a 16 month old have amoxicillin strattera give you energy how many hours apart should you take 500mg of metformin dr is it ok to take augmentin 1g with cialis 5mg singulair drowsiness side effects when starting wellbutrin for smoking womera viagra philippines do viagra work yahoo doxycycline 400 mg surgery levothyroxine how many pills are there in a viagra prescription celexa versus paxil for postmenopausal tamsulosin hcl 0.4 mg side effects azithromycin two first day vitamins instead of paxil medical abortion misoprostol methotrexate celebrex nocturia ketoconazole coverage amoxicillin 250 mg liquid how much for 11 year old lexapro for anger management verapamil and viagra does seroquel come in 50mg zoloft and seizure threshold heart disease and diet pills australian kamagra ventolin quemador turkish viagra reviews doxycycline dosage for sinus infection lanoxin 0.125 compresse se toma kamagra gel dostinex seguridad social side effects of lasix iv push orlistat es lo mismo que sibutramina neurontin and ambien drug interactions sertraline will it keep you from getting a cdl can you take zithromax on a full stomach lexapro has no side effects in withdrawal metoprolol dosage for pots topamax side effects throat propecia 20 year old vibramycin 100g dosage metoprolol tartrate nursing responsibilities forest pharmaceuticals lexapro generic buy amaryllis bulbs taking strattera and effexor dr reedy sildenafil what can u dose if u overdose fluconazole no prescription albuterol 17g inhaler is bactrim forte 800 mg harmful to pregnancy augmentin pret dona metformin 850 mg granules amoxicillin 500 mg cost in rupees propranolol er for anxiety dosage can you take diflucan with zoloft tenormin 50 mg price what is stronger flexeril or methocarbamol taking doxycycline in early pregnancy abortion misoprostol alone celebrex dosing for back pain from golf tamoxifen australia cost ohio viagra legislation anafranil 10mg can amlodipine be taken with viagra cardizem sr 90 pre?§o trop de synthroid apo gabapentin 900 mg for anxiety 1000 mg quetiapine tramadol taken with celebrex amlodipine cost walgreens gabapentin 399 side affects farmacias donde venden cytotec en honduras finasteride for transgenders levaquin weed reaction cialis sans ordonnance en pharmacie forum tamoxifen womb lining taking 100 ml viagra two days running celebrex developer whats ciprofloxacin hcl 500mg metronidazole for 6 months is bupropion available in australia doxycycline hyclate mydoxy brand dies zoloft looses effect after 10 years taking indomethacin drug uses valtrex dystonia ciprofloxacin meds aciclovir tabletas 200 lisinopril side effects rosacea benicar 40mg appearence abilify prices usa doxycycline hyclate eyes propranolol watson can women take viagra to get high levitra 20mg t?rkei buy esomeprazole online irbesartan 150 mg causes tiredness is it okay to take viagra abroad how long after getting a stent must i drink clopidogrel buy generic colcrys amoxicilline ethinylestradiol desogestrel kristine sutherland abilify commercial gabapentin dosage dogs metformin side effects extended release kamagra im laden kaufen clopidogrel 75mg tablets prices is amoxicillin 500 mg the same as a z pack beer and bactrim ds provera medroxyprogesterone fungsinya untuk apa nolvadex increase libido cymbalta withdrawal symptoms treatment cual es la formula del cytotec lexapro ejeculation buy estradiol 3 mg cream lisinopril combined with hctz what is the disadvantages of viagra como se le llama al cytotec en honduras buy trazodone online uk lamisil over the counter cream best prices for best generic viagra periactin for migraines and oral contraceptives viagra als therapie neurontin for depersonalization can a 15 year old take a cialis furosemide at gnc online apotheke voltaren spray flagyl 250 mg for bv seroquel demanda w jakim kraju jest jest bez recepty bactrim how much antibiotics cost 4 pregnant women in medi rite lyme amoxicillin dose accutane lip problems nursing responsibility of lasix rizatriptan acetaminophen rosacea flagyl making zyvox suspension and recipe not buy can conception occur on 4th cycle of clomid paxil birth defect attorney cialis dans le sang clopidogrel cirugia augmentin bd 1000mg price in pk diflucan ship to singapore is it ok to take unisom with zoloft tadalafil 5mg australia can cialis make a woman horny lipitor with food or without erythromycin azithromycin comparison best pill splitter for viagra metronidazole dosing pellet disulfiram implantacion prednisone single dosage prazosin nederland 6 finax hair loss generic propecia amoxil syrup safe for guinea pigs can amoxicillin and levothyroxine cause green pooh hydroxyzine 25 mg pill can dogs take zofran for vomiting south africa flagyl availability sildenafil citrate oral gel patents where can i buy cialis shipped from canada cytotec provocar parto lamisil