celebrex for prostatitis tbr.pl can clomid cause ringworm buy zovirax eye ointment 3 4.5 g trazodone 300 mg for sleep metformin and gastric bypass price of lamisil oilment in india norweco singulair aerator model 206c on sale mobic dosage 50mg starting warfarin without heparin till-landry.com drank wine can i take amitriptyline for sleep phenergan elixir urdu meaning what does doxycycline hyclate 100mg look like floryakurye.com.tr is levaquin better than amoxil what is lisinopril 10 mg used for how much does 600mg of zyvox costs gkminc.com champion-container.com provera ukradenih vozila rantical.com finasteride australia side effects baclofen mankind nexium kegunaannya cialis 20 mg tablet tamoxifen sore feet au eude.es gkris.com pastillas indocin indomethacin 25 mg effects of sildenafil citrate mtm 100 on women sobrietybyyourside.com can you buy otc viagra zantac and levofloxacin using lamisil on cats ultimos estudios finasteride levofloxacin 500 mg en alcohol erythromycin newborn directions ilosone cream brand names over the counter seroquel 50 mg effects on dogs gabapentin side effects half life what is the essence of sildenafil citrate tables azithromycin 4 dollar list buy flagyl dogs does viagra make you horny que contiene citotec aparte de misoprostol cual es la diferencia entre viagra y cialis buying viagra delivered worldwide doxycycline 6 months buspar high nasal diltiazem cd 300 ic amoxicillin 500 for abscess tooth theartofmarketing.com hrg seroquel viagra andnot generic trazodon erectile disfunction cytotec versi indonesia spacecityparent.com pandahomecare.com wilbraham.com how to use misoprostol 4weeks into pregnancy coreg 3 prednisone for 10 days for asthma eu-atp.org photoloco.com disulfiram cost in india sideinfo.com.br dws-xip.pl cipro buy online para perros pastillas para la alergia atarax does zoloft cause emotional numbness shoppers drug mart diflucan zovirax generic dosage what is baclofen called on the streets orlistat slimming tablets centergaz.pl doubleglazingcompanies.com brand levitra erectile dysfunction champion-container.com nolvadex and hdl can i exercise after taking cialis mylan bupropion xl reviews citalopram uk forum how long can you take buspar meth beach in celebrex commercial lisinopril holistic alternatives kidney esomeprazole 3d 14leclub.com will gain weight if taking to much synthroid pediatric amoxicillin dosage for strep throat vibramycin cream doxycycline hyclate and alcohol consumption over the counter substitute for flomax lexapro headache alcohol how can bactrim suspension syrup help my 4months baby buy tadalafil uk online who is brunette in cialis commercial virtualsem.com where to buy roaccutane capsule in malaysia augmentin 625 cost india can u get high on 20 mg baclofen augmentin 875 mg tablets waterfrontalehouse.com thuoc voltaren 50mg dilofenac free sample herbal viagra flagyl aka metronidazole side effects with alcohol synthroid 25mcg side effects of paxil and fosomax taken together rf5.org buy liquid albuterol russianfestival.ie weingutkohl.de jwalkny.com 5x5.hu wedlok.com 8weeks abortion with misoprostol 200 mg metronidazole benzoate oral suspension image kamagra 100 mg oraljelly si ta perdorim coparmex.org.mx liquid tamoxifen for sale harga obat amlodipine besylate aatif.lu que funcion ace el plavix 75mg flagyl and augmentin forte combination lexapro south africa street price for hydroxyzine huafengcreative.com provera tablets price in the philippines kesan pill doxycycline 100mg secretlives.me montelukast 10 mg hapacol la thuoc gi 2buy levitra online viagra escitalopram oxalate 10mg mixing alcohol metronidazole 500 mg how long does it take to work floraphotographs.com SUNNYDUVET.COM chamber.md camerata.com cong dung thuoc phenergan 25mg pret tableta levofloxacin prednisone 20mg dosage for bulging discs propranolol purchase online diarrhea from lisinopril ncsdsample2.docbro.com digoxin cara kerja antibiotics safe for the liver citalopram withdrawal symptoms gums prise 500mg atarax clozapine brand tab cost in usa sertraline 100mg effects fertility amitriptyline and celexa causing weight gain side effects famvir ointment fluoxetine hydrochloride 30 mg oeufspolis.com chamber.md amitriptyline 25 mg get you high floryakurye.com.tr can you buy antibiotics over the counter frace toughfurniture.com thomaskingsleytroupe.com how to taper 30 mg prednisone in 5 days buy gabapentin 800 mg no prescription can you overdose on propranolol and trazodone cymbalta preis ch lamisil cream on polished nails kamagra oral jelly price list torontoems.ca grandcanyonbrewery.com brown tablet erection wordsalamode.com sertraline and levofloxacine interactions ubat fluconazole capsule 150mg difluvid hangover relief. neurontin how many 500mg augmentin to 3 grams topiramate wellbutrin weight loss redzigaismu.lv diffrents between cozaar yellow and cozaar white pill isotretinoin 100mg zithromax 1000mg for chlamydia how do flagyl work in preventing pregnancy famvir drug cat where can i buy nolvadex and proviron in the uk nursing interventions when giving ondansetron montelukast sodium 10 mg tablet cause dark urine all the anxiety pills that make you high prazosin toughfurniture.com eude.es ciprofloxacin 500mg antibiotics treatment snort baclofen 10 mg augmentin 375 mg used does prednisone help tennis elbow levitra generic price corral88.org lexapro and nexium interaction treatment for uti amoxicillin dosage kamagra jelly online indian rupee gauntletpress.com dctourguideonline.com metformin and green stool buy amoxicillin clavulanate erowids vault prednisone niagarajazzfestival.com tadalafil tablets 20mgdapoxetine coumadin coagulopathy icd 9 why does furosemide affect after load buy valsartan hctz do you have to wean from ritalin to switch to strattera ciprofloxacin effects kidneys huafengcreative.com augmentin brands in nigeria clomid 50mg twice a day haciendahotel-oldtown.com how quick does iv lasix work icsliberia.org cardura 2 mg fiyat?± kimlearningcenter.com sweetcheekshq.com cialis mg 50 viagra australia women usian.org who are the innovator of ampicillin should diflucan be taken during period or after misoprostol venta libre en salta what happebens if i take 40mg of cialis in one time hanhvyshop.vn i have been on 5 mg of lexapro for year augmentin 875 for tooth abscess cheap viagra brand indomethacin 25 mg drug interactions interaction colcrys taking with carvedilol 3.125 is it safe to take viagra with ramapril prednisone 5 mg dose pack shingles reciews prednisone for muscle pain tbr.pl ibuprofen vs naproxen gabapentin for dogs side effects overdose cuanto vale el orlistat en wallmart mexico tamsulosin 400 mg side effects mhc-s.com diarea after drinking alcohol on paxil price of longer erection pills in india premarin .625 helps to get pregnant nearion.com buy cheap generic cialis tadalafil can 1500 milligrams of levofloxacin cure chlamydia citalopram 30 mg anxiety estrace generic equivalent cream would .3 clonidine get me high tamoxifen biogaran 20 mg amoxicillin oral suspension and nurofen aasoc.pl can u smoke telmisartan like crack when is it ok to take ten tablets of flagyl onlywebs.us side effects of women taking viagra soleaturk.com fluconazole for dogs no prescription prednisone 5mg side effects generic cialis for daily use rantical.com happyknits.com serviciosarcom.com metronidazole eyelash cream buy uk can doxycycline hyclate end your period clomid price canada dosage of levofloxacin in uti in europe is buspirone like valium fungsi doxycycline hyclate 100 ondansetron ip 4 mg is safe in pregnancy buy famvir online canada theartofmarketing.com online farmasi jual cytotec ciprofloxacin price valacyclovir and bcs bactrim forte breastfeeding can i take a second apo fluconazole will clomid work if i have a 37 day cycle likelihood 25 mg seroquel tardive dyskinesia eu-atp.org valacyclovir salep cymbalta ruined my life waterfrontalehouse.com flomax bambini 400 mg supposte minum obat azithromycin 500 mg furosemide 40 mg and hives mitsuifinearts.com purchase estradiol patch albuterol nebulizer for hyperkalmeia newest antidepressants precedex to clonidine conversion estradiol 79 can i legally buy viagra online in australia mobilfodral.net amoxicillin for uti treatment site:.edu flagyl dan manfaatnya what if i take 50 mg of montelukast how soon can you take another diflucan virtualsem.com esbueno tomar viagra naproxen 750 mg reviews how long does half a pill of levitra work for singulair 4 mg or 5mg valacyclovir 1 gm is that over 500 mg 1001.org azithromycin price per tablet philippines dws-xip.pl onlywebs.us prednisone dose for 14 lb dogs plavix price in uae dubai lexapro patient assistance lexapro 7 months prednisolone alternative without lactose price of azithromycin tablet 1000mg in niveria benazepril hydrochloride australia anemia and bactrim forte movix meloxicam 75 mg fluconazole capsule prices in india taking prozac wellbutrin and depakote does celexa cause gynecomastia coming off of doxazosin does gabapentin and klonopin cause sleepiness loperamide and propranolol buildingsonfire.com tamsulosin hci 0.4 alternativ flagyl make you pregnant in who many weeks groganstudios.com walterbruck.de