cream price in dubai order albuterol online no prescription what works just as good as viagra tinidazole south africa taking sildenafil without ed what flagyl 400mg tablets used to do es malo usar viagra priligy 30 mg welcher arzt verschreibt das generic anastrozole cost dfifference between cialis and taladafil buy acyclovir cream from canada is spironolactone safe long term tadalafil after orgasm propecia 0.25 berapa harga esomeprazole magnesium tablets she got naked after taking viagra augmentin 228 suspension side effects viagra manufacturers australia finasteride weight gain amlodipine benazepril 5 20 mg can metformin stop my periods cymbalta 60mg for ms neurontin withdrawal after taking for one month meloxicam 7 5mg para que sirve how long does it take prednisone to work in dogs cytotec misoprostol laboratorio caja tramadol sildenafil tablet cabergoline experiences celebrex de 200 mg lipitor and oranges does 20mg cialis cost twice as much as 10 mg metoprolol succinate at night generic name linezolid amoxil 500 mg buy online greece zoloft slutte azithromycin 1 gm cefixime 800 mg metronidazole tablet para que es propranolol buccal patches dose of propranolol in hyperthyroidism difference between benadryl and phenergan meloxicam bula pre paxil before intercourse fluoxetine10mg and adderal 10 mg twice per day elyzol metronidazole gel in india does cialis improve motility is flagyl bacteriostatic or bactericidal venta de cytotec en farmacias similares ciproxin 500 bayer prezzo cymbalta nerve pain 400mg gabapentin help opiate withdrawal cymbalta global sales 40 mg lisinopril fungsi diclofenac misoprostol can you buy viagra at wal mart engravidar tomando tamoxifeno ja existe cialis generico alternative lamisil once uk lisinopril 2.5 mg diazepam 2.5 is there weight gain on zoloft color of synthroid 100mg generic plavix best price out of pocket cost flagyl perte blanche sous clomid estrace 3mg kegunaan salep acyclovir 500 mg diane 35 vs aldactone amitriptyline 40mg sleep side effects drinking alcohol while taking paxil is augmentin duo good to cure tooth abcess the total cost for getting propecia cheap augmentin online avodart oily skin aciclovir pimples soti mobicontrol review will cialis prevent you from ejaculating treating anxiety with wellbutrin metformin and oatmeal chloramphenicol 5mg nefazodone buspirone clonazepam super kamagra elado buspirone hcl pill how much should i take to get high nizoral head and shoulders celecoxib vs indomethacin neurontin withdrawal symptoms cialis vrij verkrijgbaar cipro label cellulitis levaquin dose felodipine 5mg when should you start using propecia how much baclofen to get you high hair loss spironolactone dose clomid te vroeg genomen buy cialis generic australia nizoral tablets price in india do androgel and propecia cancel eachother out viagra prices germany ciproxin 1000 per uretrite posso prendere due priligy da 60ml amoxil cellulitis qualcuno sa il prezzo do periactin compresse can i take citrulline and cialis how long will zoloft stay in your system taking more than one cialis daily dose coumadin 4mg price philippines 150 mg clomid for 7 days estradiol dergboadre canada clomid wann eisprung spironolactone globus augmentin e enterogermina bactrim ds in first trimester metformin 500 mg side effects cyproterone,metformin side efects seroquel 800 mg canine doseage singulair pierwsza czesc allegra sonatowego dosage for glimepiride vs metformin buspirone and marijuana metformin in menopause is 50mg of sertraline a high dose nizoral spry walmart atarax apteka internetowa buy nexium mexico amaryl 3mg tabletten warfarin and lamisil allegra restaurant jakarta prometrium 100mg reviews erythromycin ethylsuccinate is used for levaquin side effects ibuprofen naproxen uk otc amoxicillin for 2 years old paroxetine hcl 12.5 mg durchschnittsalter viagra delais cialis azithromycin 500mg tablets cytotec cervix ripening tamoxifeno age lexapro pots syndrome cymbalta 500 compridos antibiotics what do they do fluoxetine 60 mg pregnancy can cipro br used to treat mrsa where to buy nizoral shampoo 1 generic liquid antibiotics in edmonton caccia cipro il cialis ? curativo bactrim og alkohol taking acidophilus with cephalexin is it safe to drink wine while on cipro cost of montelukast sodium at cvs buy viagra sheffield zovirax comprimidos ficha tecnica can you take phenergan every 4 hours equivalent dosage of vilitra 40 to levitra generic levitra professional lamisil once 1 cutaneous solution 4g levofloxacin 500mg teaching azithromycin 1200 mg daily azithromycin and benzonatate clomid response test baclofen esophagus sildenafil a alkohol zofran quantity sepeda secialist aldactone adrenal fatigue clomiphene citrate einnehmen can you purchase nexium over counter difference between lipitor and lipomax misoprostol y ulcera gastrica metoprolol succinate uk

The Challenge of the Catholic Film Critic

Should Catholics abandon the movies? Some think so.
by Steven D. Greydanus | Source:
Last Sunday, of the two painstakingly crafted but dark, violent pictures at the top of the Oscar nomination heap, the Academy chose — as I see it — the nihilistic, amoral one over the hollow, misanthropic one.

No Country for Old Men won a total of four awards, including picture and director, while There Will Be Blood won two, including actor. The two had been tied in the nomination race with eight categories apiece.

Other best-picture nominees included the ironically named Atonement, in which an attempted act of reparation is exposed as narcissistic self-deception, and the handsome but shallow Michael Clayton. Rounding out the five was the only one I liked, the dark-horse Juno, a crass but life-affirming comedy about a pregnant teen who changes her mind about aborting her baby and decides to give it up for adoption instead.

There was some good news. Ratatouille won animated film (and was nominated for more awards than any cartoon in history). Juno won original screenplay, and The Bourne Ultimatum won three awards. Those three were among the films I most admired last year.

In general, though, top awards and nominations went to films that underscore the moral distance between Hollywood and my own faith-informed perspective.

In spite of the Academy’s choices, 2007 remains a generally strong movie year for me, with one notable caveat: There wasn’t much high-quality family fare, other than Ratatouille and In the Shadow of the Moon. (Of course there was no problematic content in Into Great Silence, my favorite film of the year, but I wouldn’t call it a family film.)

On the other hand, for mature viewers there were profoundly moral outlooks in films like Juno, The Devil Came on Horseback and The Lives of Others, and I was pleased to include them in my 2007 Top 10 list.

At least, that’s my take. Not all adult Catholics agree. Even among active and devout Catholics, my opinions are sometimes found too harsh, other times too lax. On the one hand, some thought I was too critical of ultraviolent R-rated films like 3:10 to Yuma and Apocalypto, which they feel are deeply moral films (a claim I partly accept as regards Apocalypto, and at least respect as regards 3:10, though I strongly disagree). On the other hand, equally engaged Catholics have objected to my recommending anything but the most innocuous family fare, even for adult audiences.