what antibiotics can i buy over the counter in georgia orlistat uk supply metronidazole side effect and price piroxicam 4mg firsttimetravels.com creasite.fr theweddingdolls.co.uk taking anavar while on propecia brownhousephoto.com hansrajcollege.info side effects of amitriptyline metronidazole in vietnamese revue-pto.com finasteride philippines forums what is the street value of gabapentin 300mg generic cialis online fast shipping 4kom.it gotfi.pl gabapentin300 feels grrear kegunaan dexamethasone viagra 50 adult dosage for ciprotab action of cytotec como tomar el mifepristone misoprostol singulair montelukast 10 mg and treatment for the nerve prezzo voltaren 100g retard dws-xip.pl metronidazole gel costs amitriptyline dog sleepy 272ug ivermectin where to buy flagyl suposetery in south africa durban prometrium 200 mg ovuli chamber.md viagra making it work better lamisil cream and tablet for vagina fungi buy metformin tablets uk blood clots and flagyl is levaquin gluten free does metronidazole vaginal gel cause miscarages nortriptyline pain street value chizeaphockey.com theitrecruiters.com famciclovir tablet alternate in india will bactrim treat bad tooth dry mouth on ciprofloxacin eu-atp.org buy diflucan for dogs without a rx inovaclub.com.mx contraceptive ethinyl estradiol desogestrel rape dose metoprolol 736 menafilmfest.com synthroid 300 mcg photoloco.com habitat.tj dexamethasone acetate tablets haciendahotel-oldtown.com generic lexapro best prices turystykawinternecie.pl can trazodone cause bloodshot eyes and small pupils metoprolol er 25 mg side effects marontech.com.my coupon para diovan 80 mg generic viagra houston tx finasteride 1 mg.co.in para que sirve la crema piroxicam gel vpdcorp.com farmacia donde puedo conseguir cytotec tepic nayarit is it safe to use flagylpill during your period km-kh.com famciclovirpara q s usa vitaroom.net nexium 40 rates online without a prescription zithromax for dogs how much is too much prazosin to snort para que sirve el metoprolol er 50 mg springracinginsights.com micardis hct and perrier escitalopram omega 3 misoprostol dosage 27 weeks 15 mg buspirone high accidental overdose of metoprolol sandoz green tea and soy and propecia together gratisdiscotecas.com buy amoxicillin line twentynineinches-de.com zoloft 100mg vs 50mg how does one know clomiphene citrate pills worked wife is happy with cialis can i take acyclovir during first trimester q2melbourne.com ive taken 250mg of sildenafil teva tablets kmmvin.eu azithromycin chlamydia treatment g.e. escitalopram vs lexapro buspirone used for opiate withdrawal katartisi-pnai.gr pfizer viagra online uk prazosin pdf finasteride in hinde can you take amoxicillin and diclofenac together audiomaximus.com la amoxil para que sirve sekerpinarosgb.com theisod.org prazosin 8 mg dosage ivermectin25 lb dig scabies can lopressor cause low platelets bactrim ds uti length of infection flagyl forte 500 adalah how long to get topiramate out of system albuterol cycle side effects monikagawor.pl corsidoppiaggio.com newworldfoods.ca himax vs viagra prozac topimax alcohol interaction cialis 75mg shampoo dengan ketoconazole siwe.be finasteride 1mg side effect chest pain cuatro meses tomando finasteride schwanderinsurance.com ebusiness-lab.gr fluconazole for dogs probiotic redzigaismu.lv gestodene 75 mcg ethinyl estradiol 20 mcg fluoxetine after 3 weeks bociansafaris.com duloxetine bioequivalence schwanderinsurance.com dermo care terbinafine dusting powder como tomar sildenafil con alcohol do people sell atarax on the streets horners.org.uk actionoftablet rupatadineandmontelukast if you take cialis twice a day misoprostol contraindications xenical sold in stores lbc4help.org side effects of lisinopril stada 5 mg sevban.com rantical.com citalopram 60mg daily bad yahoo sertraline hcl 100 mg street value accutane without birth control pill cd37 clomid filmarray.com vancomycin tablets and linezolid wordsalamode.com habitat.tj canadian ketoconazole shampoo 2 perrigo seroquel vs sinogan tbr.pl what is the target tissue of thyroxine viagra for what purpose is being used clomid cycle day 13 and peeing a lot edgewaterstudio.com mobile-pharma.com amoxicillin for herpes stomatitis viagra rogain online sales verapamil cost firsttimetravels.com supplements while on coumadin probiotics iv to po lasix bupropion generic price ir thesoundalarm.com free viagra without prescription fexofenadine and montelukast combination cheap generic do fluconazole 150 mg work for oral thrush buy single dose azithromycin buy ondansetron wafers 283858.com estradiol ii e411

The Failure of Speculative Capitalism

Catholic moral and social teaching tell us that a financial system that purposely channels greed into speculation and usury, rather than into productive investment, is inherently irrational and unstable. A collapse was inevitable.
by Angelo Matera | Source: NCRegister.com

Since the global financial crisis began in September, stock markets around the world have careened hundreds of points up and down almost every day, sometimes within just a few hours.

Investors are nervous, uncertain about the future, wondering whether tomorrow will mark the start of a recovery or the beginning of a disastrous depression. So they buy or sell on a whim. Such is the irrationality of our financial markets.

What’s happening? How can a trillion dollars of company value be created or destroyed in just a day? What caused the financial meltdown in the first place? While the media blames good old-fashioned greed, the reasons are more complex, involving financial practices that constitute a “structure of sin.”

Catholic moral and social teaching tell us that a financial system that purposely channels greed into speculation and usury, rather than into productive investment, is inherently irrational and unstable. A collapse was inevitable.

Put simply, usury is lending money at punitively high interest rates, and speculation is high-risk investing that is actually a form of gambling. From the Catechism of the Catholic Church to the social encyclicals issued by popes going back to Leo XIII in the 19th century, the Church has recognized usury and speculation as harmful forms of lending and investment (the Church is not alone — most civil governments have laws against excessive interest rates and “Ponzi” investments schemes. The FBI recently arrested Bernie Madoff for running his much-heralded investment fund as an actual “Ponzi” scheme for two decades. His investors stand to lose $50 billion).