A few have doubted whether my reviews are substantially informed by Catholic thinking at all. One Register reader, responding to my 2007 Top 10 (“And the Winner is … Life?” Jan. 20-26), spoke for many when she wrote:

“We feel as though there is a disconnect in the reviews and what we believe as Catholics. Many of the promoted movies are largely flawed with some minor redeeming quality. It seems as though you are saying it’s okay to watch if any part of it has some sort of value, no matter how insignificant. … If we are to look at everything through the lens of our faith should we not critique movies in the same way? We strongly feel that the movies are reviewed on their artistic presentation versus any sort of Christian values.”

I couldn’t agree more about the crucial importance of keeping the faith paramount in all areas of life, including watching and evaluating movies. I don’t insist on absolute perfection, but a good movie must be at least basically wholesome. That’s why I can’t share the Academy’s enthusiasm for No Country, well-made as it is.

Artistic merit can never trump moral and spiritual considerations — a principle I think can easily be seen in my reviews of well-made and acclaimed but morally problematic films like 3:10 to Yuma, Match Point, Brokeback Mountain and The Magdalene Sisters. Moral analysis of films like these, as well as less critically successful films like The Golden Compass and Elizabeth: The Golden Age, is an important part of what I see as my calling.

Recent Register coverage of controversy among Catholics over positive reviews from a Catholic source of one or two of the above-mentioned films rightly highlights the problem of critics overlooking or minimizing important moral issues in films.

At the other end of the spectrum is the approach of a Catholic-run DVD rental service, also recently featured in the Register, which rents only what they deem family-friendly fare, a service for which I hope there is a substantial market. I wish them every success, though I think we disagree about whether there is a place for movies for mature audiences. (Speaking on the phone a while ago with one of the founders, I suggested that they might want to think about carrying some films for older audiences; he replied, “We really want to keep it pure.”)

Perusing their website, it turns out that The Passion of the Christ — a magnificent film for mature viewers, in my view, though not perfect — counts as family-friendly fare, despite its violent and bloody as well as horrifying satanic imagery. On the other hand, Amazing Grace — a Christian-produced, PG-rated biopic about Christian abolitionist William Wilberforce — failed to pass, in his words, the “dog poop test.” He used the vivid metaphor to illustrate how a bit of grossness can ruin otherwise worthy fare, like nasty stuff mixed into cookie dough.

Yet we consume small amounts of impurities all the time; drinking water, for example, contains traces of arsenic. It only has to be pure enough, not totally pure, to be fit for consumption.

Why did Amazing Grace fail? Apparently, according to one founder, the sticky point is not language (several instances of “God” and “hell” as well as “ass,” a “damn” and a couple of N-words) or references to the harsh conditions of slave ships, including rape. Rather, it seems to be: “Cleavage Appropriate to the Times.” (In spite of this, the founder was open to overturning the “dog poop” verdict and adding Amazing Grace with the rating “Parents Decide” — a phrase I personally would avoid, since parents should always decide.)

I point this out, not by way of critique, but simply to highlight that sensibilities among Catholics as to what is appropriate for both children and adults differ greatly, and the same people can find one another too rigorous in some respects and too lax in others.

This doesn’t mean we are completely at sea. The truths of Church teaching on moral and spiritual matters as well as art, culture, entertainment and the whole truth of man offer essential and certain reference points in engaging movies and other forms of culture, art and entertainment. Below are some important principles drawn from Church teaching that are crucial for Catholics in a mass-media culture.

Movies have potential for both good and evil. As early as 1929, Pius XI praised efforts to make worthy films available, while also calling for vigilance regarding immoral films (Divini illius Magistri, No. 90-91). Seven years later, in the first encyclical devoted to film, Pope Pius noted that while bad films are occasions of sin and instill false attitudes toward love, marriage and the family, good films exert a “profoundly moral influence” on viewers and society (Vigilanti Cura, No. 28-29). This has been reiterated by Vatican II (Inter Mirifica, No. 2) and elsewhere.