These dangers are clearly understood in Europe because of its Catholic heritage. When European leaders met several months ago, they blamed “speculative capitalism” for the crisis. French President Nicolas Sarkozy contrasted the difference between real productivity and speculation when he said: “We want a capitalism of entrepreneurs. We don’t want speculators.”

This distinction echoes what Pope John Paul II said, in his encyclical on the dignity of work, Centesimus Annus:

“Ownership of the means of production, whether in industry or agriculture, is just and legitimate if it serves useful work. It becomes illegitimate, however, when it is not utilized or when it serves to impede the work of others in an effort to gain a profit which is not the result of the overall expansion of work and the wealth of society, but rather is the result of curbing them or of illicit exploitation, speculation or the breaking of solidarity among working people. Ownership of this kind has no justification and represents an abuse in the sight of God and humanity.”

This is not a pie-in-the sky critique. The most influential American critic of stock speculation is Warren Buffet, one of the richest men in the world and considered by many to be the most successful investor ever. The Tao of Warren Buffet (2006), a book authored by Mary Buffet and David Clark, is filled with his scathing criticism of investment firms for focusing on short-term results:

“The trading madness that goes with the mutual and hedge funds is almost boundless … if there is even the slightest drop in earnings, they will sell the stock, and if there is even a modest rise in earnings, they buy it. … This is not investing; it is speculating under the guise of investing. Investing is buying a piece of a business and watching it grow; speculating is throwing the dice on the short-term direction of the stock’s price.”

This speculative mentality is at the root of the current crisis: Beginning in the 1980s, laws and regulations enacted after the Great Depression to restrict dangerous and unproductive speculation were peeled away in the name of “deregulation.”

As a result, investment banks, hedge funds, private equity firms and other speculators, operating without any oversight and looking for outsized profits for themselves and for investor clients not satisfied with merely average rates of return on their money, were able to invest trillions and trillions of dollars in ever more complex and opaque financial instruments, turning the stock and credit markets into a monstrously high-risk, high-leverage, financial casino.

When the subprime mortgage market (mortgages issued at high interest rates to people who were poor credit risks) ran into problems last year due to the end of the housing boom and other reasons having to do with fraud and usurious practices, it started a chain reaction that now threatens to bring the whole shaky structure crashing down. (For the most detailed, definitive analysis of the crisis, see Charles Morris’ The Trillion Dollar Meltdown.)

Like sex outside the generative context of marriage, making money through speculation — gambling on price increases caused by luck, mass psychology, or some other arbitrary reason — is a form of mutual exploitation, a zero-sum game where winners gain at the expense of losers. In real business, profit is the result of something else; it comes from “creating a customer,” in the words of the late, great management guru Peter Drucker.

When we consider our slowly declining standard of living, we should consider Drucker’s prescient observation about Wall Street, as cited in a 1999 article in The New York Times during the height of the Internet stock market “bubble”:

“Typically, Dr. Drucker gave the global bankers the back of his hand: They have introduced not ‘a single major innovation in 30 years,’ he said. Rather, the financial industry has turned inward to perfecting ‘supposedly scientific derivatives,’ in a shortsighted hope of wringing the risk out of financial speculation, like Las Vegas gamblers who futilely try to devise ‘systems’ to beat the house.”

Or, as Warren Buffett concisely put it, “… according the name investors to institutions that trade actively is like calling someone who repeatedly engages in one-night stands a romantic.”

Ironically, like “safe sex,” safe speculation has proved to be an illusion. 

Angelo Matera is publisher and editor of GodSpy.com

Click Here to Donate Now!

Join the new media evangelization. Your tax-deductible gift allows Catholic.net to build a culture of life in our nation and throughout the world. Please help us promote the Church's new evangelization by donating to Catholic.net right now. God bless you for your generosity.




Post a Comment
Write a comment on this article

Email required (will not be published)
required Country

Most Popular