Moral considerations are paramount in all areas of life, including art and entertainment. Vatican II ringingly affirmed “the absolute primacy of the objective moral order,” which “surpasses and fittingly coordinates all other spheres of human affairs — the arts not excepted — even though they be endowed with notable dignity” (No. 6). The attitude which divorces moral considerations from areas of life such as art and entertainment is incompatible with Catholic faith.

Art and culture — as well as entertainment and diversion — are important human goods in their own right. I can only scratch the surface here. Pius XII praised cinema as both “part of the great gift of art” (Vigilanti Cura, No. 6) and a salutary form of diversion and recreation (No. 21-22).

Vatican II declared that media like movies “greatly contribute to men’s entertainment” among other things, named “culture and the fine arts” as well as spiritual values among the goods served by the media (Inter Mirifica, No. 12), and encouraged efforts to promote “production and showing of films that have value as decent entertainment, humane culture or art” (No. 14). The attitude which sees entertainment, diversion, culture and art as distractions from “more important things” — as if we should spend all our time in spiritual pursuits — is inconsistent with authentic Catholic anthropology. Those who live in the world are not called to be monastic wannabes.

Artistic and technical excellence, as well as moral value, demand the favor of Catholics. Pius XII began his “Discourse on the Ideal Film” with open admiration for the technical and artistic achievements made in the first six decades of cinema. Vatican II taught that “a proper choice demands that [Catholics who use the media] fully favor those presentations that are outstanding for their moral goodness, their knowledge and their artistic or technical merit” (Inter Mirifica, No. 9, italics added).

Good art and entertainment must always be morally sound — but morally sound doesn’t always mean family-friendly or uplifting. Church documents bespeak special concern for youth, who “need a press and entertainment that offer them decent amusement and cultural uplift” (Inter Mirifica, No. 11), but must also be safeguarded from what “may be harmful to them at their age” (No. 12). In making age a factor, the council decree implies a distinction between what is harmful, period, and what may be harmful to children at their age but harmless to adults.

Decent films may deal with disturbing themes and immoral behavior. In his Letter to Artists, Pope John Paul II observed, “Even when they explore the darkest depths of the soul or the most unsettling aspects of evil, artists give voice in a way to the universal desire for redemption” (No. 10).

Not all films worth watching and worth recommending for anyone will appeal to all audiences. The 1995 Vatican film list includes a number of important films that many Register readers might never want to see. But I think informed Catholics ought at least to know about them, and be able to recognize that there may be significant value in something they personally prefer not to see.

In my work, I try to cover both films of widespread appeal to many Register readers as well as some films that not all will want to see, but many may be interested in knowing about. (See my recent review of the Romanian abortion-themed film 4 Months, 3 Weeks and 2 Days, for example.)

No critic can offer a one-size-fits-all approach for all well-formed and properly catechized Catholics. I can’t tell anyone what to think or watch, or make definitive pronouncements about good or bad movies. I’m not the Pope; I’m not even the pope of movies. There is no pope of movies. Even the Pope isn’t the pope of movies.

What I can do, and do my best to do, is this: I try to offer readers a responsible take on every film I see, one informed by serious reflection on Catholic teaching, along with enough information about the film itself and my thought processes in reviewing it to allow readers to arrive at their own conclusions and make an informed choice about whether they want to see it.

I hope my work is a starting point for readers thinking about films, not an ending point telling them what to think. I hope my writing sparks new lines of thought or new ways of looking at films after seeing them. I hope that my efforts to articulate how I look at a film are helpful to others seeking to sharpen their own critical skills.

Also, of course, I hope it’s fun to read — and I hope you find my picks more reliable than the Academy’s.

Register critic Steven D. Greydanus has a master’s degree in religious studies from St. Charles Borromeo Seminary and a bachelor’s in media arts from the School of Visual Arts in New York City.
Source: National Catholic Register - March 2-8, 2008 Issue

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular